Virtual reality (VR) is far from a new concept — the term was coined in 1987 by computer scientist Jaron Lanier. But the technology hit a critical milestone this year, as high-end VR gadgets are now widely available to the masses for the first time.
The Facebook-owned Oculus VR’s Rift headset began shipping on March 28, after first appearing as a Kickstarter project in 2012. HTC’s Vive headset launched on April 5. Samsung’s Gear VR goggles, based on the same software as the Rift, was released in November.
Each of these devices enable experiences that are some mixture of immersive, strange and awkward. And each has advantages and drawbacks. The more expensive models offer better experiences, but their cost keeps them out of most consumers’ range.
Thinking about buying a virtual reality headset? Here’s a look at how the Rift, Vive and Gear VR compare.
- Price: $599
- System requirements: Computer with the following specifications: NVIDIA GTX 970/AMD R9 290 equivalent or greater, Intel i5-4590 or greater, 8GB or more of RAM, Compatible HDMI 1.3 video output, 3 USB 3.0 ports and 1 USB 2.0 port, Windows 7 Sp1 64 bit or newer
- Estimated cost of PC with system requirements: Between $949-$999 when purchased with Rift
- App store size: 50 games and apps
- Sensors: Gyroscope, accelerometer, optical sensor for peripheral space tracking
- Resolution: 1,200 x 1,080 pixels per eye
- Refresh rate: 90 HZ
- What’s included in the box: Oculus Rift headset, Sensor, Xbox One controller, Oculus Remote, cables
The Oculus Rift offers a premium virtual reality headset, delivering vivid graphics and smooth gameplay with no lag. When combined with the headset’s sensors that track your movement, the Rift’s stunning visuals trick your mind into thinking you’re taking part in all types of adventures, from soaring through the sky to greeting aliens on distant worlds.
But the Rift has its drawbacks. It needs to be tethered to a high-end, expensive gaming computer, and that cord can get in the way. Additionally, interacting with objects in the Rift’s virtual space means using a gaming controller. There were many instances in which I wanted to reach out and touch what I was seeing in the Rift, but that’s not possible yet. Oculus’ Touch controllers will help address this concern when they ship later this year. For now, most Rift games are designed to be played while sitting down, while HTC’s Vive offers more motion-based activities.
- Price: $799
- System requirements: Computer with the following specifications: NVIDIA GeForce GTX 970 or AMD Radeon R9 290 equivalent or greater, Intel i5-4590 or AMD FX 8350 equivalent or greater, 4GB or more of RAM, HDMI 1.4 or DisplayPort 1.2 or newer, USB 2.0 or greater port, Windows 7 SP1 or newer
- Estimated cost of system requirements: Around $999
- App store size: At least 50 games at launch
- Sensors: Accelerometer, gyroscope, laser position sensor, front-facing camera
- Resolution: 2,160 x 1,200 combined resolution
- Refresh rate: 90 HZ
- What’s included in the box: Headset, two motion controllers designed for VR, two base stations, a link box, earbuds, alternate face cushion, cleaning cloth, cables and mounts to set everything up.
Where the Rift leaves users stuck in a seat, HTC’s Vive is one step closer to Star Trek’s Holodeck. Two innovations — the Vive’s motion-tracking base stations and its special controllers — enable wearers to explore virtual worlds by physically walking around and “touching” objects.
The two base stations, which look like tiny black cubes, must be mounted in spots overlooking the player’s area. Then, they cast invisible lasers detected by the Vive’s hardware that help its software track players’ movement. The controllers, meanwhile, let wearers use natural-feeling gestures to pick up or manipulate objects in games and other experiences. The controllers transform into everything from a golf club to a magic staff to a paint brush.
Like the Rift, the Vive is powered by a high-end, expensive gaming PC. That helps it provide smooth and gorgeous graphics. But that means it, too, has a cord that can get in the way. And that’s a bigger problem with the Vive, given all the moving around you’ll want to do. The Vive is also the most expensive virtual reality headset on the market, and it requires the most effort to set up.
Watch This Super-Talented Eighth Grader Paint Using the HTC Vive:
Samsung Gear VR
- Price: $99.99
- System requirements: Compatible with the following Samsung phones: Galaxy S7, Galaxy S7 Edge, Galaxy Note 5, Galaxy S6 Edge+, Galaxy S6, Galaxy S6 Edge
- Estimated cost of system requirements: Between around $629 and $800 depending on which Samsung phone you choose (without carrier subsidy)
- App store size: More than 200 apps
- Sensors: Gyroscope, accelerometer, proximity sensor, touchpad for navigation
- Resolution: Based on Samsung phones with 2,560 x 1,440 resolution display (Note: Resolution when looking through the Gear VR will be lower since it provides a windowed view of the phone’s screen)
- Refresh rate: 60 Hz
- What’s included in the box: Gear VR headset
Samsung’s Gear VR provides a milder yet enjoyable virtual reality experience at a much more affordable price. While the Rift and Vive require expensive gaming PCs, the Gear VR draws its power from a Samsung smartphone. This makes the experience more convenient — just snap in your phone and it’ll automatically start running virtual reality software. The lack of a cord also means you’re free to look around without worrying about getting tangled up.
But the Gear VR’s reliance on a smartphone rather than a high-performance PC means a less refined overall experience. The Gear VR can be laggy, and it doesn’t track your body’s movement in the digital space. The Rift and Vive, by comparison, create far more immersive virtual worlds. It’s comparable to the difference between playing a smartphone game and playing the latest PlayStation 4 or Xbox One title.
Samsung’s headset is a winner in its own right, however. There’s a giant library of content, it’s more convenient to use, and it’s a whole lot cheaper. Those factors make it a solid choice, especially for those who already have a Samsung phone. It’s a great entryway into virtual reality, but those who get hooked will likely find themselves wanting to upgrade quickly.