Capitol Police History: Why Force Was Created

Updated: January 8, 2021 3:27 PM EST | Originally published: June 14, 2017 12:09 PM EDT

Jan. 6, 2021, was a dark day in U.S. history, and in the history of the U.S. Capitol Police. A violent mob attacked the seat of the legislative branch and ran amok through its halls, breaking into offices—including House Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s—in one of the biggest security breaches in the U.S. Capitol’s history.

The U.S. Capitol Police Chief has resigned, and lawmakers have called for investigations into what went wrong. Among the five fatalities linked to the Jan. 6 riot is a U.S. Capitol Police officer who died Thursday night from his injuries. Only four U.S. Capitol Police officers have been killed in the line of duty since its establishment in 1828.

The Jan. 6 assault on the Capitol stands in stark contrast to the assault that prompted the founding of the U.S. Capitol Police force, which is charged with protecting Congress, amid the polarized political climate that was 1828.

At the time, “Jacksonian” politicians (supporters of Andrew Jackson, who had nearly become president in 1824) had secured a majority in Congress after the midterm elections. Sitting President John Quincy Adams could have expected he was going to have to fight Jackson for the White House in the upcoming 1828 presidential election — but he probably didn’t expect his son to get into an actual physical fight with a Jacksonian before Election Day.

Russell Jarvis, a journalist for a pro-Jackson newspaper The Washington Telegraph, attended a New Year’s Eve celebration at the White House with his wife and Boston relatives, when John Adams Jr., the president’s son and personal secretary, made what Jarvis later described as a “grievous insult to the ladies of my family.” Here’s how a book that chronicled the political and social scene in mid-19th century Washington, D.C., Perley’s Reminiscences of 60 Years in the National Metropolis, described the contretemps:

Mr. Jarvis introduced them courteously, and they then passed on into the East Room. Soon afterward they found themselves standing opposite to Mr. John Adams, who was conversing with the Rev. Mr. Stetson. “Who is that lady?” asked Mr. Stetson. “That,” replied Mr. John Adams, in a tone so loud that the party heard it, “is the wife of one Russell Jarvis, and if he knew how contemptibly he is viewed in this house they would not be here.” The Bostonians at once paid their respects to Mrs. Adams and withdrew, Mr. Jarvis having first ascertained from Mr. Stetson that it was Mr. John Adams who had insulted them. A few days afterward Mr. Jarvis sent a note to Mr. John Adams, demanding an explanation, by a friend of his, Mr. McLean. Mr. Adams told Mr. McLean that he had no apology to make to Mr. Jarvis, and that he wished no correspondence with him.

Jarvis is said to have been waiting for the right moment to seek revenge when he saw Adams in the Capitol Rotunda in April 1828. He said he asked the junior Adams if he would apologize, and when he didn’t, “I was excited by his continued refusal, and by a recollection of the offense, to commit an assault upon his person, which consisted merely in pulling his nose and slapping one side of his face, with my open hand,” Jarvis recalled, according to a personal account of the incident published in the newspaper Niles’ Register.

Jarvis’s actions have been described as “all standard and approved provocations for a duel,” according to the biography of presidential families America’s Royalty: All the Presidents’ Children, “however, John Quincy Adams’s disapproval for dueling was made evident when he responded for his son by sending a message to Congress…requesting that Congress provide funds to secure the way between the president’s office and Congress so that future incidents could be prevented.”

Congress passed the act creating the U.S. Capitol Police on May 2, 1828.

The History Behind the Founding of the U.S. Capitol Police

More Must-Reads from TIME