September 30, 2015 10:57 AM EDT

How I Met Your Mother fans rejoice! Barney and Robin teamed up to pull one over on three party planners during Tuesday night’s episode of Best Time Ever with Neil Patrick Harris. Cobie Smulders’ real-life husband, Taran Killam, also got in on the action.

Similar to last week’s Britney Spears “Voices In Your Head” segment, the sketch features Smulders interviewing potential party planners while Harris and Killam instruct her on what to say and do. The interviews take place in Smulders’ home where she suggests several awful anniversary party ideas fed to her through an earpiece. She proposes covering the pool to create a dance floor and giving a cringeworthy sentimental toast.

“There are so many stars, so many grains of sand, but when I look to you, my light, my hero, the wind beneath my wings — I have found my planet that I want to live on,” the actress says while barely containing her laughter.

Write to Megan McCluskey at

Read More From TIME

Related Stories