House Conservatives Brace for GOP Blowback in Leadership Fight

6 minute read

The Freedom Caucus—the conservative House Republican rebels who drove Speaker John Boehner to quit and forced his most likely successor out of the race—has a nightmare scenario on its hands. It isn’t that Boehner stays on as Speaker, or that Paul Ryan or even would-be Speaker Kevin McCarthy ends up replacing him. It’s that establishment Republicans could soon use the conservatives’ own tactics against them.

The caucus of about three-dozen members has caused chaos on Capitol Hill in recent weeks, forcing Boehner’s retirement and bringing down the candidacy of his heir, House Majority Leader McCarthy. But as every one in Washington holds their breath to see if Ryan tries to pursue the job he’s told everyone he doesn’t want—and with some conservatives like Sen. Ted Cruz questioning if Ryan is even one of them—it’s worth noting what the other wing of the Republican Party is up to.

Don’t call them “moderates,” because in any other caucus they’d be conservative. So let’s call the 56-member coalition known as the Tuesday Group “pragmatists”—or, for lack of a better word, the establishment. Just about the only thing that the establishment and the Freedom Caucus agree upon is that something’s got to change. “Whoever is the next Speaker, if he or she chooses path of appeasement of rejectionist wing of the party, we’ll be stuck on path of paralysis and speaker will be ineffective,” says Rep. Charlie Dent, a Pennsylvania Republican who chairs the Tuesday Group. “We have to change the underlying governing dynamic going forward.”

To make his point, Dent and his colleagues signed on to a bipartisan petition earlier this month to reauthorize the obscure Export-Import Bank over the objections of the Freedom Caucus. Dent notes that any real governing—the passage of Senate-brokered compromises usually opposed by the conservative insurgents—will have to go through his group working with Democrats. “[Ryan] understands the circumstances he faces,” Dent says. “He clearly understands that he’s going to have to move some important legislation as speaker—the debt ceiling, an omnibus—and if does those things he’ll be sniped out from his right flank.”

This is the same box that Boehner and McCarthy faced and punted on: whether to turn the conference to the left to avoid catastrophes for the Republican Party like shutting down the government or defaulting on the nation’s debt, or stick to a right-wing course at a time when outsiders like Donald Trump, Ben Carson and Carly Fiorina are dominating the presidential election.

“Conservatives are simply asking leadership to make good on their campaign promises, but it’s moderates who are joining with liberal Democrats to resurrect the cronyist Export-Import Bank that subsidizes privileged corporations,” says former South Carolina Sen. Jim DeMint, who now heads The Heritage Foundation. “The current majorities were elected on promises to stop amnesty and fight for full repeal of Obamacare, and the next Speaker needs to lay out an agenda that ends favoritism toward special interests and provides opportunity to all Americans.”

The problem is, the leaders were never going to make good on their campaign promises: They don’t control the White House or a big enough majority in the Senate to deliver. So, in frustration, the Freedom Caucus has gone after the system itself, particularly its leaders. “Disorder and chaos are not the traditional conservative vales,” scoffs Dent. “The rejectionist arm of the party seems to have a problem with James Madison and the system [of checks and balances] that he devised.”

Dent essentially argues that two can play the game of disruption the Freedom Caucus has devised. If it only takes 30 votes for a Republican to lose a floor vote for Speaker (the GOP majority of 247 minus 30 is 217, below the 218 needed to pass a motion), those votes can be found elsewhere if need be. “If there are somewhere between 30 and 50 Republican members who say they won’t vote for the choice of the majority of Republicans for speaker, well then yes, the Democrats will have an impact and influence on who will be the next speaker if there aren’t 217 votes on the House floor,” Dent says. “I would prefer we elect a Speaker on majority-Republican votes on the House floor. I’m just not sure that’s possible.”

But the Freedom Caucus has bigger worries than competing voting blocs: The establishment is taking another page from its playbook by going after them in primaries. One of the demands of the Freedom Caucus is that the leadership and allied groups not run ads against them when they buck the system. “We’re asking for assurances that the next Speaker or any of his allies, including the Chamber of Commerce and the American Action Network, will not run ads against us as has happened over the last six months to many of us,” says Rep. David Brat, who defeated former House Majority Leader Eric Cantor in his Virginia primary last year.

Many have asked for support from the National Congressional Campaign Committee, which works to elect Republicans to the House. But given that Freedom Caucus districts lean strongly Republican, there’s little chance that those members will receive NRCC funds, which tend to go to more competitive swing districts.

