data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1f8b2/1f8b20d519cbe41c749675a0c0d2cd3213ece5ba" alt="James Boyd, Keith Sandy James Boyd, Keith Sandy"
In March 2014, two Albuquerque cops shot and killed a homeless man following a prolonged standoff in the foothills of New Mexico’s Sandia Mountains. It was an incident that could have easily become another instance of a police-related death without enough evidence to bring about formal charges against the cops involved. But a police body camera caught the entire confrontation on video, providing prosecutors the evidence needed to file formal charges—and perhaps launching a new era of increased prosecutions against cops thanks to the growth of wearable cameras nationwide.
Kari Brandenburg, the district attorney for New Mexico’s Bernalillo County, filed murder charges Monday against Keith Sandy and Dominique Perez, the two Albuquerque officers who were involved in the death of James Boyd, a homeless man with a history of mental illness who was camping in the mountain’s foothills. It was an open murder charge against both officers, which will let prosecutors decide whether to pursue manslaughter, first- or second-degree convictions.
MORE 2 Albuquerque Officers Charged With Murder in Shooting of Homeless Man
In video released last spring by the Albuquerque Police Department and recorded with a helmet cam used by one of the officers, Boyd is first shown arguing with police before a flashbang goes off. Officers then fire at Boyd as he appears to turn away from police. Boyd, who was carrying two knives, can be heard wheezing on the video as he’s being apprehended before he died. An autopsy later showed that Boyd had been shot twice.
“The video is instrumental in pointing out some of the issues in the investigation,” Brandenburg says, adding that the recording provides prosecutors with probable cause in a case that otherwise wouldn’t have it.
Advocates of body cameras often argue that recordings of officers on duty provide more transparency regarding police behavior and could even alter that behavior because officers know they’re being recorded. In Rialto, Calif., for instance, the police department began using body-worn cameras a few years ago, and its police chief often touts numbers showing that use-of-force complaints have decreased since officers began using them.
But experts say cameras might have an additional side effect: more prosecutions of cops involved in civilian deaths.
“Body cams should increase the number of criminal cases brought against police officers,” says Paul Butler, a Georgetown law professor and former federal prosecutor.
Oftentimes one of the barriers to prosecuting officers, Butler says, is that trials turn into “credibility contests” between police officers and civilians. But video evidence can go a long way to clearing up discrepancies about what happened while giving prosecutors additional evidence to move forward in a case.
MORE ‘Ferguson’ is 2014’s Name of the Year
“When there is doubt, people believe the police over civilians, especially when the civilians are suspects in some kind of criminal conduct,” Butler says. “Knowing this, prosecutors are often reluctant to bring charges against police officers, even when the prosecutors themselves believe the officers are guilty.
Many police departments around the U.S. have started using body worn cameras following the death of Michael Brown, an unarmed black teenager killed last year by a white police officer in Ferguson, Mo. No video recording of that incident exists, and witnesses disagreed on the circumstances surrounding the confrontation between Brown and Officer Darren Wilson. Brown’s parents have been advocating for police departments to adopt cameras nationwide, believing that video recording of their son’s encounter with Wilson could’ve helped bring grand jury charges against the officer.
But cameras have their limitations. The fatal confrontation between Eric Garner and New York City officer Daniel Pantaleo, who placed the Staten Island man in a chokehold in July, was all caught on video by a bystander. Yet a grand jury still decided against bringing murder charges against the officer.
“The increased use of cameras both by agencies and by citizens will make it easier for prosecutors and defense lawyers to get a sense of what happened in a fraught encounter,” says Columbia University law professor Dan Richman. “The cases brought against officers may be stronger and the decisions not to charge may be easier. Still, the controversy surrounding the death of Eric Garner highlights how filmed encounters can be deeply contested.”
Justin Hansford, a Saint Louis University law professor, says he doesn’t believe more body cameras will necessarily equal more prosecutions because the definition of what constitutes use of force in most states are still weighted heavily in favor of police officers.
“The problems we’ve seen in places like Ferguson are not with the amount of evidence but with the laws themselves,” Hansford says. “When you think hard about use of force standards, officers have so much leeway that you have only a few outliers in terms of cases where prosecutions can go forward because of the laws really going above and beyond what is reasonable.”
Hansford argues that an increase in police prosecutions could come from a change in those standards, not in more body cameras.
“The harm of the body cam is that people think it solves everything,” he says.
