Socially conservative women in politics remain wary but generally supportive of President Donald Trump despite recent allegations of adultery and hush money.
Many white evangelical Christian women leaders see the president as an ally thanks to his conservative judicial appointments, anti-abortion policy changes and decision to move the U.S. embassy in Israel to Jerusalem, among other actions.
Still, they’re not enthusiastic about other recent developments. In recent weeks, allegations surfaced that Trump had affairs with porn star Stormy Daniels and Playboy model Karen McDougal after his wife gave birth, that his personal attorney paid Daniels $130,000 shortly before the election and that an ally at the National Enquirer helped keep McDougal quiet. And then there was his defense of top aide Rob Porter in light of accusations of domestic violence.
“Detractors of President Trump would only be satisfied by my complete disavowal and call for his immediate resignation because that’s what they really want,” says Penny Nance, president of the Concerned Women for America, which has half a million members. “We won’t be their little pawns.”
“Though this president’s personal life is alien to us,” she says, “there are things that made us vote for him.”
For Nance, a major reason is that Trump vowed to fight for the causes they believe in, and he has followed through on his promises.
“I’m not surprised by any of this,” she says. “What I was surprised was that American conservative women, primary voters, said it doesn’t matter. The reason they said this is they wanted a champion, who would take the gloves off and punch the bully in the nose.”
Many social conservative women see Trump’s relationship with women as more complicated than just vulgar comments and alleged payouts to porn stars. They are quick to cite his relationship with his daughter Ivanka, how Kellyanne Conway was the first woman to lead a winning presidential campaign and how Sarah Huckabee Sanders is the first mother to serve as White House press secretary. “I do believe on a personal level that the president supports women,” Nance says.
Trump’s history and behavior made many social conservatives uncomfortable during the 2016 campaign. Early on, many evangelicals and Catholics questioned Trump’s harsh rhetoric about woman and non-whites, and the social conservative base was deeply fractured, with many backing Ted Cruz, Marco Rubio or Jeb Bush instead.
But social conservative leaders decided to support Trump in large part because he agreed to champion their anti-abortion policies and to appoint a conservative judge to the Supreme Court.
Despite the “Access Hollywood” tape and pockets of misgivings, conservative white evangelicals and Catholics voted for Donald Trump in force. More than 80% of white evangelicals and 60% of white Catholics voted Trump into office. Similarly, 80% of white evangelicals also voted for Alabama Republican Senate candidate Roy Moore even after he was accused of sexual misconduct with minors.
Morality itself isn’t primary for Trump’s opponents, Nance argues, many of whom defended Bill Clinton’s sexual relationship with an intern.
“I find it laughable that the same people who have the vapors regarding an alleged consensual affair between a future president and a porn star were just find with an affair between a sitting president and an intern,” she says. “I think character counts. But I live in the real world of a president who is doing his best to save the country. I will leave it to his family to take care of character issues that need to be refined, and I will pray for him.”
March for Life president Jeanne Mancini praises the White House for its anti-abortion policies, and many in the anti-abortion movement argue that the Trump White House has advanced their cause more than any administration in recent memory. Trump was the first president to address the March for Life live, he appointed Neil Gorsuch to the Supreme Court and he reinstated the Mexico City policy, which prohibits the U.S. from giving foreign aid to non-governmental organizations abroad that provide abortion-related services.
“To have a pro-life administration makes a difference,” she says. “That is where I make my decision in terms of voting. It is not a personal endorsement of a person and all the behavior.”
The March for Life, she adds, invited the White House to participate exclusively because of the anti-abortion policies. “It was not a broad blanket condoning of everything,” she says.
Mancini’s institutional commitment to anti-abortion policies also keeps her from publicly discussing any tension she may feel. “I don’t speak as Jeanne Mancini, I speak representing pro-life Americans,” Mancini says. “As a person I absolutely grapple with some of these different things.”
Rebecca Hagelin, a conservative columnist and former vice president of the Heritage Foundation, believes Trump has acted on biblical principles when it comes to policy.
“My prayer is that as he understands these principles are best for the nation, that they are best in human interactions too,” Hagelin says. “I pray for him daily that if he hasn’t yet connected the dots on personal relationship and family and how women should be treated, that he will soon.”
She also wishes Trump exercised more wisdom. Trump’s approach troubles her, like his reported comments calling African nations “shithole countries.” She feels freer to call it out since she is not in an advisory or policy role. “Mr. President, the way that you talk sometimes is the way we’ve taught our sons never to be like,” she says.
But still, Hagelin’s critique only goes so far.
“He’s done nothing as president anywhere near what Bill Clinton has done in the Oval Office,” Hagelin says. “If I woke up tomorrow morning and found out the president of the U.S. was having affairs in the Oval Office with interns, you bet I would be angry.”
- Volodymyr Zelensky and the Spirit of Ukraine: TIME's 2022 Person of the Year
- Mickey Guyton Is TIME's 2022 Breakthrough Artist of the Year
- The 10 Best Nonfiction Books of 2022
- Column: What Elon Musk Gets Wrong About Free Speech
- The Forgotten Story of One of the First U.S. Soldiers Killed Overseas After Pearl Harbor
- Why You're More Likely to Get Sick in the Winter, According to New Research
- Column: What the Protests Tell Us About China's Future
- 18 Last-Minute Gifts for Everyone on Your List