Dear Tech Executives: Nobody Cares if You’re ‘Thrilled’

5 minute read

The quarterly call that executives hold to discuss earnings is, short of face-to-face meetings, the best chance for investors to get a sense of a company’s financial health. Over and over again, the analysts on these calls focus their questions on pressing for metrics or hard numbers to gauge that health.

It’s one thing for executives to be bashful about sharing too much data that could help their competitors. It’s another for them to try and replace cold hard numbers with a completely useless commodity: a confessional on how a CEO or CFO is feeling in the moment.

Yet this is an unwelcome trend in tech earnings, where over and over tech leaders who are smart enough to know better keep repeating how thrilled they are, how excited, how they couldn’t be happier about all the boring little incremental developments that apparently please them to no end. It’s unwelcome because these calls aren’t support groups. Investors tune in to decide whether they should buy, sell or hold a company’s stock.

Take Google. On a recent earnings call, Citigroup analyst Mark May asked a reasonable question about Compute Engine, Google’s cloud services platform. “What sort of impact is that having on revenue or expenses and capex for the business?” “We’re really thrilled by the momentum,” Google CFO Patrick Pichette replied.

A no comment would have sufficed here. But Pichette offered less than a no-comment, a comment of negative value, a subjective emotion as answer to a mathematical question. It’s like ordering food at a restaurant and being served a picture of someone who just had a yummy meal. It neither nourishes nor satisfies.

And yet Pichette and Chief Business Officer Omid Kordestani went on to mention how thrilled they were about this or that (we’re thrilled to be a platform!) six more times during the call. The Oxford English Dictionary defines a thrill as “an intense emotion or excitement” that causes “a subtle nervous tremor.” The word comes from the English “thirl,” meaning to pierce something with a sharp instrument–to bore it, which is what Pichette and Kordestani were doing to their audience.

America's 500 Biggest Companies

Wal-Mart Posts 21 Percent Drop In Q4 Profit
Wal-Mart Stores The retail giant held on to the top spot on the Fortune 500, edging out Exxon Mobil for the second year in a row. For fiscal year 2014, Wal-Mart’s net sales totaled $473.1 billion, up 1.6% from the year-earlier period. While its sales grew domestically, Wal-Mart said the expiration of a payroll tax cut, reductions in the U.S. food stamp program, and poor winter weather hurt its results. But in the U.S., Wal-Mart is bullish about its plans to open even more small stores, which compete with drugstores and small grocery stores.Justin Sullivan—Getty Images
Key Speakers At 21st World Petroleum Congress
Exxon Mobil In 2013, Exxon Mobil’s total revenue dropped 8.8% to $438.26 billion, and net income fell an even steeper 27%. Oil production took a tumble in 2013, all while capital and exploration expenditures increased. While Exxon has said it plans to start production at a record 10 major projects this year, capital spending is expected to decline 6.4% from 2012. Deepwater projects in the Gulf of Mexico and a liquefied natural gas project in Papua New Guinea are among the ventures scheduled for this year.Bloomberg—Bloomberg via Getty Images
General Views from Chevron Corp. Gas Stations
Chevron Chevron, the U.S.’s second-largest oil company after Exxon Mobil, posted a 5.4% decrease in total revenue in 2013, to $228.9 billion. Chevron Chief Executive John Watson said results were hurt by lower global crude oil prices and refining margins, as well as fewer asset sale gains and higher expenses. The company expects production will increase in 2015 and beyond. Chevron says it has also made progress with its projects in Australia and the Gulf of Mexico.Bloomberg—Bloomberg via Getty Images
Warren Buffett Speaks At Conference Focused On Detroit's Revitalization
Berkshire Hathaway Berkshire Hathaway’s per-share book value climbed 18.2% in 2013, but it underperformed the Standard & Poor’s 500 index, which grew by more than 32% with dividends. The company traditionally outperforms the S&P when the index falls or moderately rises, but falls short in years when the market is strong. Berkshire kicked off 2013 with a big-name acquisition, joining 3G Capital to pay $23 billion to acquire H.J. Heinz. The earnings boost from that deal, which closed in June, is expected to be substantial in 2014, according to Chief Executive Warren Buffett.Bill Pugliano—Getty Images
CHINA-US-TELECOMMUNICATION-RETAIL-APPLE
Apple Apple’s net sales keep climbing, as the tech giant continues to sell more iPhones and digital content. But the company faces pressure in the smartphone business, as Android phones grow increasingly dominant. Meanwhile, Apple reported an annual drop in net income in fiscal year 2013, a first in more than a decade. Activist investor Carl Icahn last year disclosed a stake in Apple and subsequently pushed for the company to spend billions on share buybacks. In April, the company increased the amount of shares it is authorized to repurchase and raised its quarterly dividend by 8%, and in late May it announced it was acquiring Beats Music and Beats Electronics for $3 billion. JOHANNES EISELE—AFP/Getty Images
US Gas Prices Increase
Phillips 66 The refining company reported a 4% dip in revenue in 2013 — the first full-year results since it separated from the exploration division of ConocoPhillips in 2012. Results were hurt by lower average prices for crude oil and petroleum products. Phillips 66 is planning to spend about 40% more on capital expenditures in 2014 compared to the prior year, as the company invests in its midstream and chemicals segments to capitalize on North America’s energy renaissance.Bloomberg—Bloomberg via Getty Images
Detroit Exteriors And Landmarks
General Motors GM’s troubles with its dangerously defective vehicles don’t appear to have hurt sales — at least not yet. In April, the automaker’s U.S. sales rose 7% from a year ago as CEO Mary Barra explained to Congress how GM would handle recalls of millions of its vehicles. This follows higher vehicle sales in 2013 across many key markets, including the U.S., South America and the Asia/Pacific. The company expects to spend $1.7 billion to cover the cost of its record-setting number of recalls so far in 2014.Paul Marotta—Getty Images
Ford Issues Recall For 850,000 2013-14 Vehicles
Ford Ford has benefitted from a stronger economic recovery in the U.S., as many drivers look to replace their aging vehicles. Executives also expect it to be profitable in North America this year, albeit at a lower level than in 2013. In Europe, where Ford has closed factories and cut thousands of jobs, the company expects to report a narrower loss in 2014 and achieve profitability the following year. Worldwide, Ford’s 2013 revenue increased 10% from the previous year to $146.9 billion, while profits climbed 26%.Joe Raedle—Getty Images
Engine Manufacturing At General Electric Aviation Ahead Of U.S. Manufacturing Data
General Electric GE kicked off 2013 with a large asset sale announcement, agreeing in February to sell its remaining stake in NBCUniversal’s joint venture with Comcast for $18.1 billion. Proceeds from that sale were used to accelerate both share buybacks and the conglomerate’s restructuring plans. In the year ahead, GE is looking to invest. In April, the company made an offer to to buy French firm Alstom’s power and grid businesses for nearly $17 billion — a deal that would, if approved, immediately boost GE’s earnings.Bloomberg—Bloomberg via Getty Images
A Valero Energy Corp. Gas Station Ahead Of Earnings Figures
Valero Valero has benefited from increased oil and gas production in North America, and the company has said domestic gasoline demand and margins look positive heading into the summer driving season. This comes after some big changes for the refining giant: Valero completed the spin off of its retail business, CST Brands, last year. And earlier this year, the company named its new CEO, Joe Gorder, who was previously the company’s chief operating officer.Bloomberg—Bloomberg via Getty Images
US-ECONOMY-AT&T
For the full list, click here.SAUL LOEB—AFP/Getty Images

