--- title: Antonin Scalia Death: How It Helps Teachers' Unions description: The U.S. Supreme Court was widely expected to deal a mortal blow in June to teachers unions' primary source of funding. Not anymore. canonical: https://time.com/4225942/antonin-scalia-dead-supreme-court-teachers-unions-friedrichs-california-teachers/ author: Haley Sweetland Edwards article:opinion: false article:content_tier: free article:published_time: 2016-02-16T21:07:55.000Z article:modified_time: 2026-02-22T15:07:05.551Z article:section: Politics og:title: How Antonin Scalia's Death Will Help Teachers' Unions og:description: He would have likely ruled against their basic funding model. og:url: https://time.com/4225942/antonin-scalia-dead-supreme-court-teachers-unions-friedrichs-california-teachers/ og:site_name: TIME og:image: https://static.time.com/v3/assets/bltea6093859af6183b/blt2a6146edb2747d7f/69887da2524fc07c11df6c15/antonin-scalia-heart-attack.jpg?branch=production&width=2400&quality=75&auto=webp&crop=16:9 og:image:width: 1200 og:image:height: 675 og:image:alt: Supreme Court Justices Scalia and Ginsburg Discuss First Amendment At Forum og:type: article twitter:card: summary_large_image twitter:title: How Antonin Scalia's Death Will Help Teachers' Unions twitter:description: He would have likely ruled against their basic funding model. twitter:image: https://static.time.com/v3/assets/bltea6093859af6183b/blt2a6146edb2747d7f/69887da2524fc07c11df6c15/antonin-scalia-heart-attack.jpg?branch=production&width=2400&quality=75&auto=webp&crop=16:9 ---  # How Antonin Scalia's Death Will Help Teachers' Unions  by [Haley Sweetland Edwards](https://time.com/author/haley-sweetland-edwards/)  ## Haley Sweetland Edwards Feb 16, 2016 9:07 PM UTC  Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia waits for the beginning of the taping of "The Kalb Report" on April 17, 2014 at the National Press Club in Washington, DC. Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia waits for the beginning of the taping of "The Kalb Report" on April 17, 2014 at the National Press Club in Washington, DC.Alex Wong-Getty Images  by [Haley Sweetland Edwards](https://time.com/author/haley-sweetland-edwards/)  ## Haley Sweetland Edwards Feb 16, 2016 9:07 PM UTC Teachers’ unions may have just gotten a reprieve. The U.S. Supreme Court was widely expected to hit them hard in June by cutting off their primary source of funding: compulsory union dues. In [_Friedrichs v. California Teachers Association_](http://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/friedrichs-v-california-teachers-association/)_,_ a narrow majority of Supreme Court justices was expected to decide that collecting such dues [violate the First Amendment.](http://www.scotusblog.com/2016/01/union-fees-in-jeopardy-in-plain-english/) Justice Antonin Scalia, who [hinted strongly](https://www.the74million.org/article/mehlhorn-how-the-unions-lost-three-swing-votes-and-pushed-the-supreme-court-towards-historic-friedrichs-ruling) during oral arguments in January that he considered mandatory dues unconstitutional, would likely have been a deciding vote. His [unexpected death](http://time.com/4220671/justice-antonin-scalia-death-reactions-video/), at 79, on Saturday throws that decision into question. It also potentially reverses what would have happened to teachers unions, and other public sector unions, had he lived. Here’s how. A decision against the unions in the _Friedrichs_ case would have eviscerated the funding model for California teachers’ unions, which primarily rely on mandatory dues. It also would have cast a giant, Constitution-sized shadow of doubt over almost all public sector unions across the country, which overwhelmingly rely on levying mandatory dues. That because the _Friedrichs_ decision almost definitely would have resulted in overturning a four decade-old ruling in another Supreme Court case called [_Abood v. Detroit Board of Education_](http://usedulaw.com/147-abood-v-detroit-board-of-education.html)_,_ a foundational text for unions. _Abood_ allows public sector employees to collect compulsory or “fair share” dues for the purpose of collective bargaining. Without _Abood,_ union lawyers would be vulnerable to suits challenging any kind of mandatory dues. The idea of putting union lawyers on the defensive is, of course, is a dreamscape for Republicans, who have long sought to make the entire country a so-called “right-to-work” jurisdiction, where no employee can be required to pay mandatory union dues. Part of that’s political. In “right-to-work” states, such as Wisconsin and Mississippi, unions are generally smaller, weaker and hold much less political clout. So a decision to overturn _Abood_ would be a gut punch to Democrats, who rely on the unions as a primary source of political support. The weaker the unions are, the weaker their political support. While we don’t know for sure how any of the justices would have ruled in the _Friedrichs_ case, Scalia had telegraphed that he considered compulsory union dues an affront to the freedom of speech, which includes acts of political expression, like spending