• Entertainment

This Game of Thrones Fan Theory May Explain What Happened to Hodor

3 minute read

Warning: This post contains spoilers from both the Game of Thrones TV show and George R.R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire series.

Those who watched the second episode of Game of Thrones sixth season Sunday were witness to one of the show’s rare flashback scenes — a sequence that featured Bran Stark and the Three-Eyed Raven traveling into the past to see a young Ned, Benjen and Lyanna Stark. They were also given some insight into a character who up until that moment had remained largely an enigma: Hodor.

The scene in question shows Hodor as a young stable boy named Wyllis who could speak in full sentences, causing fans to begin speculating about what made him become the disyllabic gentle giant he is now. One popular theory posits that Hodor was a warg, but stayed inside his animal for too long and drove himself mad — a concept that has been mentioned before in the G.o.T. universe. Back in season four, Jojen Reed tells Bran that, “If you’re trapped in Summer [Bran’s direwolf] for too long, you’ll forget what it was to be human.”

So what evidence is there that Hodor possessed the power to warg? Luckily, two Reddit users have explained the theory in detail. “The last episode made a point of showing how [Wyllis]/Hodor was friendly with Lyanna, and how eager he was to please her and her family,” wrote TazoGreenTea. “As a stable boy, it would make sense that his choice would be to warg into a horse since, like dogs, they are docile and are accustomed to his presence. And if the (possibly) only girl treating him nicely was Lyanna, it would make complete sense that this is the horse he would warg into.”

Read More: There’s More to That Hodor Flashback on Game of Thrones

See The Real-Life People Who Inspired Game of Thrones Characters

HBO; Getty Images
From left: Cersei and Margaret of AnjouHBO; Getty Images
From Left: Khaleesi and Queen Elizabeth I.HBO; Getty Images
From Left: Melisandre and Bloody MaryHelen Sloan—HBO; Getty Images
From left: Talisa Stark and Anne Boleyn.Helen Sloan—HBO; Getty Images
From left: Brienne of Tarth and Joan of Arc.HBO; DeAgostini—Getty Images
Portrait of Henry VIII. By Hans Holbein Date c. 1540. Henry VIII (28 June 1491 - 28 January 1547) was King of England from 21 April 1509 until his death. He was also Lord of Ireland (later King of Ireland) and claimant to the Kingdom of France.
From left: Henry VIII and Robert Baratheon.HBO; Getty Images
From left: Joffrey and Caligula.HBO; De Agostini—Getty Images

The Redditor goes on to explain how this also means Hodor could have been present for many of the events surrounding Lyanna and Rhaegar Targaryen’s relationship, a storyline that likely leads to the death of Lyanna’s horse and Hodor’s current state of mind. “Since Rhaegar and Lyanna would eventually run away from everyone, it also makes sense that they would both be on horses while doing so and Wyllis/Hodor would have been witness to many events of that storyline,” the user wrote. “My guess is that the horse was slain during battle while Hodor was warging into it, which would explain why he is a very much a simpleton now and is afraid of fighting and lightning. Would also explain why Bran is able to warg into a human, because the mind inside the human is an animal’s mind (or the remnant of a mind trapped into a horse).”

“Oathbreaker,” the third episode of Game of Thrones‘ sixth season airs Sunday at 9 p.m. EST on HBO.

More Must-Reads From TIME

Write to Megan McCluskey at megan.mccluskey@time.com