Should Ronda Rousey Play Captain Marvel in the Movie?

3 minute read

Marvel’s first female superhero movie, Captain Marvel, doesn’t hit theaters until 2018. But MMA fighter Ronda Rousey, who not only packs a mean punch but is making a foray into the acting world, has put herself forward for the role in a recent Reddit AMA. Would Rousey make a good Carol Danvers? Here are some pros and cons.

MORE: Meet Captain Marvel: Fighter Pilot, Feminist and Marvel’s Big Gamble

Pros

Captain Marvel is one of the strongest characters in the Marvel universe. Whoever plays her should be powerful too, and who better than the woman who just won Best Fighter at the ESPYs? Not only is she undefeated, she usually takes down her opponents in under a minute. She recently KO’d challenger Bethe Correia in just 34 seconds. It would be easy to buy that when Rousey’s Captain Marvel hit a bad guy, he would stay down.

Rousey seems to be excited by the prospect. After the Reddit AMA, people sent her fan art of what she might look like as the superhero. She shared them on Instagram writing, “There were so many cool ones I couldn’t pick just one to share.” The ones she did are pretty convincing:

Cons

The obvious problem with casting Rousey is that she hasn’t had much experience on the big screen. She played a supporting role in the Entourage movie, and is also set to star in an upcoming biopic about herself. But considering that studio executives are hesitant to greenlight female superhero films — the Sony hacks revealed an email from Marvel Studios CEO Ike Perlmutter warning Sony against creating a female superhero movie for financial reasons, calling past attempts “a disaster” — a lot is riding on the Captain Marvel film. Perhaps a proven action hero like Mad Max: Fury Road’s Charlize Theron, Battlestar Galactica’s Katee Sackhoff or Edge of Tomorrow’s Emily Blunt would make more sense.

There’s also the more minor issue that Rousey said in a Reddit AMA that she would “like to vie for Miss Marvel.” This statement doesn’t inspire confidence because first, Ms. Marvel, as far as we know, doesn’t have her own movie in the works. And second, Ms. Marvel is currently a 16-year-old Muslim girl.

Here’s the backstory: Carol Danvers, the current Captain Marvel and the character getting the silver screen treatment, did used to be Ms. Marvel. Back then she looked like this. The Marvel editors (and Captain Marvel writer Kelly Sue DeConnick) decided to promote Carol from Ms. Marvel to Captain Marvel. She now looks like this. Some fans were angry that Marvel covered her up and cut her hair, but many were delighted by her more powerful look. Captain Marvel even has a rabid fanbase called the Carol Corps.

Since the Ms. Marvel spot was open, Marvel created a new character named Kamala Khan who now occupies that role (and totally worships Carol Danvers). The new Ms. Marvel is extremely popular. The first issue even made the New York Times bestseller list.

In short, Rousey’s comic book knowledge is not spectacular, though presumably she would read up on the part before agreeing to the movie.

