The 2016 List of Best U.S. Colleges Is Now Out

3 minute read

At midnight on Wednesday, U.S. News & World Report released its 2016 Best Colleges list, the magazine’s annual survey that, for more than three decades, has been one of the most prominent if at times controversial metrics of academic excellence in American higher education.

The rankings, which assess nearly 1,800 colleges and universities on 16 criteria rarely see drastic change from year to year, and the latest iteration is no exception. For the third consecutive year, the top three spots on the list of national universities reliably went to Princeton, Harvard, and Yale Universities — the “Big Three,” in admissions industry slang — in that order. Columbia, Stanford, and the University of Chicago all placed fourth, as they did last year.

Johns Hopkins University enjoyed the only significant climb within the holding pattern. After years of hovering in the low teens (then making its way to 12th last year), Hopkins has eked its way into the coveted top ten shortlist for the first time since 2000, pushing out Dartmouth College to tie with the California Institute of Technology.

Not every upward trajectory continued. The University of Notre Dame, which had jumped three spots since 2011 to tie with Brown University at 16th last year, fell back to 18th this time around.

Boys and Girls Together: When Co-Ed College Dorms Were New

Oberlin College, 1970.Bill Ray—TIme & Life Pictures/Getty Images
Oberlin College co-ed dorm, 1970.
Caption from LIFE. "Oberlin students Rob Singler and Cindy Stewart, here shown in Rob's room, live in a co-ed dorm housing 23 boys and 26 girls. Since meeting this fall, they have become very close."Bill Ray—TIme & Life Pictures/Getty Images
Oberlin College co-ed dorm, 1970
Oberlin, co-ed dorm, 1970.Bill Ray—TIme & Life Pictures/Getty Images
Oberlin College 1970
Caption from LIFE. "During Rob Singler's radio show, Cindy Stewart keeps him company. They have been going together all fall but continue to see other friends."Bill Ray—TIme & Life Pictures/Getty Images
Oberlin College co-ed dorm, 1970
Caption from LIFE. "The sexes share laundry centers in coed dorms. Above, freshman Debbie Seim irons while Roger Schachat, a visiting friend of another student, inspects his clothing."Bill Ray—TIme & Life Pictures/Getty Images
Holy Kempner, a freshman in Dascomb Hall, talks with her friends Nick Muni and David Jensen (back to the camera), Oberlin, 1970.
Holly Kempner, a freshman in Dascomb Hall, talks with her friends Nick Muni and David Jensen (back to the camera), Oberlin, 1970.Bill Ray—TIme & Life Pictures/Getty Images
Oberlin College co-ed dorm, 1970
Oberlin College, 1970.Bill Ray—TIme & Life Pictures/Getty Images
Oberlin College co-ed dorm, 1970
Oberlin College dorm, 1970.Bill Ray—TIme & Life Pictures/Getty Images
Oberlin College co-ed dorm, 1970
Oberlin College dorm, 1970.Bill Ray—TIme & Life Pictures/Getty Images
Oberlin College co-ed dorm, 1970.Bill Ray—TIme & Life Pictures/Getty Images
Oberlin College co-ed dorm, 1970
Caption from LIFE. "Each of the Oberlin dorms is run by a student staff and a house director. The student staff in South Hall (238 students) meets for a Napalese dinner in the living room of director Christine Larson (center rear)."Bill Ray—TIme & Life Pictures/Getty Images
Oberlin College, 1970
Oberlin College, 1970.Bill Ray—TIme & Life Pictures/Getty Images
Oberlin College, 1970
Oberlin College, 1970.Bill Ray—TIme & Life Pictures/Getty Images
Oberlin College, 1970
Oberlin College, 1970.Bill Ray—TIme & Life Pictures/Getty Images
Oberlin College 1970
"There is usually plenty of mixed activity in the corridors of Oberlin's co-ed dorms. Above is the third corridor at Damask Hall."Bill Ray—TIme & Life Pictures/Getty Images
Oberlin College 1970
"French House students collect in the corridor for their regular late evening talk."Bill Ray—TIme & Life Pictures/Getty Images
Oberlin College co-ed dorm, 1970
Oberlin College co-ed dorm, 1970.Bill Ray—TIme & Life Pictures/Getty Images

Plan for college: Use MONEY’s Find Your Fit tool to create custom college rankings based on what’s important to you

Williams, Amherst, and Swarthmore Colleges respectively took the top three positions on the scoresheet of liberal arts colleges for at least the fifth year in a row. Immediately behind them, a four-way tie: Bowdoin, Middlebury, Pomona, and Wellesley Colleges all took fourth place.

