December 16, 2015 12:16 PM EST

Jennifer Lawrence stopped by Late Night on Tuesday, where she told host Seth Meyers that she once had a big crush on him. She also later revealed another secret celebrity crush.

Lawrence hosted Saturday Night Live a few years ago, back when Meyers was the show’s head writer. She was convinced he was going to ask her out, and when he didn’t, she decided she’d be the one to make the first move. Right before she was planning to give him her number, she found out he was engaged, so she shut it down.

Meyers is now happily married, but he was clearly flattered, because she’s Jennifer freaking Lawrence! He then asked if she’s developed any other celebrity crushes, and she quickly replied that she did—and she’d just been texting her pal Amy Schumer about it.

“I have so many sexual and boyfriend/marriage feelings for Larry David, I feel like I’m gonna be sick,” J.Law wrote to Schumer.

When Meyers said that made him feel “a little less awesome” about Lawrence’s crush on him, she replied, “Don’t. You guys have something special.”

Read next: Check Out the 5 Biggest Highlights from Jennifer Lawrence’s Year

Contact us at

Read More From TIME

Related Stories