Blake Lively at the Time 100 Gala at Jazz at Lincoln Center on April 25, 2017 in New York City.
Landon Nordeman for TIME
April 2, 2018 5:05 PM EDT

Blake Lively and Meghan Markle are two of our favorite street style icons, and now even they are dressing alike. When Lively stepped out on Easter Sunday for a party at Martha Stewart’s house (more on that later), the actress chose a camel-colored Smythe coat that Markle wore back in January.

Of course, the jacket sold out almost immediately when Markle first wore it for an outing with future husband Prince Harry, which means that Lively either already had this topper in her closet, or has an “in” with the brand.

While they have the same taste in coats, they styled the jacket very differently. Markle wore it closed and bundled up with a scarf, simple black top, wide-leg pants, and pumps, and Lively wore it open over a cream turtleneck. She paired the striped top with a printed skirt and olive green boots (shop similar here).

As for the occasion, the Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants star was out and about in Bedford, N.Y. to attend an Easter celebration at Martha Stewart’s house with her daughter James. In the past, Stewart had gone on record with some not-so-positive comments about Lively after she launched her now-defunct lifestyle site Preserve.

Read More: Ryan Reynolds Shut Down Rumors About His Marriage to Blake Lively as Only He Can

But it seems all is well now between the two baking aficionados, as Lively later said she was trying to become friends with her new neighbor. In 2014, Lively talked about befriending the lifestyle expert during a Q&A they held together.

“[Ryan Reynolds] rides around on his motorcycle, and Martha said, ‘Oh, I know how to ride a motorcycle, I can go with him.’ That’s the only woman that could creep up on my man! I said to him, ‘Oh, please, go with Martha, it would be so great for us!'” Lively said.

Seems like she’s finally made it.

This article originally appeared on

More Must-Read Stories From TIME

Contact us at

Read More From TIME
You May Also Like