• Politics

How Hillary Clinton Won the Benghazi Hearing

7 minute read

In a marathon 11-hour hearing Thursday, Republican members of the Select Committee on Benghazi put Hillary Clinton’s tenure as Secretary of State on trial before a national audience.

In three rounds of sharp-tongued questioning, House Republicans grilled Clinton on her advisors, her management of embassy security and her push for the U.S. military intervention in Libya. They questioned her management style, her transparency and even her public relations strategies.

The hearing began with an assurance from committee chair Trey Gowdy, a white-haired former prosecutor, that the questions would be focused on the 2012 attacks in Benghazi that led to the deaths of four Americans.

“Madame Secretary, I understand some people have suggested this investigation is about you,” he said, in a rare moment of understatement at the hearing. “Let me assure you that it is not.”

As the hearing opened, it stuck to that script, with both Clinton and her Republican interlocutors seeking to present an image of thoughtful truth-seekers. But with little new material to engage on that front, the hearing soon turned to Clinton’s legacy in the Obama Administration.

For her part, Clinton was eager to use the opportunity to relive her time at Foggy Bottom. She defended her decision to push for the Libyan intervention, laid out a vision for foreign policy that could have doubled as a campaign speech and rattled off some of her accomplishments in the Obama Administration.

Decoding Hillary Clinton's Campaign Photo Ops

Des Moines, IA - April 15: Hillary Clinton began her 2016 campaign by driving from her house in Chappaqua, N.Y., to Iowa in a van instead of flying, as she did in 2008.Justin Sullivan—Getty Images
Marshalltown, IA - April 15: Clinton had coffee and spoke with customers during her first Iowa visit. Many of her advisors think she performs best in small groups with voters, so her campaign began with a carefully planned “listening tour."Michael B. Thomas—AFP/Getty Images
Hillary Clinton Begins Presidential Campaign In Iowa
Monticello, IA - April 14: At a community college in Iowa, Clinton said exactly what the left wanted her to say. "There's something wrong when hedge fund managers pay lower tax rates than nurses or the truckers that I saw on I-80 as I was driving here," Clinton said.Justin Sullivan—Getty Images
Keene, N.H. - April 20: Clinton’s first good baby photo-op came early in New Hampshire in the town of Keene. Her campaign has made multiple references to her new status as a grandmother.Lucas Jackson—Reuters
Keene, N.H. - April 20: Clinton visited a family-owned children’s furniture factory to talk small business and manufacturing. Planks of wood, stacked boxes and heavy machinery formed an ideal backdrop.Don Emmert—AFP/Getty Images
Keene, N.H. - April 20: Clinton chose a casual setting to brush off questions over the Clinton Foundation’s acceptance of donations during her time as secretary of state. She called allegations that she intervened on behalf of donors “distractions.” Don Emmert—AFP/Getty Images
Hillary Clinton Begins New Hampshire Election Campaign
Concord, N.H. - April 21: Clinton got a chance to talk student debt with young women at a community college in Concord, New Hampshire. “You cannot expect people to have that much debt and then be expected to pay it off,” she said.Andrew Burton—Getty Images
Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Rodham Clinton speaks with long time friend and political adviser Mary Louise Hancock on April 21, 2015, in Concord, N.H.
Concord, N.H. - April 21: Clinton paid her dues with a required visit for Democratic hopefuls in New Hampshire: a gathering at the home of 94-year-old former state Sen. Mary Louise Hancock, the so-called grand dame of New Hampshire politics.Jim Cole—AP
Former U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton (R) takes part in a roundtable of young Nevadans discussing immigration as she campaigns for the 2016 Democratic presidential nomination at Rancho High School in Las Vegas, on May 5, 2015.
Las Vegas, NV - May 5: Clinton discussed immigration with a roundtable in Las Vegas, Nevada, a primary state with a heavy population of Hispanic immigrants, calling for a path to citizenship for undocumented immigrants. Mike Blake—Reuters

Speaking in measured tones, sometimes slowly and mostly emotionless, except for a description of how the deaths happened, Clinton avoided any serious missteps that might have damaged her presidential campaign. There was no overriding bad moment, as in her 2013 appearance on Benghazi before a Senate committee, when she asked “What difference, at this point, does it make?” in response to a question.

Read More: Watch Clinton’s Most Entertaining Facial Expressions

During one telling exchange, Republican Rep. Peter Roskam of Illinois sought to corner Clinton into taking credit for the American strategy in Libya. Instead, Clinton parried, using his question to discuss her views on foreign policy.

“That wasn’t the Obama doctrine, was it Madame Secretary?” Roskam said, asking whether Clinton’s role in the Libya was an example of her much-touted “smart power.” “This was the Clinton doctrine,” he said.

“No,” Clinton concurred, giving Obama ultimate responsibility on Libya before recounting her own bona fides. “The way we put together the coalition—the way I put together the coalition—that imposed sanctions on Iran, I think there is a lot to talk about. I talk about smart power. You talk about what I believe? I believe you have to use every tool at our disposal: lead with diplomacy, support with development, and when necessary, as a last resort but not a first choice, defense. So, yes, is that what I believe, yes it is what I believe and Libya was to some extent an example of that.”

Clinton has already leaned heavily on her record on the campaign trail, claimed much of the credit for laying the groundwork of the Iran deal, and recounting the miles she traveled to broker a ceasefire between Israelis and Palestinians, defend women’s rights and discuss the risks of climate change.

