A woman crashes her car into the White House barricades and then careers off toward the Capitol, where she is shot and killed–in an unnecessary fusillade–by Capitol police, who are working without pay because of the government shutdown. The next day, a man incinerates himself on the Mall. Is it just me, or is there a whiff of the apocalypse in the air? It isn’t hard to locate the immediate cause of the shutdown and impending debt-ceiling debacle: the radical nihilist minority of the Republican Party and the GOP’s craven leadership. Words should not be minced here. These radicals–it is wildly inaccurate to call them conservatives–are a pestilence feeding on ignorance and cynicism, preying on fear as a period of unprecedented prosperity wanes. They are not the apocalypse but represent the desperate last gasp of the white majority and of an era. My generation’s era.
My work in journalism began almost exactly 44 years ago at a suburban newspaper just north of Boston; very quickly, I found my true niche in Boston’s vibrant underground press. The memories of that time have overwhelmed me during the current crisis, helped along by a rising tide of articles comparing today’s Tea Party to the left-wing radicals of my youth. There is some facile merit to this, but also important substantive differences. The old New Left featured a moral absolutism that didn’t wear very well over time, but was based in a dream of justice. We opposed a criminally foolish war; we marched for racial equality. But by the time I started work, righteousness was beginning to curdle into self-righteousness and then devolve into nihilism. The weekly newspaper I worked for ran a photo of Richard Nixon–oh, for a Republican like Nixon now!–with a shark’s mouth. Nixon drove liberals nuts, turned moderates into extremists, much the same way Barack Obama affects conservatives today. But there is no equivalency here: Nixon was a moderate politician, except for the carnage he sponsored in Vietnam, but a palpable crook. Obama is also a moderate politician–the individual mandate and health care exchanges that are at the heart of Obamacare were Republican ideas–but he has been pilloried and calumniated by extremists like Senator Ted Cruz’s father, who recently said the President was “likely to side with the Muslims” and called Obamacare “suicide counseling.” No doubt many of the more lunatic anti-Obama excretions have a basis in racism.
The real similarity between the Tea Party and the New Left is a matter of style: a politics of confrontation rather than of compromise. Indeed, our generational tendency toward public melodrama provided the script for the inevitable backlash. The pro-life movement came first, after the Roe v. Wade decision in 1973: suddenly it was opponents of abortion who were filling the Mall with placards and protests. Eventually, the Tea Party’s don’t tread on me flag–a brilliant piece of choreography–joined the peace symbol as an icon. The left was never able to elect a President as ideological as Ronald Reagan–though he, too, was a moderate compared with today’s bullyraggers–or to hijack the government, as the Tea Party has, but it was every bit as solipsistic. It was all about street theater, bombast, showtime. “Bread and circuses is not the policy of a republic,” William Galston wrote recently in the Wall Street Journal, “but rather of an empire entering moral senescence.”
I am not saying the baby-boom generation caused the government shutdown, but we’ve presided over an era during which public trust in government has been demolished. We allowed the influence of concentrated money to corrupt our democracy. We allowed the gerrymandering of congressional districts, especially the racial gerrymandering that became legal after the 1965 Voting Rights Act, to make it less likely that politicians would run in districts with a centrist majority. We were brilliant at marketing, which plays to our niche differences. All of which conspired to make the political parties ideologically coherent rather than confusing regional coalitions. Those coalitions allowed a system where compromise was easier than confrontation. There would have been no New Deal without Southern Democrats, no Medicare without Northern Republicans.
We are far from that now. My generation has done wonderful things–increased equality across racial, gender and orientation lines; rock ‘n’ roll; The Sopranos; Whole Foods–but we have made a hash of government. We failed to bring our democracy into the information age; instead we brought it to a precipice. We allowed lobbyists to fester, turning every major piece of legislation into an encyclopedia of contradictions. There is some polling evidence that the millennial generation will be different, more collegial. I certainly hope so. Our sell-by date has passed.
TO READ JOE’S BLOG POSTS, GO TO time.com/swampland
More Must-Reads from TIME
- Introducing the 2024 TIME100 Next
- Sabrina Carpenter Has Waited Her Whole Life for This
- What Lies Ahead for the Middle East
- Why It's So Hard to Quit Vaping
- Jeremy Strong on Taking a Risk With a New Film About Trump
- Our Guide to Voting in the 2024 Election
- The 10 Races That Will Determine Control of the Senate
- Column: How My Shame Became My Strength
Contact us at letters@time.com