January 27, 2015 12:02 PM EST

Channing Tatum stopped by Jimmy Kimmel Live! Monday night to talk about general celebrity things — but the conversation got really good once it turned to the topic of fatherhood. And then also poop.

Tatum’s daughter, Everly, is one and a half now, and Chan is still really, really into being a dad. One of his favorite things about babies in general, he says, is that they all have “these different poop faces.”

Then he demonstrates what Everly’s poop face looks like and says it reminds him of the scene in The Godfather when Marlon Brando dies.

It’s a pretty good poop face, but we’re a bit disappointed it doesn’t look like this.

Read next: Watch The Decemberists Sing YouTube Comments on Jimmy Kimmel

Listen to the most important stories of the day.

Contact us at editors@time.com.

Read More From TIME

Related Stories