Meanwhile, Republican presidential candidates have lambasted Clinton for her time in the Obama Administration. Donald Trump has called Clinton “the worst Secretary of State in the history of the United States.” In an op-ed published Thursday by the conservative news organization Breitbart, Florida Sen. Marco Rubio wrote that “the debate about Clinton’s precise role in the Benghazi disaster should not obscure a broader point that is obvious to most observers: Hillary Clinton’s failed record as Secretary of State … has made America less safe at home and abroad.”

Read More: Read Clinton’s Opening Statement at the Benghazi Hearing

While the United States was instrumental in overthrowing the dictator Muammar Gaddafi, Libya remains a war-torn nation bitterly contested by militias and jihadist groups. Clinton advocated for a larger U.S. role in Syria, but the country is now in large part overrun by the Islamic State and there is little evidence American aid has had any effect on the conflict.

Thursday’s hearing provided a chance for Republicans to question her record, and for Clinton to reaffirm her legacy in the Obama administration.

Beginning with her opening remarks, Clinton made a case for American influence around the world, delivering a statement that would serve well on the campaign trail. “We need leadership at home to match our leadership abroad. Leadership that puts national security ahead of politics and ideology,” said Clinton. “Our nation has a long history of bipartisan cooperation on foreign policy and national security. Not that we always agree—far from it—but we do come together when it counts.”

Then she explained how she worked with the Republican chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee and Republican Senate Leader Mitch McConnell to advance democracy in Myanmar.

Conscious of the wider American audience beyond Capitol Hill, Clinton recounted the intensely dramatic nature of her position, saying there were times she received documents so important they were delivered to her in a locked briefcase. In response to questioning from Rep. Susan Brooks about her lack of email correspondence with slain ambassador Chris Stevens, Clinton pointed to her constant liaisons around the world. “I did not conduct most of the business I did on behalf of our country on email. I conducted it in meetings, I read massive amounts of memos, great deal of classified information, I made a lot of secure phone calls, I was in and out of the White House all the time,” Clinton said.

Read More: Most See GOP Benghazi Probe as Vehicle to Hurt Clinton

She also expressed deep concern for the safety of her diplomats, and answered some softball questions from the Democrats on the committee to vividly recall the events of Sept. 11, 2012, in Benghazi.

“We were desperate,” said a visibly emotional Clinton. “What appears to have happened some point later is that Libyans found Ambassador Stevens, and they him brought to the hospital where they labored” to resuscitate him.

In one exchange, Rep. Mike Pompeo grilled Clinton on her management of consulates and whether she did enough personally to oversee security for the ambassadors. Clinton answered with a theory of delegating decisions to lower management.

“You want to find people who are dedicated 100 percent to security,” Clinton said. “You don’t want a Secretary or anyone to dip in and out.”

“Yes ma’am—leaders lead,” Pompeo remonstrated.

While Clinton spoke, her campaign worked overtime. During the hearing, Clinton staffers posted a video of her testimony speaking about keeping testimony. And on Facebook, her campaign broadcasted her message: “Hillary has been testifying at the House Select Committee on Benghazi for hours, and what have we learned? That she was a Secretary of State devoted to upholding our nation’s values abroad, practicing smart foreign policy, and keeping our diplomats as safe as possible.”

Widespread scrutiny of the Benghazi Committee has increased in recent weeks since House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy claimed that the members successfully hurt Clinton’s poll numbers. A second Republican congressman, Rep. Richard Hanna, said the committee was “designed to go after people and an individual, Hillary Clinton.”

With Gowdy’s committee under fire for its motives, he and the Republican majority appeared chastened during the hearing, mostly refraining from slamming Clinton. But after 11 hours, they appeared unable to point to specific gains from the day.

After the hearing, Gowdy was asked what new insights lawmakers gleaned from Clinton’s testimony. “I don’t know if she testified that much differently today than she has previous times she testified,” he said.

Read Next: Clinton Prepares for Benghazi Showdown

See an Intimate Portrait of Hillary Clinton

With an ice cream cone in hand, Hillary waves to the crowd in Weedsport, New York, as she heads to the Harriet Tubman Home for the Aged in Auburn, New York, one of the stops on her Save America's Treasures tour, July 14, 1998.Diana Walker—Contour by Getty Images for TIME
Getting ready for President Clinton's second inaugural, Hillary gets her first glimpse of daughter Chelsea's short skirt. Jan. 20, 1997Diana Walker—Contour by Getty Images for TIME
The President and the First Lady Share a private moment, one of their last in the Oval Office. Jan. 11, 2001. Diana Walker—Contour by Getty Images for TIME
Hillary checks her messages upon departure from Malta for the as-yet-undisclosed location, Tripoli, Oct. 18, 2011. This photo was turned into a meme that circulated around the world. Diana Walker—Contour by Getty Images for TIME
Before an appearance with David Letterman, Hillary checks her BlackBerry while Diana Walker takes their picture. Feb. 4, 2008.Diana Walker—Contour by Getty Images for TIME
Hillary gathers her thoughts moments before her introduction at Nueva Esperanza Academy Charter High School in Philadelphia. Apr. 18, 2008. Diana Walker—Contour by Getty Images for TIME
Diana Walker—Contour by Getty Images for TIME
Hillary walks up the steps of the US Capitol to meet with Senate leaders. May 16, 2006. Diana Walker—Contour by Getty Images for TIME
Hillary enters a Super Bowl party at a bar and grill in St. Paul Minnesota, where she watches the New York Giants win the game, Feb. 3, 2008. Diana Walker—Contour by Getty Images for TIME

More Must-Reads from TIME

Contact us at letters@time.com