While Texas real estate developer Joelle “Jo Jo” Fletcher didn’t find love with Ben Higgins on The Bachelor (even though he told her he loved her), the new Bachelorette now has a whole group of men angling for her affections, including a hipster, a landscape architect and a unicorn.

But there are some real contenders vying for a chance to sit in a hot tub with Fletcher. The frontrunners include Jordan Rogers, the brother of NFL star Aaron Rogers; a dreamy firefighter named Grant; and a singer/songwriter named James Taylor (really!).

As Fletcher starts on her path to love, we looked back to decide which season made for the best reality television. From worst to best, here is a definitive ranking of every season of The Bachelorette.


More Must-Reads From TIME

Contact us at letters@time.com.

Read More From TIME