Nor were they the only corporate thrillseekers. “Overall, I’m thrilled with the progress we made across all of our initiatives,” Groupon CEO Eric Lefkofsky said on Thursday. But at least Groupon’s stock rose 25% on the evidence of that progress. So even if Lefkofsky wasn’t exactly atremble with joy over the company’s progress, the surge in value Friday of his Groupon shares surely enlivened his mood.

Not so for Mark Zuckerberg. Facebook’s shares fell 10% on warnings of slower growth and heavier spending. The normally low-key Zuckerberg had no thrills to report but he does get excited pretty easily–nine times in last week’s earnings call. Most people in the Bay Area get excited when the Giants win the World Series, but for Zuckerberg it’s a new ad platform, deep linking or “partnering with credit card companies.”

This is fine, in a nerdy way. But the point is, on Wall Street nobody cares about excitement levels, even with an influential executive like Zuckerberg. The numbers Facebook delivered meant everything in the selloff. The emotional state over at Hacker Way meant nothing. So why do executives even bother?

Sometimes the hyperbole defies common sense, as when Greg Blatt, chairman of IAC’s Match Group, which owns OKCupid and Tinder, explained that Tinder isn’t being monetized right now but that he “couldn’t be happier.” But wouldn’t surging revenue and profits from the popular Tinder app make him happier? Because it would probably make investors in IAC feel better.

Perhaps the king of earnings hyperbole is Apple’s Tim Cook. Which seems strange because Cook gives off this constant Zen vibe. “It’s just absolutely stunning,” Cook said about Mac sales to a group of investors who were completely not stunned. Later, Cook added, “I could not be more excited about the road ahead in fiscal 2015.”

At one point in last week’s call, Cook said he “couldn’t be happier” about Apple’s ability to supply its new iPhone lines. Then, only a few seconds later, he said he “couldn’t be happier with the way demand looks.” Which is either a direct contradiction or a crazy business koan that, once cracked, will yield immediate enlightenment.

The effect of such relentless hyperbole is that, when companies do have good news to be excited about, investors just dismiss it as more hollow rhetoric. Instead, it’s the immediate, often knee-jerk reaction to the stock price that sets the consensus on how well or poorly a company is performing financially. The thicker the happy feelings are layered on, the more they are distrusted as more corporate spin.

Of course, such grandiose language is also to be found outside of the tech industry. Starbucks CEO Howard Schultz on Friday said he was “beyond thrilled” to be announcing—not blowout profits or guidance surpassing Wall Street’s hopes—but a new roastery Starbucks is opening in December.

Maybe Schultz is on to something. Taking his words “beyond thrilled” at face value could be good advice for overexcited executives in general: Hurry up and get past your declarations thrills/excitements/pleasures. Because the rest of the market is already well beyond caring about them.

And while you’re at it, more numbers would be helpful.

More Must-Reads from TIME

Contact us at letters@time.com