August 20, 2015 7:03 AM EDT

Perhaps all those years of brutally honest Project Runway evaluations have gotten the best of her, but Heidi Klum is not a great liar.

On Wednesday’s episode of The Tonight Show, Klum challenged host Jimmy Fallon in a game called Box of Lies. In it, they opened up mystery boxes containing unusual objects and told their opponent what they saw. The opponent had to then guess whether the contents were being described honestly… or if they were being told an outlandish lie.

Fallon came out on top, just by one point, but it’s worth watching just to see the weird objects that come out of the boxes. Some Tonight Show interns really went to town on the arts and crafts here.

This article originally appeared on

Read next: Watch Zac Efron Play Egg Roulette with Jimmy Fallon

Download TIME’s mobile app for iOS to have your world explained wherever you go

Contact us at

Read More From TIME

Related Stories