How the Great Sandwich War of 1958 Changed the Way We Eat

4 minute read

“When is a sandwich not a sandwich?” asked the intrepid reporters at TIME in April of 1958. As more recent battles over the sandwich-status of the burrito have demonstrated, the question has never been an easy one to answer. (Spoiler: a burrito, according to the United States government in 2006, is in fact not a sandwich.) But more than a half-century ago, the age-old query came with a twist, as the debate raged at 30,000 ft. above the Atlantic.

It was the dawn of the Jet Age, the era when commercial airlines were making air travel accessible to the common man for the first time. But, as it turned out, not that accessible: tickets for Trans-Atlantic routes in the existing First and Tourist classes were, in many cases, prohibitively expensive. So, in an effort to democratize the skies, and to sell more tickets, the airline companies introduced the now all-too-familiar and cheaper “Economy Class” on its trans-Atlantic flights.

Afraid that unbridled competition between carriers would jeopardize the safety and quality of flights for travelers, the International Air Transport Association (IATA) tightly regulated the airline industry at the time. As a result, fares and seating configurations on these new “Austerity” flights, which debuted on April 1, 1958, were standardized across companies. So was the menu airlines were allowed to serve: coffee, tea, mineral water and a few “simple, cold, and inexpensive” sandwiches.

These directions seemed simple enough at first. Then came the sandwiches.

It quickly became clear that different airlines had different interpretations of the word—and that those differences were enough to shake the very foundations of international goodwill.

The first camp was led by the North Americans PanAm and Trans World Airways, which both served up typical American-style sandwiches, such as egg salad, roast beef, or ham and cheese layered between two thick slices of bread.

Their opposition presented sandwiches in the open-faced, European-style. Menus on Scandinavian Air Systems (SAS) flights consisted of items like “five slices of ox tongue, a lettuce heart, asparagus and sliced carrots—on a slice of bread” while Swiss Air provided guests with two dessert sandwiches, “perhaps peach on Zweiback,” after they had finished their assortment of twelve dainty appetizer sandwiches and primary sandwich. KLM Royal Dutch Airlines and Air France too served up similarly extravagant selections.

Needless to say, PanAm and TWA were not pleased with the sumptuous sandwich affairs of the European carriers. Their sandwiches amounted to a three-course meal on bread, the North Americans claimed, a level of luxury that was contrary to the ideals of economy class—and which might sway customers’ airline choices. A spokesman for SwissAir declared in response, “everyman is entitled to his concept of a sandwich and we have ours.” The company, in turn, would “defend [its] sandwiches to the end.”

As the weeks progressed, the discord only continued to grow, with SAS publishing a sales letter declaring to its potential customers, “on our planes you won’t find rubbery indigestibles wrapped in cellophane.” American carriers responded with threats to banish European airlines from American airspace.

As the media latched on to the mounting absurdity of “the Great Sandwich War of 1958,” the IATA stepped in, convening a special meeting in London to determine once and for all what constituted a sandwich in the friendly skies.

To the disappointment of sandwich aficionados everywhere, the IATA sided with PanAm. According to their ruling, a sandwich must be “cold… simple… unadorned… inexpensive,” and must “consist of a substantial and visible chunk of bread.” Any materials “normally regarded as expensive or luxurious, such as smoked salmon, oysters, caviar, lobster, game, asparagus, pate de foie gras,” as well as “overgenerous or lavish helpings which affect the money value of the unit” were prohibited as well. Although most European carriers escaped the affair unscathed, SAS was slapped with a $20,000 fine for its blasphemous slander of indigestibles wrapped in cellophane.

It wasn’t until the deregulation of the airlines in the 1970s that menus started to change and creativity, for better and for worse, returned to the bill of fare for Economy Class. SAS today still serves up sandwiches on its flights, but with demand for cheaper fares overpowering in-flight service, it’s now often up to economy customers to purchase those meals themselves. Although the skies are now indeed more accessible to all, sometimes the current state of dining at 30,000 feet is enough to make one miss the good old days of the Sandwich Wars.

The War on Delicious and 19 Other TIME Magazine Food Covers

The War on Delicious Bacon Time Magazine Cover
TIME Photo-Illustration. Bacon: Donald Erickson–Getty Images
June 23, 2014
The June 23, 2014, cover of TIMEPhotograph by Mitchell Feinberg for TIME
Dec. 3, 2012
The Dec. 3, 2012, cover of TIMECover Credit: PHOTOGRAPH BY DWIGHT ESCHLIMAN FOR TIME. FOOD STYLING BY KEVIN CRAFTS.
Sep. 12, 2011
The Sep. 12, 2011, cover of TIMECover Credit: PHOTOGRAPH BY BARTHOLOMEW COOKE FOR TIME
Aug. 31, 2009
The Aug. 31, 2009, cover of TIMECover Credit: PHOTOGRAPH FOR TIME BY BILL KALIS. INSETS, FROM LEFT: SAUL LOEB/AFP/GETTY; JOHN UELAND FOR TIME.
Mar. 12, 2007
The Mar. 12, 2007, cover of TIMECover Credit: PHOTOGRAPH BY ERIC ANTHONY JOHNSON/STOCKFOOD
May 3, 2004
The May 3, 2004, cover of TIMECover Credit: AARON GOODMAN
Oct. 20, 2003
The Oct. 20, 2003, cover of TIMECover Credit: AARON GOODMAN
Sep. 2, 2002
The Sep. 2, 2002, cover of TIMETIME
July 15, 2002
The July 15, 2002, cover of TIMETIME
Nov. 1, 1999
The Nov. 1, 1999, cover of TIMETIME
Jan. 8, 1996
The Jan. 8, 1996, cover of TIMECover Credit: MICHAEL EASTMAN & CLARK KINCAID
July 15, 1991
The July 15, 1991, cover of TIMECover Credit: MATTHEW KLEIN
Mar. 27, 1989
The Mar. 27, 1989, cover of TIMECover Credit: MATTHEW KLEIN
Aug. 26, 1985
The Aug. 26, 1985, cover of TIMECover Credit: MATTHEW KLEIN
Mar. 26, 1984
The Mar. 26, 1984, cover of TIMECover Credit: ANDREW UNANGST
Mar. 15, 1982
The Mar. 15, 1982, cover of TIMETIME
Aug. 10, 1981
The Aug. 10, 1981, cover of TIMECover Credit: HENRY WOLF
Dec. 19, 1977
The Dec. 19, 1977, cover of TIMETIME
Dec. 18, 1972
The Dec. 18, 1972, cover of TIMECover Credit: ROB CRANDALL

More Must-Reads from TIME

Contact us at letters@time.com