Read Next: 10 Questions With Ronda Rousey

See the Evolution of Jennifer Lawrence

Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence at Nylon Magazine's TV Issue launch party at SkyBar on Aug. 24, 2009 in Los Angeles.Jason LaVeris—FilmMagic/Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence receives the Marcello Mastroianni Award from jury member Juriy Arabov during the 65th Venice Film Festival on Sept. 6, 2008 in Venice.Venturelli—WireImage/Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence poses for a portrait during the 2010 Sundance Film Festival on Jan. 23, 2010 in Park City, Utah. Jeff Vespa—WireImage/Getty Image
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence as Ree in the critically acclaimed 2010 film Winter's Bone.Roadside Attractions
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence accepts the Rising Star Award during the 22nd Annual Palm Springs International Film Festival Awards on Jan. 8, 2011 in Palm Springs, Calif. John Shearer—Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Actors Jennifer Lawrence and Jon Hamm speak onstage during the 16th annual Critics' Choice Movie Awards on Jan. 14, 2011 in Los Angeles.Kevin Winter—Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence arrives at the 68th Annual Golden Globe Awards held on Jan. 16, 2011 in Los Angeles.George Pimentel—WireImage/Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence at the 83rd annual Academy Awards on Feb. 27, 2011 in Los Angeles. Jason Merritt—Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence in The Hunger Games.Lionsgate
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence during an interview with Jimmy Fallon on May 20, 2011.Lloyd Bishop—NBC/Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Josh Hutcherson and Jennifer Lawrence arrive at the premiere of The Hunger Games on March 12, 2012 in Los Angeles.Kevin Winter—Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence appears on El Hormiguero on April 19, 2012 in Madrid.Juan Naharro Gimenez—Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Robert De Niro, Jennifer Lawrence and Bradley Cooper at the Silver Linings Playbook premiere during the 2012 Toronto International Film Festival on Sept. 8, 2012 .Jeff Vespa—Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Bradley Cooper and Jennifer Lawrence in Silver Linings Playbook.The Weinstein Copany
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence onstage during the 2013 People's Choice Awards on Jan. 9, 2013 in Los Angeles.Lester Cohen—WireImage/Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence and Bradley Cooper attend the 18th Annual Critics' Choice Movie Awards on Jan. 10, 2013 in Santa Monica, Calif.Christopher Polk—Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence poses with her Best Performance by an actress in a motion picture comedy or musical award for Silver Linings Playbook at the Golden Globes awards ceremony on Jan. 13, 2013 in Los Angeles.Robyn Beck—AFP/Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence attends the Vanity Fair, Barneys New York and The Weinstein Company celebration of Silver Linings Playbook in support of The Glenholme School on Feb. 20, 2013 in Los Angeles.Charley Gallay—Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence accepts the award for Best Female Lead onstage during the 2013 Film Independent Spirit Awards on Feb. 23, 2013 in Santa Monica, Calif.Kevork Djansezian—Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence accepts the award for Best Actress for her role in Silver Linings Playbook from presenter Jean Dujardin at the 85th Academy Awards on Feb. 24, 2013 in Los Angeles.Mario Anzuoni— Reuters
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence attends the 2013 Vanity Fair Oscar Party on Feb. 24, 2013 in Los Angeles.David Livingston—Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence attends the Costume Institute Gala for the PUNK: Chaos to Couture exhibition at the Metropolitan Museum of Art on May 6, 2013 in New York City.Jamie McCarthy—Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence at the screening of Jimmy P. Psychotherapy of a Plains Indian during the Cannes Film Festival on May 18, 2013 in Cannes, France.Anne-Christine Poujoulat—AFP/Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence as Rosalyn Rosenfeld in American Hustle.Sony
Jennifer Lawrence
Peter Dinklage, Jennifer Lawrence, and Nicholas Hoult at the Comic-Con International 2013 on July 20, 2013 in San Diego, Calif. Albert L. Ortega—Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence working with director Francis Lawrence on the set of The Hunger Games: Mockingjay - Part 1.Lionsgate
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence attends the U.K. premiere of The Hunger Games: Catching Fire on Nov. 11, 2013 in London.John Phillips—Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Liam Hemsworth, Elizabeth Banks, Jennifer Lawrence and Josh Hutcherson attend the German premiere of the film The Hunger Games - Catching Fire on Nov. 12, 2013 in Berlin.Franziska Krug—Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence at the Los Angeles premiere of The Hunger Games: Catching Fire on Nov. 18, 2013 in Los Angeles. Robyn Beck—AFP/Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence gets cozy with Dave when she visits the Late Show with David Letterman on Nov. 20, 2013.CBS/Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence arrives to the 71st annual Golden Globe Awards on Jan. 12, 2014 in Los Angeles.Christopher Polk—NBC/Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence presents the Best Actor category at the 86th Academy Awards on March 2, 2013 in Los Angeles. Adam Taylor—ABC/Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Ellen DeGeneres poses for a selfie taken with Jared Leto, Jennifer Lawrence, Channing Tatum, Meryl Streep, Julia Roberts, Kevin Spacey, Brad Pitt, Lupita Nyong'o, Angelina Jolie, Peter Nyong'o Jr. and Bradley Cooper during the 86th annual Academy Awards on March 2, 2014 in Los Angeles.Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence arrives at the 2014 Vanity Fair Oscars Party in Los Angeles on March 2, 2014. Danny Moloshok—Reuters
Jennifer Lawrence x-men
Jennifer Lawrence as Mystique in X-Men: Days of Future Past.FOX
Jennifer Lawrence Seth Meyers
Jennifer Lawrence during an interview on Late Night with Seth Meyers on May 21, 2014.NBC/Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence Sidney Toledano
Sidney Toledano and Jennifer Lawrence attend the Christian Dior show as part of Paris Fashion Week - Haute Couture on July 7, 2014 in Paris.Rindoff/Dufour—French Select/Getty Images
jennifer lawrence hunger games mockingjay premiere
Lorde, Natalie Dormer, Jennifer Lawrence, Elizabeth Banks, Jena Malone and Julianne Moore attend the World Premiere of The Hunger Games: Mockingjay Part 1 on Nov. 10, 2014 in London.Dave M. Benett—WireImage/Getty Images
Jennifer Lawrence The Hunger Games Mockingjay Pt. 2
Evan Ross, Jennifer Lawrence, Liam Hemsworth and Sam Claflin in The Hunger Games: Mockingjay - Part 2.Lionsgate
Jennifer Lawrence
Fan Chelsea Boyce takes a selfie with Jennifer Lawrence at the release of The Hunger Games: Mockingjay - Part 1 on Nov. 17, 2014 in Los Angeles. Michael Buckner—Getty Images
jennifer lawrence met gala
Jennifer Lawrence attends the "China: Through The Looking Glass" Costume Institute Benefit Gala at Metropolitan Museum of Art on May 4, 2015 in New York City. Karwai Tang—WireImage/Getty Images
jennifer lawrence comic con
Director of The Hunger Games: Mockingjay - Part 1 & 2 Francis Lawrence poses with cast members Jennifer Lawrence, Josh Hutcherson and Liam Hemsworth during the 2015 Comic-Con International Convention on July 9, 2015 in San Diego, Calif. Mario Anzuoni—Reuters
jennifer lawrence
Jennifer Lawrence at the 26th Annual PGA Awards on Jan. 24, 2015 in Los Angeles.Jon Kopaloff—FilmMagic/Getty Images

More Must-Reads from TIME

Write to Eliana Dockterman at eliana.dockterman@time.com