January 19, 2016 11:02 AM EST

No one won Jeopardy! Monday night, meaning three new contestants will compete Tuesday night, a stunned Alek Trebek said.

Here’s the “Final Jeopardy” prompt that stumped everyone, from the category of “State Capitals:”

“A 1957 event led to the creation of a National Historic Site in this city, signed into law by a president whose library is now there too.”

The correct response was “Little Rock, Arkansas.” In 1998, President Bill Clinton signed a bill designating Little Rock Central High School as a National Historic Site for its role in the desegregation of schools throughout the United States.

Video of the three-way $0 finish is circulating on Reddit:

Other news outlets point out that there was a three-way loss on the teen version of game show in February 2013, while on the flip side, there was a three-way win on Jeopardy! in March 2007.



Write to Olivia B. Waxman at olivia.waxman@time.com.

Read More From TIME

Related Stories