October 21, 2015 11:04 AM EDT

Channing Tatum will never truly disguise his extreme hotness — but he got pretty close with his Halloween costume this year. He attended his daughter’s Halloween carnival in this little number:

Yes, that’s noted actor and handsome person Channing Tatum in a low-budge Winnie the Pooh costume. The lumpy, misshapen potbelly and five o’clock shadow really take this ensemble from cute to creepy. He says he’s pretty sure he “terrified all the children” at the carnival, and he’s probably right.

As far as celebrity costumes go, this is pretty good, but it still doesn’t beat Katy Perry’s sad Cheeto from last year.

Read next: Channing Tatum Loves Pinterest and 9 Other Wonderful Things We Learned From His Reddit AMA

Contact us at letters@time.com.

Read More From TIME

Related Stories