Watch Mark Wahlberg and Jimmy Fallon Give Watermelon Slinging a Shot

On Tuesday’s Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, the host did just that, putting together a competition with guest and Deepwater Horizon actor Mark Wahlberg. In a large setup on New York’s Rockefeller Plaza, the two took turns seeing who could achieve optimum accuracy with summer’s final fruit.

To no one’s surprise, Marky Mark turned out to be naturally talented at the test of strength, casually hitting the central target rings without breaking a sweat and handily beating the host at his own game. It’s not quite watermelons exploding, but you have to give it to Fallon for consistently coming up with wacky ways to showcase his guests’ secret skills.

Watch above.

Write to Raisa Bruner at raisa.bruner@time.com.