Best Cotton Sheets for the Dreamiest Night’s Sleep Possible

Brooklinen is a newer brand and a favorite of discerning shoppers, particularly when it comes to its original product, i.e., sheets. (The brand has also made our lists for the best places to buy bedding, best duvet covers, and best bath towels.) The core sheet sets combine premium fibers with tasteful colors, at accessible prices. Although not the cheapest product on the list, the classic percale set is the most affordable core sheet bundle that Brooklinen sells, but it doesn’t compromise on customer satisfaction. These sheets offer the crispness usually associated with quality percale, but also retain a smoothness on the skin. With 18 colorways to choose from, there’s something for every aesthetic and every bedroom—you may even want to buy a few.

There are some real gems among Amazon’s vast selection of bedsheets and the California Design Dex Luxury Sateen Sheet Set is a true diamond. With many sizes available for under $50, these sheets are some of the most affordable options on the market if you’re looking for 100% cotton. California Design Den uses a sateen weave for a softer finish that reviewers love, although it might be missing some of the luxurious quality of higher-end brands. Shoppers can choose from 41 color variations, but double check that the one you like is available in the size you need. Fortunately, every sheet set offers natural temperature regulation and easy laundering, no matter which color you choose.

Egyptian cotton is a prized fiber due to its extra-long length and smaller diameter, which allows for smoother yarn and therefore smoother fabrics. You can really sense the fiber’s unparalleled breathability and moisture-wicking properties in this percale sheet set from Parachute, which uses 100% long-staple Egyptian cotton. (The set also made our list of the best percale sheets you can buy online.) It’s ideal for hot sleepers, warm climates or summertime sleeping and comes in a palette of ten beautifully muted colors, for a really elegant addition to any bedroom. The basic sheet set doesn’t include a top sheet and prices can be a little high when adding one to the bundle, but that makes sense when you’re buying such quality materials.

Supima is an American-grown Pima cotton that is valued for being extra-long, accounting for just 1% of cotton grown in the world. As such, this high end fiber creates premium sheets and this is especially true in the case of the L.L. Bean Pima Cotton Percale Sheet Set. The 280-thread count sheets have a percale weave that creates a crisp, cooling effect balanced with a luxuriously smooth feel on the skin. The nine colors available are not the most modern shades, but they do include classic neutrals and every sheet set features both a flat and fitted sheet. These sheets are a great price for the quality they offer and are sure to keep sleepers cool and comfortable night after night.

Lands’ End Premium Supima Cotton Sateen Bed Sheets combine a high thread count of 400 with quality fibers for a truly indulgent bedding set. Using only 100% American-grown Supima cotton for this product, Lands’ End highlights the reduced environmental impact of its manufacturing and the premium texture of its material. The sateen weave also ensures a silkier feel and cozier night’s sleep than a regular cotton or percale style sheet. You will need to pay more for these sheets, but you’ll be rewarded with a machine washable, iron-free set that has a pressed appearance straight from the dryer for at least 30 washes. They’ll last you so long, Lands’ End even provides the option to get them monogrammed for a true luxury experience.

This sheet set from Better Homes & Gardens uses HygroCotton, a yarn made from 100% cotton fiber that has a hollow core to improve breathability. HygroCotton also softens over time, creating bed sheets that only grow more comfortable as you use them, similar to linen. The result is this sheet set, which balances the freshness of cotton with a cozier feel and comes in a color mix of neutrals, brights, and prints. This is all the more impressive when you consider the affordability of these sheets; a King set includes a fitted sheet, top sheet, and two King pillowcases, yet still comes in at under $65. While not as luxurious or cooling as the percale cotton options on this list, this is a great choice for anyone who doesn’t want to spend too much and values comfort over crispness.

One of the reasons shoppers opt for cotton percale is because they’re looking for sheets that will help them keep cool during the night. We’ve found that Riley Home’s Cotton Percale Sheets are some of the coolest around, thanks to their premium long-staple cotton fibers that mirror an expensive dress shirt. Reminiscent of luxury hotel sheets, this set comes in a limited range of expensive-looking neutrals (although only neutrals) with the option to add a top sheet for an additional price. Even though these sheets are made of high-quality fibers, they are still suitable for machine washing and will even soften over time for a more indulgent, yet still crisp feeling.

Coyuchi has managed to retain the lightweight crispness of percale, but enhance the softness of the cotton with its Organic Crinkled Percale Sheets. These sets are all made from 100% organic-certified cotton, as well as being certified by GOTS, Fair Trade, 1% For the Planet, and Made Safe, so customers can feel confident their purchase is as environmentally friendly as possible. The collection includes a range of warm shades that are quite uncommon for bedding, including ginger and hazel tones, so this is a good choice for people whose aesthetic leans warmer. The slightly crinkled effect may not be to everyone’s taste and these sheets begin at a higher price point, but they’re designed to soften over time and become more comfortable with use, which makes them a worthy investment.

When you’re buying a set of high quality sheets that you plan to use every night, you want to be sure that they’ll last, especially if you’re spending a decent amount. Parachute’s Brushed Cotton Sheet Set balances the best of percale with the best of sateen for a perfect middle option that will stand up over time. The 100% cotton sheets use a regular weave that is then rubbed with metal brushes to fluff the fibers and increase softness, while retaining coolness and breathability. This makes brushed cotton a great choice year-round, so it needs to hold up well. Fortunately, it does: Repeated use doesn’t result in pilling as long as the sheets are treated properly and this is easily done, as Parachute sheets are machine washable.

Cotton doesn’t always need to be crisp–in fact, it can be indulgently soft, as is the case with Cuddledown’s Solid Sateen Sheet Set. Made of 100% cotton which is then combed for extra smoothness, these sheets have a sateen weave which gives a cozier, heavyweight feeling than percale. The result is a deliciously soft fabric that’s perfect for anyone who prefers a silky, warm night’s sleep. Although these sheet sets start at over $200, this includes a top sheet and every product has been shrinkage controlled and made wrinkle-resistant, so that maintenance is minimal once you’ve brought them home. If you become a fan of this style, keep in mind that the large range of 21 block colors has been designed to complement the brand’s printed sateen duvet covers.

A high thread count doesn’t guarantee quality, but it is a good way to learn more about bedding. Thread count refers to the tightness of a fabric’s weave, with a higher count meaning a tighter weave and therefore a smoother, more insulating fabric. High thread count sheets are prized for their softness and warmth and The Citizenry’s Organic Resort Cotton Sheet Set is no exception. With a luxurious drape, a soft, but breathable feel and a silky finish that mattifies tastefully over time, it’s no wonder that these sheets are one of the most expensive in this guide. Sets come in a limited range of five neutral colors, but the benefit is that all of The Citizenry’s bedding is designed to mix and match, so if you like these, you’ll be able to overhaul the rest of your bedding in complementary shades. Shopping tip: For more organic options, check out our round up of the best organic sheets.

Cashmere is the ultimate in cozy sweaters, so it makes sense that it would lend itself to wonderfully soft bedding for colder weather. The Brooklinen Heathered Cashmere Core Sheet Set combines Himalayan cashmere with 95% cotton to create balanced bedding that keeps sleepers cozy, but not overheated. The lightweight fabric has an attractive textured finish thanks to the heathering process and is available only in neutral shades. The soft yet breathable material feels expensive–and indeed it is, topping our list with prices beginning at over $300. All the same, those willing to spend on cashmere will know how worthwhile it can be.