money. The _Friedrichs_ decision was always widely expected to break down on ideological lines, with the five conservative justices lining up with Scalia, and the four liberal justices ruling to uphold _Abood_. With Scalia’s death, the _Friedrich_ case will likely end with a 4-4 tie. Under that scenario, the high court would defer to the ruling of the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, which originally decided in favor of the teachers union. If that’s what ends up happening, California’s law, which currently allows compulsory union fees, would stand, as would _Abood_. Other challenges to public sector unions’ ability to collect mandatory fees would be weaker. Labor leaders foresaw the expected _Friedrichs_ decision as essentially a death knell. After all, if all teachers or other workers who benefit from a union’s collective bargaining—higher wages, better health care, etc.—can’t be made to pay compulsory dues, then it creates a free-rider problem and pulls the rug out from underneath the union fundraising model. Those who oppose powerful teachers unions, including the conservative [Center for Individual Rights](https://www.cir-usa.org/), which is arguing the _Friedrichs_ lawsuit, and self-proclaimed “pro-student” groups, such as [The Seventy Four](https://www.the74million.org/article/mehlhorn-student-rights-judicial-precedent-and-why-2016-could-see-a-profound-shift-in-education-law), had celebrated the expected outcome of the case. They generally see compulsory fees as a violation of basic freedoms: why should teachers be forced to pay dues to an organization with whom they disagree? In the _Friedrichs_ case, Rebecca Friedrichs, an elementary school teacher, and nine other non-union teachers in California, argued that mandatory fees amounted to coercing them into support union bargaining positions they didn’t agree with. Joshua Pechthalt, the president of the California Federation of Teachers, said in a statement Sunday that Scalia’s death would likely “result in a delay” in the _Friedrichs_ case, but he stopped short of declaring victory. “I think the public sector unions and the education unions have to continue the organizing we have been doing with the assumption nothing has changed,” he said. Those who would like to unwind the power of teachers unions may not win in _Friedrichs_ case, but there’s no reason to believe they won’t bring similar cases in the future, Pechthalt warned. Whoever is appointed to fill Scalia’s seat “could be interpreting the Constitution for the next generation.” ```json [{"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"NewsArticle","@id":"https://time.com/4225942/antonin-scalia-dead-supreme-court-teachers-unions-friedrichs-california-teachers/","mainEntityOfPage":{"@type":"WebPage","@id":"https://time.com/4225942/antonin-scalia-dead-supreme-court-teachers-unions-friedrichs-california-teachers/"},"headline":"How Antonin Scalia's Death Will Help Teachers' Unions","datePublished":"2016-02-16T21:07:55.000Z","dateModified":"2026-02-22T15:07:05.551Z","description":"The U.S. Supreme Court was widely expected to deal a mortal blow in June to teachers unions' primary source of funding. Not anymore.","url":"https://time.com/4225942/antonin-scalia-dead-supreme-court-teachers-unions-friedrichs-california-teachers/","keywords":["Supreme Court","Education","Antonin Scalia topic"],"thumbnailUrl":"https://static.time.com/v3/assets/bltea6093859af6183b/blt2a6146edb2747d7f/69887da2524fc07c11df6c15/antonin-scalia-heart-attack.jpg?branch=production&width=1200&quality=75&auto=webp&crop=1200:675&height=675","author":[{"@type":"Person","name":"Haley Sweetland Edwards","jobTitle":null,"url":"https://time.com/author/haley-sweetland-edwards/"}],"articleSection":"Politics","image":[{"@type":"ImageObject","url":"https://static.time.com/v3/assets/bltea6093859af6183b/blt2a6146edb2747d7f/69887da2524fc07c11df6c15/antonin-scalia-heart-attack.jpg?branch=production&width=1200&quality=75&auto=webp&crop=1200:675&height=675","width":1200,"height":675,"headline":"Supreme Court Justices Scalia and Ginsburg Discuss First Amendment At Forum","caption":"Supreme Court Justices Scalia and Ginsburg Discuss First Amendment At Forum","creditText":"Alex Wong-Getty Images","representativeOfPage":true}],"publisher":{"@type":"Organization","name":"Time","url":"https://time.com/","logo":{"@type":"ImageObject","url":"https://time.com/images/logo.png","width":528,"height":156},"foundingDate":"March 3, 1923","sameAs":["https://www.facebook.com/time","https://www.instagram.com/time/?hl=en","https://twitter.com/time","https://www.pinterest.com/timemagazine"]}},{"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"BreadcrumbList","itemListElement":[{"@type":"ListItem","position":1,"item":{"@id":"/section/politics/","name":"Politics"}},{"@type":"ListItem","position":2,"item":{"@id":"/tag/supreme-court/","name":"Supreme Court"}},{"@type":"ListItem","position":3,"item":{"@id":"https://time.com/4225942/antonin-scalia-dead-supreme-court-teachers-unions-friedrichs-california-teachers/","name":"How Antonin Scalia's Death Will Help Teachers' Unions"}}]}] ```