• Entertainment

The ‘Blurred Lines’ Ruling Is the First of Its Kind

2 minute read
Updated: | Originally published: ;

This article has been enhanced with interactive sound clips. To hear the sound clips, click the phrases highlighted in red.

A jury ruled Tuesday that Pharrell Williams and Robin Thicke copied Marvin Gaye on their 2013 hit “Blurred Lines,” awarding the Gaye family nearly $7.4 million dollars in a verdict that could have a chilling effect on pop music.

You don’t have to be trained musician to spot the similarities between
soundFile=http://time.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/blurred-lines-clip.mp3|
startPosition=1|
endPosition=5750|
content= “Blurred Lines” and Gaye’s 1977 song
soundFile=http://time.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/got-to-give-it-up-clip.mp3|
startPosition=1|
endPosition=7500|
content= “Got to Give It Up.” Listen for yourself: Both begin with skittering, light-on-their-feet drum beats punctuated by a few pulsing bass notes; both Gaye and Thicke begin the track showing off their falsettos, though Thicke drops the high notes shortly after. Williams argued that he had just been “channeling that feeling, that late-’70s feeling” (and you can’t copyright feelings), but Gaye’s copyright applied only to the sheet music version of the song—the jury didn’t even hear the official recording in court—which means the case came down to the actual nuts and bolts of the songwriting.

Historically, these kinds of legal disputes are settled by insiders who can analyze note-for-note the stretches of the song coming under scrutiny, the Los Angeles Times reports. But while the “Blurred Lines” case had plenty of expert testimony from musicologists and industry executives, they ultimately didn’t get to make the call—regular people did.

“It’s never been based on a jury’s opinion,” Irving Azoff, the chairman and CEO of Azaoff MSG Entertainment (which reps Williams) told the Los Angeles Times. “If we’re now entering into a gray area, that’s very scary.” By putting it to a jury, the debate was turned over to relatively untrained ears, which makes this ruling a particularly slippery slope for both songwriters and artists.

Read next: Here’s Exactly How Much Money ‘Blurred Lines’ Made

Artists Who Have Never Won A Grammy

Photo of QUEEN
QueenJohn Rodgers—Redferns/Getty Images
'60s R&B Quintet "Jackson 5"
Jackson 5Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images
Spice Girls
Spice GirlsRay Burmiston—Photoshot/Getty Images
Pepsi Super Bowl XLIX Halftime Show
Kevin Mazur—WireImage/Getty Images
RBC Royal Bank Bluesfest - Ottawa, ON
BjörkMark Horton—WireImage/Getty Images
Diana Ross Performs In Dublin
Diana Ross performs in Dublin.ShowBizIreland/Getty Images
2014 iHeartRadio Music Festival - Night 1 - Show
Nicki MinajDenise Truscello—WireImage/Getty Images
Janis Joplin
Janis JoplinEvening Standard/Getty Images
Photo of Patti SMITH
Patti SmithDick Barnatt—Redferns/Getty Images
"How The West Was Won" Tour - Irvine, CA
Snoop DoggGabriel Olsen—FilmMagic/Getty Images
Photo of Jimi HENDRIX
Jimi HendrixDavid Redfern—Redferns/Getty Images
The Who
The WhoThe Visualeyes Archive/Redferns/Getty Images
Photo of Jim MORRISON and DOORS
The DoorsGunter Zint—Redferns/Getty Images
Led Zeppelin File Photos
Led ZeppelinChris Walter—WireImage/Getty Images
Photo of Flavor FLAV and Chuck D and PUBLIC ENEMY
Public EnemyDavid Corio—Redferns/Getty Images
Journey
JourneyMichael Putland—Getty Images
Kiss
KissMichael Putland—Getty Images
Photo of Run DMC
Run-D.M.C.Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images
The Ramones
RamonesRoberta Bayley—Evening Standard/Hulton Archive/Getty Images
Andre Agassi's 6th Grand Slam for Children Fundraiser - Show
Brian McKnightKMazur—WireImage/Getty Images
Fun Fun Fun Fest 2014
NasMerrick Ales—FilmMagic/Getty Images
Iggy Pop 1988
Iggy PopFrans Schellekens—Redferns/Getty Images
Kid Rock In Concert
Kid RockScott Legato—Getty Images

Listen to the most important stories of the day.

More Must-Reads from TIME

Write to Nolan Feeney at nolan.feeney@time.com