April 8, 2014 8:00 AM EDT

Silly magicians, tricks are for dogs!

In the 100% necessary follow-up to Dogs Reacting to Magic, an intrepid magician tries his hand at impressing cats with his sleight-of-hand tricks.

While the dogs were adorably mystified by the Case of the Disappearing Dog Treats, as it turns out cats just…aren’t that into magic. The magician consistently failed to get the felines interested in next-level prestidigitation, complex card tricks or the ability to make streamers erupt in a seemingly endless flow from his mouth. The most impressive trick the magician managed was to make his cat audience disappear.

MORE: Cute Hedgehog Becomes Even Cuter With a Series of New Faces

MORE: 9 Animals That Are On the Verge of Disappearing Forever

Contact us at letters@time.com.

Read More From TIME

Related Stories