3 Times a Personal Loan Might Make Sense, and 3 Times It Definitely Doesn’t

Photo illustration to accompany article on whether you should get a personal loan Getty Images

We want to help you make more informed decisions. Some links on our site — clearly marked — will take you to a partner website and may result in us earning a referral commission. For more information, see How We Make Money.

Personal loans can be taken out for just about anything: debt consolidation, medical bills, a ballooning wedding budget. It’s this flexibility that makes personal loans both appealing and potentially dangerous for the borrower. 

Whatever your reason for getting a personal loan, if you don’t have a plan for how to pay it back, you could be on the hook for thousands of dollars that could’ve been saved or invested elsewhere. A late payment — or worse, a defaulted loan — could put you in bad standing with credit bureaus, making it harder to take out a credit card or rent an apartment someday.

Given the COVID-19 pandemic and record levels of unemployment, and with experts pointing to a tendency for more people to apply for loans during a recession, more people are likely looking at personal loans right now as a way to bridge the gap between their bills and income. More than 20 million consumers have a personal loan, and the average debt per borrower is $8,402. 

The experts we spoke to said personal loans can be useful for debt consolidation in this time — but it may be more difficult to get one, due to increased application volume and tightened lending standards. It’s still worth applying if you decide you need one, but people who are unemployed may find that lenders have implemented strict income or employment verification requirements or raised interest rates.

Before taking out a personal loan, ask yourself: Can I afford to take on debt? Am I getting the best deal? What would I be giving up by taking on debt? Would a loan be necessary now?

Here are six common reasons why people seek out personal loans, and whether or not it’s a good idea to get one during the COVID-19 pandemic.

When a Personal Loan Makes Sense

Debt consolidation

Consolidating credit card debt is one of the most popular use cases for personal loans. Anuj Nayar, financial health officer at LendingClub, says, “When we first started in 2008, we positioned ourselves as just a better way to get a loan for whatever you wanted. It could be home improvements, vacations, whatever. What we found was that customers were overwhelmingly coming to us for debt consolidation — and the vast majority of that was people looking to refinance credit cards to get themselves back on a path to financial health.”

At an average APR of 15%, with some cards exceeding 25%, credit card debt can be expensive and overwhelming. It’s a difficult treadmill to get off, so personal loans can be beneficial. To cover the debt, you take out a fixed amount of money at a fixed interest rate, and you pay a fixed monthly payment. 

With proper budget planning and automated payments in place, managing personal loan debt can be simpler than managing credit card debt, the interest rate of which is usually variable. For comparison, personal loan interest rates can range between 5% to 36%, depending on your creditworthiness and the terms of the loan. But to be clear, since loan interest rates can easily exceed the rates on higher credit cards, this move only makes sense if you can get a personal loan with a lower interest rate than your credit card APR.

If you are having issues with managing debt, we recommend getting in touch with your creditor first. Oftentimes — and especially now with the pandemic — lenders are willing to work with you in times of hardship. Whether it’s deferring payments, negotiating a lower interest rate or monthly payment, or waiving fees, getting an accommodation from your lender will make it easier on you and your credit score in the long run.

Home repairs

Home improvement, whether it’s a renovation or repair, is another common reason to take out a personal loan. In the event of a leaking roof, termites, or utility issues, it may behoove you to get a personal loan to help with the significant up-front costs and pay back the expense over time. However, if you’re thinking about knocking out walls for an open floor plan or digging up the backyard to build a pool, consider whether this is an important reason to take on potentially tens of thousands in debt and what a reasonable loan amount would be. 

“Don’t overborrow,” says Farnoosh Torabi, finance journalist and host of the “So Money” podcast. “With any kind of debt that you take on, especially a personal loan, you don’t want it to be more than 5 to 10% of your monthly budget.”

And again, it’s important to have a plan — and the means — to pay back a loan, especially for nonessential home repairs that could potentially be put off for the time being. It might make more sense to take out a loan for a long-planned home repair if you’re confident in your job security than if you could be facing a layoff or furlough related to the pandemic.

Funerals

First off, the Funeral Consumers Alliance, a nonprofit consumer advocacy organization, does not recommend taking out a loan to finance a funeral, due to the high interest rates these loans often come with. 

That said, the average cost of a funeral was $7,360 in 2017, according to the National Funeral Directors Association. It’s a staggering amount of money for most people, but especially those in the midst of grieving a loved one and perhaps navigating financial uncertainty elsewhere. If a funeral cannot be paid for out of pocket or with life insurance, then surviving family members might find themselves looking at personal loans as a measure of last resort. 

We agree that personal loans should be an absolute last resort when facing funeral costs, but if you believe they are necessary for your circumstances, you should at least request loan estimates from multiple lenders to get a rate and terms that will cause as little additional hardship down the line as possible. 

When a Personal Loan Doesn’t Make Sense

Weddings

According to the 2020 WeddingWire Newlywed Report, couples spend $30,000 on average on their wedding. The cost has increased each year as nice-to-haves — like bridesmaid robes, wedding favors, and day-after brunches — morph into essential expenses. Many services, such as catering and venues, automatically cost more if the word “wedding” is uttered once, so it’s a no-brainer that people may want to get a personal loan to manage the rising costs. 

We do not recommend taking on debt to pay for a wedding, though. Incurring $30,000 in debt at the start of a marriage will add unnecessary pressure to this new life stage and limit your ability to invest in a home, savings, or retirement accounts.

Vacations

Some people use personal loans to pay for travel expenses, such as flights, hotels, and excursions, and pay off the debt in the months or years after. Before you call your bank to get funding for a trip to Venice or Lake Tahoe — it’s important to note that these loans can be expensive and charge high interest for those with poor credit. 

It can also be a rude awakening to come back from vacay with a large bill and no way to pay it back. Nayar from LendingClub says that personal loans are best used for emergencies or financial recovery, not to “further an Instagram lifestyle.”

Student debt

Personal loans can be used to consolidate all kinds of debt, including, yes, student loans. However, it’s generally not recommended, unless you have student loans with unusually high interest rates. Most student loans have rates lower than personal loans, and when you repay with personal loans, you lose access to deferments, forbearances, and other types of payment arrangements.