April 15, 2016 8:00 AM EDT

Correction appended, April 18, 2016

More than two decades had elapsed since Slash and Axl Rose last played together when Guns N’ Roses first reunited earlier this month—a reunion that will be celebrated on Saturday, as they headline the Coachella music festival. The reunion has been an occasion for eager fans to look back at the decade or so during which the band dominated rock, between their start in 1985 and their sort-of end in 1993, when the band didn’t exactly break up but essentially stopped being able to tolerate one another long enough to make a significant amount of music.

Get your history fix in one place: sign up for the weekly TIME History newsletter

But their internal disputes weren’t the only source of Guns N’ Roses controversy. Their lyrics and image roiled non-fans—but it also helped make them what they were, as TIME explained in 1991:

But when these images from 1985 and 1986 were taken, they’d barely started down that rocky road toward controversy, fame, disputes and reunions. The band at that time was on the brink of fame, just signing to Geffen Records and starting to amass fans (and freak out parents) all across America.

Read the 1991 profile of Guns N’ Roses, here in the TIME Vault: Misfit Metalheads

Correction: The original version of this gallery incorrectly credited several of the photographs. They were taken by Jack Lue.

Write to Lily Rothman at lily.rothman@time.com.

Next Up: Editor's Pick
Why Do We Dream?
EDIT POST