“To find the best fit, students should consider a range of factors, from financial aid offerings and location to campus size and majors,” Brian Kelly, editor and chief content officer at U.S. News, said in a statement that accompanied the rankings’ release. “The process can be overwhelming, but our rankings and advice content are a great place to start.”

The rankings have been the subject of controversy. Some argue that they are more a catalyst than a barometer. For college-bound teenagers, they say, the rankings perpetuate popular illusions of a college’s desirability (or lack thereof), which impacts a school’s acceptance rate, which in turn factors into a school’s U.S. News score — a hypothesis argued by a 2008 University of Michigan study that showed a”substantial improvement in admissions indicators” at those schools that appeared at the top of U.S. News’ list the previous autumn.

Some lament the idea that the importance of rankings could entice the colleges themselves to shift policy — or fabricate data altogether — to fill a rubric conducive to a higher score.

“Some schools or college presidents or boards have used wanting to improve in the rankings as an administrative goal. Some schools are targeting their academic policies toward improving in the rankings,” Robert Morse, director of data research at U.S. News, said to TIME in 2009.

See the 10 Healthiest Cities to Live in America

Honolulu, Hawaii
Honolulu, Hawaii Best Place for Lifelong Health The heavenly climate helps, but the key to well-being here also includes enviable health care and a rich cultural tradition of looking out for one another.Colin Anderson—Blend Images/Corbis
San Francisco, California
San Francisco Bay Area, Calif. Best Place for Eating Right. The "farm to table" movement began here. The region's bounty of produce and year-round growing season make eating healthy—and local—a natural.Getty Images
Burlington, Vermont
Burlington, Vt. Best Place for Raising Healthy Kids This New England city offers great schools, excellent pediatric care, loads of culture and limitless options for healthy outdoor fun all year long.Matt Hogan/www.mphoganphoto.com
Silicon Valley
Silicon Valley, Calif. Best Place for Workplace Wellness With treadmill desks, meetings on bikes, time off for creativity, and gobs of organic food, tech titans are reinventing how to stay healthy on the job.Jim Wilson—The New York Times/Redux
Minneapolis, Minnesota
Minneapolis-St. Paul, Minn. Best Place for Aging Well Yes, it can be cold. But with a plethora of stimulating activities and a robust web of support, the Twin Cities prove that growing old doesn't mean slowing down.Getty Images
Boulder, Colorado
Denver and Boulder, Colo. Best Place for Keeping Fit The urge to get outside and get moving is contagious in these Rocky Mountain cities, where physical challenge is built into the landscape.Celin Serbo—Aurora Photos/Corbis
Plano, Texas
Plano, Texas Best Place for Staying Safe Once a rural outpost, this booming, diverse city has kept its small-town vibe, thanks in part to a police force and community that knows how to work together.Misty Keasler—Redux for TIME
Portland, Oregon
Portland, Ore. Best Place for a Healthy Environment Small, walkable neighborhoods, 300 miles of bike paths, and urban policies that foster active living and sustainability make for one clean, green city.Getty Images
Boston, Massachusetts
Boston, Mass. Best Place for Health Care This history-rich city is home to some of the nation's most advanced medical institutions and policies that help ensure that quality care is available to all.K.C. Cohen—Courtesy of Boston Children's Hospital
Provo, Utah
Provo and Orem, Utah Best Place for Spiritual Well-Being A stunning Rocky Mountain backdrop and a tight-knit population that lives its faith contribute not only to this region's serenity but also to lower rates of disease.Getty Images

 

More Must-Reads from TIME

Contact us at letters@time.com