Best YA Books That Should Be Movies: Dream Casting for Novels

Betsy-Tacy Series by Maud Hart Lovelace This bunch of literary classics from the 1940s follows best friends Betsy and Tacy for a span of nearly 20 years during the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Coming-of-age in industrial America will only get better with the costumes. Dream casting: Hailee Steinfeld (pictured) and Sophie Turner

HarperCollins; Getty Images

1 of 8
A Separate Peace by John Knowles Yes, technically already two movies (one in 1972 and a Showtime version in 2004) but a boarding school story never gets old — oh captain, my captain. Dream casting: Miles Teller as Finny — in a tie, of course. Parenthood’s Miles Heizer as Gene.

Scribner; Getty Images

2 of 8
Wintergirls by Laurie Halse Anderson This story has the opportunity to make a true impact for teens and parents by shedding light on the heartbreaking effects of bulimia and anorexia. Dream casting: Troian Bellisario as Lia, with Bunheads favorite Julia Goldani Telles as Cassie.

Speak; Getty Images

3 of 8
Belzhar by Meg Wolitzer This soon-to-be published young adult book by The Interestings’ Meg Wolitzer is inspired by the life of Sylvia Plath and is sure to be an all-too-relatable bestseller. Dream casting: Chloe Grace Moretz as Jam

Dutton Juvenile; Getty Images

4 of 8
The Truth About Forever by Sarah Dessen Two of Dessen’s books were merged together for Mandy Moore’s How to Deal in 2003 but fell quite short of impressive. The Truth About Forever mixes typical adolescent issues with love and loss that would shine on screen. Dream casting: Elle Fanning as Macy

Speak; Getty Images

5 of 8
The Magicians by Lev Grossman Harry Potter for the older set still hits a nerve when it comes to young adults in this series by Grossman (who, full disclosure, writes for TIME). Better yet? Its third installment is due out in August. The movie was once picked up as a TV show but the pilot wasn’t green-lit. Dream casting: The Way, Way Back’s Liam James as Quentin

Plume; Getty Images

6 of 8
Prep by Curtis Sittenfeld Misfit Lee Fiora heads to a Massachusetts prep school full of questions about her sexuality, identity and where she falls among the WASP-y elite. Think of it as a not-so-popular girl mingling with the Nate Archibalds of the world. Dream casting: Elizabeth Olsen as Lee.

Random House; Getty Images

7 of 8
Looking for Alaska by John Green Being honest, everything John Green writes could be adapted for the screen and this heartbreaker is no exception. Dream casting: Logan Lerman as Miles Halter while AnnaSophia Robb (pictured) would work wonders with Alaska’s moody and elusive persona.

Speak; Getty Images

8 of 8

April 9, 2014 4:00 PM EDT

With the announcement that Rainbow Rowell’s beloved young adult novel Eleanor and Park will be adapted for film, directly following the news that John Green’s Paper Towns is also headed to the big screen, here are TIME’s recommendations for 8 other YA books worthy of a screenplay — plus, just for fun, the actors who would be perfect in the starring roles.

8 Young Adult Books That Should Be Movies (And Who Should Star in Them)