Inbox

MAIL

Lessons from the Civil War

Re “The Way We Weren’t” [April 18]: There probably will never be acknowledgment of the role slavery played, because it would stain the hands of some iconic figures, including Thomas Jefferson, James Madison and, yes, Ulysses S. Grant, whose defenders simply can’t accept that such paragons could breed, work or trade human beings as if they were cattle. As a descendant of the bred, worked and traded, I have learned to compartmentalize American history. I therefore say to those who would deny slavery’s importance: The historic flaw of slavery does not diminish but accentuates the greatness of our relatively young country. In 235 years, we have gone from slaveholding President George Washington to African-American President Barack Obama, who incidentally carried the former Confederate states of Florida, North Carolina and Virginia.

David L. Evans, CAMBRIDGE, MASS.

If this magnanimous cause to free a race of people from bondage was so important to the U.S. government that it threatened the existence of our young country, why was the government still making a concerted effort to eliminate outright an entire race of people–Native Americans–for generations after the end of the Civil War? Even today it can be argued that through neglect, there is some legacy remaining of this policy.

David White, JACKSONVILLE, FLA.

Thank you for David Von Drehle’s insightful article. I was disappointed, though, by his failure to draw a more explicit connection to the contemporary Tea Party, birther and antigovernment movements. The dotted line from the Lost Cause apologists for the Confederacy to the “take my country back” fanatics of today is direct and insidious.

Gary R. Howard, SEATTLE

Of course slavery is immoral and despicable, and of course preserving slavery motivated Southern states to secede from the Union. Yet there also can be no doubt that Southern states believed the Constitution conferred the right of secession. Abundant constitutional scholarship supports the reasonableness of such a view at that time. But Von Drehle comes no closer than a dismissive mention of “states’ rights” to the question of the legality of secession and the illegality of a war to stop it. Surely Von Drehle cannot be surprised that so many doubt the nobility of the motives of the Northern states and the legality and morality of their armed and economic devastation of the South.

John D. Wells, CHASSELL, MICH.

I was dismayed to see no mention of Uncle Tom’s Cabin. It is unimaginable to think of any serious article on slavery and the Civil War without any reference to the small book that started the big war.

Maharaj Mukherjee, POUGHKEEPSIE, N.Y.

Von Drehle’s report on Civil War revisionism was eye-opening and well written. Especially smart was the focus on Northern collusion in supporting and profiting from slavery. The time-bending photos were terrific! One omission: W.E.B. DuBois wrote an important corrective to the Lost Cause view, titled Black Reconstruction in America, in 1935–two decades before C. Vann Woodward published The Strange Career of Jim Crow–but as a black scholar, he was ignored.

Steve McGlamery, BLACKSBURG, VA.

The Budget Battle

Re “Ryan’s Hope” and “How Will Obama Handle Ryancare?” [April 18]: For many decades, the Republican Party has cherished three sacred principles: Crucify the weak, decimate the middle class, and worship the wealthy. Congressman Paul Ryan’s “daring plan” inserts itself perfectly into this unholy trinity. It would slash top corporate and individual taxes from 35% to 25% (for the wealthy), doesn’t dare tinker with the Pentagon (the powerful) and will punish the old and the poor with much higher health costs. That used to be called bullying.

Roger Carasso, LOS ANGELES

Where in Ryan’s budget plan is there a clause for cutting the salaries of Congressmen and -women?

Loretta E. Kaczorowski, ALEXANDRIA, VA.

The only way to save our nation from going broke is to embrace the Ryan plan, which Fareed Zakaria has applauded in his article. As Zakaria states, it is a serious effort to tackle entitlement programs. The Obama Administration, however, is more concerned about votes than it is about keeping our nation from going broke, as are the left-wing liberals who support it both in Congress and in the media.

John Talerico, MIDDLETOWN, N.J.

Instead of adopting Ryan’s plan, which drives a bigger wedge between the haves and the have-nots, let’s shut down the wars, eliminate the Bush tax, increase the income level for the payroll tax to $250,000 and raise the age for full Social Security to 68. Now we just have to worry about the details.

Gary Thomsen, EDEN PRAIRIE, MINN.

Mistaken Identity?

On the Closeup page, a large group of men in Afghanistan protest Florida preacher Terry Jones’ immolation of the Koran [April 18]. Yet the image taped onto the head of the body burning in effigy is that of famed Monty Python comedian Terry Jones. Why take things out on the hilarious Welshman?

Rob Reagan, LOS ANGELES

Please recycle this magazine and remove inserts or samples before recycling