See 23 Key Moments From Ferguson
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2ed5e/2ed5e2c2be8f0d4ac64ae7f2dd17c98fef370372" alt="Police Shooting Missouri Police Shooting Missouri"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c09c0/c09c0984c81d0b3f111e64be9b823acfa2ab12de" alt="APTOPIX Police Shooting Missouri APTOPIX Police Shooting Missouri"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/22098/22098489e18a3e4ae9ca6500fdd7f81cb473b152" alt="Police Shooting Missouri Police Shooting Missouri"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/32b26/32b2662f9e9589f01c2362a70e258811b1d37c2c" alt="Police move in to detain a protester in Ferguson, Mo. Police move in to detain a protester in Ferguson, Mo."
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3e262/3e2627d0b4704ea524b4de36320c1a6f77de8099" alt="Missouri Police Shooting Missouri Police Shooting"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/82c5a/82c5ad993ca139d90201c1717d39bceb8f54607a" alt="TEAR GAS SHOT AT PROTESTORS TEAR GAS SHOT AT PROTESTORS"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/28486/284860777ed8ecdf7045989b8a6a7eaa20dfce93" alt="Johnson of the Missouri Highway Patrol addresses the media in Ferguson, Missouri Johnson of the Missouri Highway Patrol addresses the media in Ferguson, Missouri"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/83edc/83edc1a713e1ad605c286d602202d8fa1c8eeb34" alt="Darren Wilson Darren Wilson"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d0456/d04560d2cb56a93e0b879a1d7e125fd9f8da48bc" alt="Outrage In Missouri Town After Police Shooting Of 18-Yr-Old Man Outrage In Missouri Town After Police Shooting Of 18-Yr-Old Man"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/79b74/79b74105ff9bd8d2cdb220a6bc3b4644252c7754" alt="Missouri race riot Missouri race riot"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5484d/5484df3e1ac7bdd26f4fdabc3a769ddac736011e" alt="US-CRIME-RACE-POLICE-SHOOTING US-CRIME-RACE-POLICE-SHOOTING"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e762e/e762e5b8e3a329d387cedbb9adf3b918e47ac25c" alt="National Guard Called In As Unrest Continues In Ferguson National Guard Called In As Unrest Continues In Ferguson"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b3fba/b3fbad287f307a0483ccab0aa3f356a71ad1a010" alt="Michael Brown Sr, yells out as his son's casket is lowered into the ground at St. Peter's Cemetery in St. Louis Michael Brown Sr, yells out as his son's casket is lowered into the ground at St. Peter's Cemetery in St. Louis"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b87b6/b87b67341afc9548d362a78c20b6887efee94381" alt="Rally Held in Ferguson Over Police Killing Of Michael Brown Rally Held in Ferguson Over Police Killing Of Michael Brown"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3d6cf/3d6cfb546dbd8bf5ae599ec8a1d8f757aec462d4" alt="Police Shooting Missouri Memorial Police Shooting Missouri Memorial"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/eedbc/eedbcfe5306b711b4cfcb90cecac0a98627c2ec3" alt="Protesters call for resignation of Ferguson police chief Protesters call for resignation of Ferguson police chief"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b5362/b536242d3af8a5ca8e1acc72ac39a6125c0cee13" alt="Activists Protest For Justice After Police Shootings Ferguson St. Louis Protests"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ffa79/ffa799bea287e0ed5d6c848de747c3c87a07ba75" alt="Cornel West Cornel West"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5832b/5832baf31ccd41b1afe58cd16f342d376113c8c4" alt="UN Committee Against Torture UN Committee Against Torture"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5303e/5303e37004ffb1d830f71a8b2703f6fa44828eb5" alt="A police car burns on the street after a grand jury returned no indictment in the shooting of Michael Brown in Ferguson, Missouri A police car burns on the street after a grand jury returned no indictment in the shooting of Michael Brown in Ferguson, Missouri"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/dad8a/dad8ab972a25687298dd5d5108d79a9d695a2405" alt="Eric Holder Eric Holder"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5f10a/5f10a6d11eaad4501619e11c32c88a08a6a0a5f1" alt="Outrage In Missouri Town After Police Shooting Of 18-Yr-Old Man Outrage In Missouri Town After Police Shooting Of 18-Yr-Old Man"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1e63f/1e63fcbffb02880abed5a3c78a0084670c4f2bca" alt="Police officers respond to a fellow officer hit by gunfire outside the Ferguson Police Headquarters in Ferguson Police officers respond to a fellow officer hit by gunfire outside the Ferguson Police Headquarters in Ferguson"
More Must-Reads from TIME
- Inside Elon Musk’s War on Washington
- Meet the 2025 Women of the Year
- The Harsh Truth About Disability Inclusion
- Why Do More Young Adults Have Cancer?
- Colman Domingo Leads With Radical Love
- How to Get Better at Doing Things Alone
- Cecily Strong on Goober the Clown
- Column: The Rise of America’s Broligarchy
Contact us at letters@time.com