Whoever becomes the next Speaker has his or her work cut out for them in managing a party engaged in a low-grade civil war. On the legislative, procedural and electoral fronts, the two wings of the party are vying for dominance. And to lead one is, by definition, to be against the other.

Who can lead both?

Photos: 6 Congressional Leaders Who Resigned Over Scandals

Former House Majority Leader Tom DeLay pauses to listen to a question as he talks to reporters as he leaves a lunch meeting on Capitol Hill, Thursday, Sept. 19, 2013 in Washington. A Texas appeals court tossed the criminal conviction of DeLay on Thursday, Sept. 19, 2013, saying there was insufficient evidence for a jury in 2010 to have found him guilty of illegally funneling money to Republican candidates. (AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster)
Rep. Tom DeLay (R-Tx.) stepped down from his post as House majority leader in 2005 when a Texas grand jury indicted him on a conspiracy charge in his management of campaign finances. His corruption conviction was overturned in October. Carolyn Kaster—AP
UNITED STATES - MARCH 01: Rep. Jim Wright speaking to press after meeting with President Reagan on Geneva arms talks. (Photo by Diana Walker/Time & Life Pictures/Getty Images)
In 1989, Rep. Jim Wright (D-Texas) became the first House Speaker to resign over scandal. He abdicated his post after a yearlong ethics investigation found he had accepted improper gifts and mishandled his speaking profits, among other finance violations.Diana Walker—Time and Life Pictures/Getty Images
WASHINGTON, : Incoming Speaker of the House of Representatives Robert Livingston (C), R-LA, speaks to the media late 17 December after a meeting of the House Republican leadership on the upcoming hearings on the impeachment of US President Bill Clinton. The House will begin the hearings 18 December. With Livingston are Rep. Tom DeLay (L), R-TX; Rep. Dick Armey (2nd L), R-TX; Rep. J.C. Watts (2nd R), R-OK; and Michael Forbes (R), R-NY. Woman (2nd L) and man (3rd R) are unidentified. AFP PHOTO/Paul RICHARDS (Photo credit should read PAUL J. RICHARDS/AFP/Getty Images)
Rep. Bob Livingston (R-La.) faced a sex scandal at the exact worst time: right as Republicans were calling for the impeachment of President Clinton. Livingston stepped down from the speakership in 1998 amid threats that details of his own affairs would be brought to light.Paul J. Richards—AFP/Getty Images
WASHINGTON, DC - MARCH 15: The Honorable Tony Coelho, Master of Ceremonies, makes a few remarks at the 2011 AAPD Awards Gala at the Ronald Reagan Building on March 15, 2011 in Washington, DC. (Photo by Paul Morigi/WireImage) *** Local Caption *** Tony Coelho
Rep. Tony Coelho (D-Calif.) was the third-ranking member of House Democratic leadership and resigned from Congress altogether as he faced a 1989 ethics probe into his personal finances.Paul Morigi—WireImage
Newly-elected U.S. Senate Republican Whip Trent Lott (R-MS) is pictured following secret voting for the new Senate Reblican leadership on Capitol Hill in Washington November 15, 2006. Lott resigned as House majority leader in 2002 during a controversy over remarks that were seen as racially insensitive. REUTERS/Jason Reed (UNITED STATES) - RTR1JD3F
Mississippi Sen. Trent Lott resigned as the Senate majority leader in 2002 after he made comments supporting the segregationist 1948 presidential campaign of Strom Thurmond. But Lott made a comeback five years later when he was elected minority whip. Jason Reed—Reuters
NATIONAL HARBOR, MD - MARCH 08: Newt Gingrich, former speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives, speaks during the 41st annual Conservative Political Action Conference at the Gaylord International Hotel and Conference Center on March 8, 2014 in National Harbor, Maryland. The conference, a project of the American Conservative Union, brings together conservatives polticians, pundits and voters for three days of speeches and workshops. (Photo by T.J. Kirkpatrick/Getty Images)
Speaker Newt Gingrich (R-Ga.) was formally reprimanded by the House and forced to pay a $300,000 penalty for violating tax law and lying to the investigating panel. He didn’t resign over the scandal, but it weakened his support among his Republican base.T.J. Kirkpatrick—Getty Images

More Must-Reads From TIME

Contact us at