December 16, 2015

John Krasinski and Jimmy Kimmel’s prank war has become a holiday tradition over the past four years, and a very amusing one at that. Notable past antics have included Krasinski and wife Emily Blunt covering Kimmel’s entire car in wrapping paper after filling it to the brim with ornaments, but on Tuesday’s episode of Jimmy Kimmel Live!, the pranksters took things up a notch.

Krasinski appeared as a guest on the show and revealed three separate gags he had already played on the late night host, including transforming Kimmel’s office into an elaborate winter wonderland. The 36-year-old actor seemed confident that he had won the year’s battle until Kimmel revealed that he and his team had posted hundreds of yard sale signs around Los Angeles with Krasinski’s face and real address on them. And if that wasn’t enough, Kimmel ended the segment by dowsing his guest in eggnog on live TV.

Watch the full clip above.

Write to Megan McCluskey at

Read More From TIME