Two Inexpensive Books About a Thrifty Man
There is a great difference between writing of the journey of a man to the South Seas, and setting down the travels of a commuter along the daily paths, in this case, of politics. That is why it is difficult to write a biography of Calvin Coolidge. But at the end of only a few months of his Administration, there are now two books on Mr. Coolidge.
One of these,* subtitled His First Biography, is by a Massachusetts politician who served in the Massachusetts legislature with the now President. The other†, called A Contemporary Estimate, is by the political columnist of the Boston Herald. Both are in the nature of biographies. Both suffer from the fact that Mr. Coolidge has never been at pains to provide good material for a Boswell or a Macaulay, and hardly less from the lack of a true Boswell or Macaulay.
Recognizing the scantiness of material, Mr. Washburn sought to clothe his skeleton facts both in the flesh of anecdote and in the drapery of buncombe. He has not forgotten the tricks of his political trade, the “lofty” theme, the “lively” wit. A few examples:
“There stood by the child’s cradle one great and powerful, Fate. . . . Her protecting arm she raised above him. She took him by the hand and ever led him on. . . . She commissioned into the service a good and a great merchant of Boston. . . . She commanded striking policemen to open a path before him. A great Police Commissioner gave wings to his feet. . . . She set him in the seats of the mighty. Even Death rode on before him and cleared the way.”
“He knows the plain people. He thus conserves their rights. He is one of them. It has been said that God loves the plain people most because He made so many of them.”
“On one occasion, [as a boy] for some undetermined reason, having been found at a village dance … his grandmother, who was one of the old school, whatever that may mean, rewarded his virtue with one dollar.”
“While many of the boys of today are feverishly putting on the golf green, Cal was happy in pursuing to its lair the sportive potato. . . . He early became an adept in divorcing the lowing herd which winds slowly o’er the lea from the raw material which makes for butter and cheese.”
“The courtship of Coolidge was unique. . . . He laid much confidence on the power of propinquity, sitting and silence. . . . When the hour ripened for action, he gently spread a kerchief upon the carpeted floor on Maple Street. . . . He confided to her alone that Fate had pointed to the Presidency for him. . . . She replied in a monosyllable: ‘Yes.’ . . . Asked once by a representative of the press for the romance of her marriage, Grace Goodhue Coolidge replied: ‘Have you ever seen my husband?’ . . . If Grace Anna Goodhue Coolidge has ever deplored her decision, she has had too much loyalty to the President to betray it.”
“A wise old owl lived in an oak;
The more he saw, the less he spoke.
The less he spoke, the more he heard;
Why can’t we be like that old bird?”
(Motto over the Coolidge fireplace in Northampton.)
“No lines are more significant in explaining Calvin Coolidge than these which follow:
“One day he came in here, and after sitting where you are for the longest time, he said, out of a clear sky: ‘Do you know, I’ve never really grown up? It’s a hard thing for me to play this game. In politics, one must meet people, and that’s not easy for me.’ ”
“He has had as little newspaper notice as any man of his prominence. This has been because he has avoided it. … His political strength is largely because the public have been curious to study the personality of the only man of that kind they have seen. . . He is a student of political economy. . . . He is a student of philosophy.”
“He now holds the highest office on earth by virtue of a title greater than that of any electorate. God made him President.”
The book of Mr. Whiting, while bearing evidence of more painstaking accuracy, is also witness to the fact that at times a journalist can be less interesting than a politician. One suspects an industrious correspondent of poring over back newspaper files and making a conscientious if uninspired summary. At times he is distressingly literal and like Mr. Washburn submits frequent homilies on the humbler virtues. He does not vapor, however, about the broodings of Fate. Some extracts:
“Calvin Coolidge has been called a second Lincoln.’ He is not. There is no second Lincoln. Abraham Lincoln was distinctively an individual. … If Mr. Coolidge, by his keen common-sense and his accurate perceptions, recalls in any way the figure of Lincoln, that is as far as the suggestion can carry.”
“When he went to the state Legislature he took a letter of introduction to the Speaker of the House: ‘. . . Like the singed cat, he is better than he looks.'”
“It will not pass unnoticed that at this stage of his career Mr. Coolidge was actively interested in some very ‘liberal’ legislation. The antimonopoly bill certainly represented the antithesis of standpattism; so also, the anti-discrimination bill; and so particularly the anti-injunction bill, which he effectively championed on the floor of the House. We may properly repeat here a line of comment from the Northampton Daily Herald of April 24, 1908, which said: ‘Mr. Coolidge is entitled to the thanks of the wage laborers of his district for his manly defense of their interests.'”
“To say that but for the [Boston police] strike Mr. Coolidge would not have attained national position is idle. We do not know what would have happened; but we may fairly suppose that those qualities which were and are his would have found manifestation sooner or later in some way that would capture the attention of the country.”
There are the two existing summaries of Calvin Coolidge. As biographies they have their limitations. They tell the outstanding facts. Both are favorable to the President. But he remains a tough nut for his biographers to crack; they have not the leverage of distance.
*CALVIN COOLIDGE — R. M. Washburn — Small, Maynard ($1.50).
†PRESiDENT COOLIDGE—Edward Elwell Whiting—Atlantic Monthly Press ($1.50).
More Must-Reads from TIME
- Inside Elon Musk’s War on Washington
- Meet the 2025 Women of the Year
- Why Do More Young Adults Have Cancer?
- Colman Domingo Leads With Radical Love
- 11 New Books to Read in Februar
- How to Get Better at Doing Things Alone
- Cecily Strong on Goober the Clown
- Column: The Rise of America’s Broligarchy
Contact us at letters@time.com