• History

How One of History’s Best April Fools’ Day Pranks Was Debunked

3 minute read

Although the exact origin of April Fools’ Day is uncertain, playing springtime pranks is a nearly universal custom, adopted around the globe and throughout history — perhaps, some have suggested, beginning with the Roman festival of Hilaria, which was celebrated by dressing up in disguise. Over the past century, April 1 hijinks have become a mainstay of Western culture.

One of the more legendary jokes came in 1934, when a German news magazine published a photo of a man on skis, propelling himself into the air by blowing into a straw to turn a pair of rotors. Many American newspapers were taken in by the hoax, including the New York Times, which ran the photo with the caption, “Man flies on his own power for the first time in history.”

TIME, however, was not fooled, as an article from later that month made clear:

Surely Pilot Kocher‘s exploit was major news, yet not one word of it had appeared in print in the U. S. until the pictures arrived. There was good reason why. Pilot Kocher had flown only in the fertile imaginations of the editors of Berliner Illustrirte Zeitung, who had cooked up the pictures for their magazine’s famed annual April Fool edition. Hearst’s International News had been gloriously hoaxed, and the U. S. Press with it. But in borrowing the Illustrirte Zeitung‘s feature, the International News editors missed two ingenious points: 1) The pilot did not simply blow the rotors around by sheer lung-power. He breathed normally into the box, in which a marvelous chemical contrivance converted the carbon dioxide of his breath into fuel to run a small motor which turned the rotors! (As everyone should know, carbon dioxide is anything but combustible.) 2) The pilot’s name, Koycher (not Kocher), was a freak spelling of Kencher which means “puffer” or “hot air merchant.”

But it wasn’t long before the kind of flight news that would have once been an obvious hoax began to seem feasible: in 1937, faux-pilot Koycher showed up again in the pages of TIME, but as a counterexample. “Three years ago, like many another newspaper, the New York Times carried an astonishing picture of a man on skis propelling himself off the ground by puffing into a pair of rotors. It turned out to be an April Fooler concocted by the editors of Germany’s Berliner Illustrirte Zeitung,” TIME noted. “Last week, however, the feat which Icarus and Leonardo da Vinci made famous by failure was finally achieved. In Milan, where Leonardo experimented with flapping wings 400 years ago, Pilot Vittorio Bonomi took off, flew five-eighths of a mile in a bicycle plane worked only by his own strength.”

Read TIME’s 1934 debunking of the lung-powered flight, here in the TIME Vault: Daedalus

PHOTOS: Beautiful Long Exposures of Airplanes at Night

College Point Blvd., College Point, Queens, N.Y., June 2014.
College Point Blvd., College Point, Queens, N.Y., June 2014.Kevin Kunstadt
36th Ave., Flushing, Queens, N.Y., June 2014.
36th Ave., Flushing, Queens, N.Y., June 2014.Kevin Kunstadt
Hermon MacNeil Park, College Point, Queens, N.Y., June 2014.
Hermon MacNeil Park, College Point, Queens, N.Y., June 2014.Kevin Kunstadt
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, N.Y., June 2014.
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, N.Y., June 2014.Kevin Kunstadt
East Williamsburg, Brooklyn, N.Y., June 2014.
East Williamsburg, Brooklyn, N.Y., June 2014.Kevin Kunstadt for TIME
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, N.Y., June 2014.
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, N.Y., June 2014.Kevin Kunstadt for TIME
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, N.Y., June 2014.
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, N.Y., June 2014.Kevin Kunstadt for TIME
Queens Botanical Garden, Flushing, Queens, N.Y., June 2014.
Queens Botanical Garden, Flushing, Queens, N.Y., June 2014.Kevin Kunstadt
Flushing, N.Y., July 2014.
Flushing, N.Y., July 2014.Kevin Kunstadt
Ocean Blvd., Atlantic Beach, N.Y., July 2014.
Ocean Blvd., Atlantic Beach, N.Y., July 2014.Kevin Kunstadt for TIME
Spray View Ave., Far Rockaway, N.Y., July 2014.
Spray View Ave., Far Rockaway, N.Y., July 2014.Kevin Kunstadt for TIME

More Must-Reads From TIME

Contact us at letters@time.com