John Hughes couldn’t stay in his seat. As his daughter Sarah glided onto Olympic ice for the ladies’ long program, he stationed himself at the door between the arena and the cavernous hallway that girdles the Salt Lake Ice Center. His equally nervous wife Amy paced the corridor, on patrol between the gourmet coffee stands and the hot-dog vendors. With every element that Sarah polished off during her 4 1/2-min. program, John would bolt outside and report, “She’s doing it. She’s doing it!”
Amy already knew. The roar of the crowd was swelling as Sarah checked off jumps and spins with the precision of a sharpshooter until the crescendo drowned out the last few seconds of her music. When Sarah’s final spin circled to a halt, John and Amy ran inside and joined in the thunderous applause for their 16-year-old daughter’s history-making performance last Thursday. After her “top this” scores were posted, Hughes slipped backstage and did something she had never done before at the end of a competition–she called her mother. “Mom, I did it,” she said. “I did it!”
Since Hughes was the first of the medal contenders to skate, she didn’t know exactly what she had done. Or that her program would weather assaults from Sasha Cohen, favorite Michelle Kwan and Russia’s Irina Slutskaya to stand, at the end of the evening, as worthy of Olympic gold. As she came off the ice, none of that mattered. “Going in, I didn’t think I had a chance for gold, let alone a medal, given who was skating here,” Hughes says. “So I didn’t hold back.”
Sarah Hughes’ performance was the pinnacle of a figure-skating competition tarnished by a judging scandal in the pairs competition that resulted in two gold-medal awards. It also had to withstand a protest by a cranky Russian Olympic federation demanding gold for Slutskaya and threatening to leave the Games over assorted alleged judging improprieties. Hughes refocused attention on the outstanding performances these Olympics offered across a menu of winter sports, before crowds that were full and festive despite an unprecedented level of security.
Hughes didn’t just skate flawlessly. She became the first woman to land two triple-triple jump combinations–the triple Salchow-triple loop and the triple toe-triple loop–in one program. Even more impressive, she is the first skater to fight her way from fourth after the short program to first overall. “It was my greatest skate ever, and it was great that it could happen in my Olympic long program,” she says.
Hughes and coach Robin Wagner made critical adjustments to her program away from the Olympic bustle, in Colorado Springs, during the week before the competition. To build up to a dramatic conclusion, Wagner decided to splice in heavier music in the last 90 sec. And to trade on Hughes’ technical skills, they opted to boost the difficulty quotient by adding the triple toe-triple loop combination. Hughes’ comfort with the program showed in her confident execution of element after element. Her seemingly hopeless fourth-place position in the short program helped free her to skate with abandon.
Hughes’ cool performance chilled her competitors into stiff responses. The eye-catching Cohen, after a solid short program, could not hold the landing of her triple-triple jump, and though she skated on brilliantly, portraying Bizet’s Carmen, her performance lacked the energy of Hughes’ routine. She and Hughes will surely be fighting for honors for years. Kwan clearly lacked magic, skating with little speed and tumbling clumsily and uncharacteristically doing a triple flip halfway through her program. The powerful Slutskaya didn’t fall but stumbled several times.
Still, John and Amy Hughes, thrilled with what they thought was, in the best-case scenario, a bronze-medal finish, learned otherwise only by watching Sarah and Wagner’s reaction on the monitors. “It never dawned on me that she could win,” says Amy. “Fourth in the short–I didn’t understand how you could win.”
In fact, it’s unlikely to happen again. No other skater–in women, men, pairs or ice dancing–has ever made up so much ground at the Olympics. Too much has to happen. Given the contorted mathematics that is the skating judging system, it was not enough for Hughes to win the long program, which she did handily. Kwan, the initial leader, also had to finish third. So it was the final skater, Slutskaya, who would determine all. Barring a once-in-a-lifetime score of her own–unlikely, since her program was not as well constructed as Hughes’–her performance would decide whether Kwan or Hughes would become champion. If Slutskaya finished ahead of Kwan in the long program, which is worth two-thirds of the total score, then Hughes would win. If the Russian finished behind Kwan, then Kwan would win.
Slutskaya, who immediately followed Kwan, has in the past been too rattled to pull off a winning program in the American champion’s wake. Normally a powerful, fast skater who achieves hang time with her jumps, she couldn’t dazzle the Olympic judges enough to overtake Hughes. But her performance to Tosca was enough to surpass Kwan, who double-footed a landing on an early jump and then struggled to maintain her confidence in the rest of the program, falling on the later triple flip. “It just wasn’t my night,” said Kwan again and again. “I don’t know what didn’t go my way.”
Four years is a long time to wait for four minutes on Olympic ice, and this was a hard defeat for the 21-year-old Californian, who won silver at Nagano in 1992. Her disappointment and surprise at finding herself with bronze this time was as deep as Hughes’ ecstatic shock at having defeated her idol. Puffy-eyed from crying when she skated out to receive her medal, Kwan will now wrestle with the burden of dealing with an Olympic victory that has slipped from her hands not once but twice. “I just wanted to come home with the gold,” she said immediately after the competition. “I have to remind myself to keep my head up high.” Her emotions still raw, the tears flowed freely when she left the ice the next evening after her exhibition skate to Fields of Gold.
As the women’s Olympic victor, Hughes, who is still a high school junior, says she is aware of the responsibility the precious medal bestows on her–as a champion, as a representative of the sport. But as she has done throughout her young career, she will refuse to allow this Olympic experience to overwhelm her identity or disrupt her life. Her next goal? High 1500s on the SATs.
More Must-Reads from TIME
- How Donald Trump Won
- The Best Inventions of 2024
- Why Sleep Is the Key to Living Longer
- Robert Zemeckis Just Wants to Move You
- How to Break 8 Toxic Communication Habits
- Nicola Coughlan Bet on Herself—And Won
- Why Vinegar Is So Good for You
- Meet TIME's Newest Class of Next Generation Leaders
Contact us at letters@time.com