When Robert Boetticher, Jr., was in mortuary school in the 1980s, his teachers barely mentioned cremation. And that mindset was reflected in the funeral homes he managed in California the following decade, which weighed heavily toward traditional burial. The fledgling cremation business, meanwhile, was often given to the youngest employees.
“The thought was, ‘It’s just a cremation family,’” Boetticher says. “That was how we managed the process. We didn’t talk through what kind of ceremony they would want. We didn’t focus the kind of energy on it that was often associated with burial.”
Boetticher now runs the Cloverdale Funeral Home, Cemetery and Crematory in Boise, Idaho, and since his time in California, the business has completely flipped. More than 60% of Cloverdale’s clients request cremation, evident in the funeral home’s two cremation gardens filled with benches and pedestals and giant granite monoliths, all designed to hold cremated remains. “You have to embrace the consumer,” Boetticher says.
Last year, the consumer spoke quite clearly. According to industry figures obtained by TIME, cremation surpassed traditional burial rates for the first time in the U.S., a milestone in the transformation of the $16 billion death industry decades in the making. According to the figures TIME reviewed, the Cremation Association of North America projects that in 2015, the cremation rate was almost 49% nationwide compared to the National Funeral Directors Association burial rate estimate of 45%. And both groups expect the trend to continue.
“Cremation has become the new tradition,” says Barbara Kemmis, CANA’s executive director. “It’s a seismic shift in the profession.”
In 1980, the cremation rate around the U.S. was just under 10%, and the percentage has been shifting toward cremation since. Part of the reason is cost—cremation is often thousands of dollars cheaper than burial because it doesn’t require a casket, embalming, or a cemetery plot. It’s been increasingly accepted by organized religions, including the Catholic Church, which historically opposed the practice. It can also be a more sensible choice for a population more mobile than previous generations. Fewer Americans today live and die in the same place, and cremation is often seen as a flexible option for those who have moved far from family plots or hometown cemeteries.
California leads the country in the number of cremations performed each year. In 2015, California cremated 157,012 people, according to CANA’s 2015 projections, followed by Florida (123,671) and Texas (73,882). Nevada, however, leads the nation in the share of cremations at 77.4%, followed by Washington (76.3%) and Oregon (75.8%). Iowa, Wyoming and North Dakota, meanwhile, have seen the biggest increase in cremation rates over the last several years.
That shift has put significant pressure on the industry. The number of funeral homes has fallen almost 10%, according to the NFDA, from 21,495 in 2005 to 19,391 in 2015, in part because of cremation’s popularity. The decrease in the number of funeral homes is even more striking in places like New York City. Since 1990, the number of funeral homes in New York has dropped from 841 to 473, according to Crain’s New York Business. Among the reasons: New Yorkers are living longer, and family-owned funeral homes are being bought out in neighborhoods in Brooklyn and Queens, where real estate prices have spiked.
Still, much of the industry has started adapting to consumers’ waning interest in traditional burial. Many funeral homes now offer an array of cremation products and highly personalized urns, including fireworks that can shoot remains into the sky, vinyl records that hold ashes, and coral reefs made of remains. And like Cloverdale in Boise, funeral homes often have designated areas for cremation ceremonies and memorials.
“I think a lot of funeral directors out there are starting to get it,” says Mike Nicodemus, NFDA’s vice president of cremation services. “They’re starting to see that cremation is not going anywhere and they’re starting to say, We better get on the ball here. But it’s been a slow process.”
The NFDA projects that by 2030, cremation rates will top 70%, a full reversal in roughly 30 years. CANA, which only makes five-year projections, is more cautious in its estimates but does project cremation rates to hit 55% by 2020.
“If funeral directors sit and do nothing as cremation rises, their business is going to take a hit,” Boetticher says. “You’ll always have people who will never embrace cremation. But funeral directors have to reinvent themselves.”
- Taylor Swift Is TIME's 2023 Person of the Year
- Meet the Nation Builders
- Why Cell Phone Reception Is Getting Worse
- Column: It's Time to Scrap the Abraham Accords
- Israeli Family Celebrates Release of Hostage Grandmother
- In a New Movie, Beyoncé Finds Freedom
- The Top 100 Photos of 2023
- Want Weekly Recs on What to Watch, Read, and More? Sign Up for Worth Your Time