See Jason Sudekis Down a Nasty Cocktail During Drinking Game with Jimmy Fallon

When you were a kid, did you ever wonder what would happen if you mixed the contents of your parents’ liquor cabinet together?

Well, on Thursday night Jason Sudeikis and Jimmy Fallon got to experience a version of that when they played a game called Drinko on The Tonight Show.

The game involved dropping colored disks down a maze and then drinking whatever combination the two disks fell into. The options were as varied as beer, pea soup, Tang, pickle juice and Yoo Hoo.

First up it was Fallon’s turn and he was forced to drink a mix of Capri Sun and bubble tea (a Taiwanese tea drink with milk and tapioca balls).

“If you puke we put it right back in,” Sudeikis said as Fallon downed the frothy liquid.

Next up it was the Sleeping with Other People star’s turn. When one of the disks got stuck, he put his fist near it and asked, “Can I Fonz it?” referring to Henry Winkler’s character for the ’70s sitcom Happy Days. He did, and the disks fell into wine spritzer – and bubble tea, again.

“Why is bubble tea a thing?” Sudeikis asked.

As he prepared to knock back the glass, he said, “It’s the chunks that get ya.”

Fallon lost the final round and had to drink a combo of beer and peppermint schnapps. “I think I’ve done this before,” he laughed.

The crowd cheered as Sudeikis offered to drink tequila with a pickle juice chaser, but they weren’t the only ones supporting the former Saturday Night Live star on Thursday.

His fiancée Olivia Wilde shared a pic on Instagram of their son, Otis, 16 months, backstage at the show.

“Cheering Dad on in the dressing room,” she captioned the pic.

This article originally appeared on People.com

Bill Murray is Dave’s first guest (1982)

For Letterman, Murray has dressed like Liberace, a Kentucky Derby jockey and a Renaissance fop. His first visit set the tone of the show when, after a long rant in which Murray decried the host’s “mind games,” Letterman responded, “Now that you’re well-known, is it harder to be funny?”

Andy Kaufman challenges wrestler Jerry Lawler to a match (1982)

In a hoax bit, comedian Kaufman got pro wrestler Lawler to slap him in the face as Letterman smirked behind the desk. The stunt confirmed Dave’s status as a comedy chaos magnet—a master at remaining calm while hysteria swirled around him.

Dave gets dunked in a suit made of 3,400 Alka-Seltzers (1984)

What some do for science, Dave did for comedy. With a snorkel and goggles in place, Dave was dunked into a fizzy experiment in laughter. He’s helpless in his harness, floating in an effervescent water tank surrounded by the volcanic chaos of bubbles. The experiment was duplicated with the likes of sponges, marshmallows and velcro, showing how far Dave would go for a laugh.

The very first top 10 list (1985)

“Heats.” “Rice.” “Moss.” These were the initial entries in the show’s first Top 10 list, “Things That Almost Rhyme With Peas.” Sometimes presented by politicians, celebrities, sports champions and everyday heroes, the lists—more than 4,600 of them—became Letterman’s signature bit.

Cher calls Dave an a–hole (1986)

Dave’s meta-deconstruction of the late night form led to uncomfortable truths — such as in this segment, where an interview with Cher centered on why it took four years for her to agree to appear on the show. Her casual reasoning — “because I thought you were an a–hole” — became part of the show’s disarming folklore.

Madonna won’t stop stop cursing (March 31, 1994)

Letterman often had a flirty effect on female guests, causing many to leave filters at the door. Here, Madonna and Dave giggled and teased, discussing their underwear and making innuendos. Madonna sweetly told Dave he was a “sick f-ck.” Never has that term sounded quite so loving.

Drew Barrymore flashes Dave for his birthday (April 12, 1995)

In a ’90s version of Marilyn Monroe’s “Happy Birthday, Mr. President,” a 20-year-old, braless Barrymore surprised Dave with a dirty dance on his desk, followed by lifting her shirt. Dave’s reaction—confused but joyful surprise—contributed to the buzz.

Dave gets personal (2000 & 2009)

It’s one thing to be a great host with a knack for comedic moments. It’s another entirely to tap into the national psyche. Dave was long regarded as the king of irony, but that died in 2000, when he dropped all comedic facades to pay tribute to the surgical team that saved his life. It was a rare but powerful moment when Dave the host became Dave the man—a feeling that would be replicated as his messy personal cheating scandal went public nine years later—and his brittle realness drew us even closer to the legend we thought we knew.

Dave gives a heartfelt post-9/11 monologue (2001)

The first late-night host to return to TV, Letterman gave viewers real catharsis following a national tragedy. His eight-minute introduction was halting, honest and vulnerable, tapping into our collective fear and sadness. By the end, he also provided what we needed most: courage and hope.

Joaquin Phoenix is bizarre and rambling (Feb 2009)

Phoenix devised a meta-hoax that found him growing a long beard and claiming to have left acting for hip-hop. Included in this, for reasons not quite clear, was appearing on Letterman like he had no idea what was happening around him. Letterman fired questions at Phoenix despite the guest’s inability to string together a sentence. Ending the interview with, “Joaquin, I’m sorry you couldn’t be here tonight,” cemented the segment as a classic.