What Denmark Gets Wrong About Halal

4 minute read
Updated: | Originally published: ;

Imam Khalid Latif is a university chaplain for New York University, executive director of the Islamic Center at NYU, chaplain for the NYPD, and co-founder of Honest Chops, an organic halal butcher shop in NYC.

Denmark banned the ritual slaughtering of animals last year, including halal and Kosher practices, unless the process includes stunning the animal. As a chaplain, executive director of NYU’s Islamic Center, and owner of an animal butcher store called Honest Chops that specializes in local and organic halal meats, I’m discouraged by all the misinformation I’ve seen in these recent conversations about halal slaughtering practices.

There are two important considerations to understanding halal: 1) In Islam, all of creation, including animals and plants, have rights that are supposed to be honored, and 2) according to Islam, much of our spirituality is tied to what we consume.

The Danish argument looks solely at the slaughtering methods used by Jews and Muslims, rather than taking into consideration the treatment of the animal during the entire duration of its life. I can’t speak on behalf of Judaism, but as a Muslim, I can tell you that a lot more goes into the practice.

The word halal means “religiously permissible,” and when used in reference to food, it denotes foods that are considered permissible for Muslims to eat. The alternate category would be haram or something that is “religiously impermissible,” such as pork. The actual slaughtering process is called dhabihah, not halal, and it becomes an integral part of the process of rendering an animal lawful to consume. Three conditions need to be met in the slaughtering process for the animal to be considered halal at the end:

  • The person doing the slaughtering is Muslim or a person from what Islam deems to be “People of the Book”, i.e. Christians and Jews.
  • Any tool that has a sharp, cutting edge (a dull blade would not be permitted) is used to cut through a majority of the four primary veins located in the throat. This is done to allow for flowing blood to be released from the animal and for it to have as much as possible an instantaneous and painless death. (To assume that it has no pain would make no sense. It is, after all, getting cut by a blade at its throat.)
  • The name of God is mentioned at the time of slaughtering.
  • The process of stunning is considered to be religiously problematic by Muslims. Inflicting and causing pain to any animal is wrong — slaughtering an animal in order to eat it is seen as an exception. Stunning causes pain before it results in unconsciousness and also has the potential of being lethal enough to kill the animal. If the animal dies as a result of the stunning, it would be consider haram to eat.

    Islam also puts a great emphasis on how the animal is treated before slaughtering. When we were opening up Honest Chops, I looked into the practices of the conventional meat industry. Learning how some animals are treated and raised was shocking and disheartening. I walked through slaughter facilities where chickens were pecking away at carcasses of dead chickens, sometimes eating their own excrement. Animals were being treated so poorly and forced to live in the most horrendous of conditions because they were seen as a commodity that needed to be mass-produced rather than as a creation that had rights. That bothered me.

    Aside from something being halal, the Qur’an calls for food to be tayyib, or pure. What we found in the commercialized meat industry was the absence of that purity, and the treatment of the animals was a primary indication of that. Commercialization seemed to strip away the presence of God and a reverence for all of His creation. There is an inherent beauty in an animal giving its life to provide sustenance to you and me. In my opinion, it makes sense that if a life has to be taken, it’s done so with much-needed care, from start to end.

    The Danish government is failing in multiple ways with this ban. It makes no sense to engage in legislation that seems to infringe upon the rights of minority communities, especially those that have been historically persecuted throughout Europe. The ban also fails to address the real problems in the meat industry — how animals are treated. By focusing only on the slaughtering method, it fails to create reasonable alternatives and substantive solutions to actual issues. It gives the semblance of movement forward, when in reality it’s pushing things backwards.

    See How Muslims Around the World Celebrate Eid al-Fitr

    Eid al-Fitr
    An Afghan boy attends Eid al-Fitr prayers in Mazar-i-Sharif, Afghanistan, on July 17, 2015. Sayed Mustafa—EPA
    Eid al-Fitr
    Muslim faithful take part in morning prayers to celebrate the first day of the Muslim holiday of Eid-al-Fitr, marking the end of the holy month of Ramadan, at the Eastleigh High School in Eastleigh, a suburb in Nairobi predominantly inhabited by Somali immigrants within Kenya's capital Nairobi, on July 17, 2015. Boniface Mwangi—Reuters
    Eid al-Fitr
    Chinese Muslims of the Hui ethnic minority hold incense as they pray at the Imam's Tomb before the last Friday prayers of the holy fasting month of Ramadan at the historic Niujie Mosque on July 17, 2015 in Beijing.Kevin Frayer—Getty Images
    Eid al-Fitr
    A young Chinese Muslim of the Hui ethnic minority sits on a prayer rug as men stand and pray during the last Friday prayers of the holy fasting month of Ramadan at the historic Niujie Mosque on July 17, 2015 in Beijing.Kevin Frayer—Getty Images
    Eid al-Fitr
    An Indian Muslim devotee looks on before the start of Jummat-Ul-Vida prayers on the last Friday of the month of Ramadan ahead of the Eid al-Fitr holiday at Jama Masjid Mosque in the old quarters of New Delhi on July 17, 2015. Chandan Khanna—AFP/Getty Images
    Eid al-Fitr
    Muslims offer Eid al-Fitr prayers outside Al Noor Mosque in Sharjah, United Arab Emirates, on July 17, 2015.Francois Nel—Getty Images
    Eid al-Fitr
    Syrian refugee children dressed in new clothes hold the hands of their grandmother while walking back to their shelter on the first day of the Eid al-Fitr holiday that marks the end of the holy fasting month of Ramadan at Zaatari refugee camp, in Mafraq, Jordan, on July 17, 2015. Muhammed Muheisen—AP
    Eid al-Fitr
    A Nigerian Muslim family takes a selfie portrait before Eid al-Fitr prayer, marking the end of the Muslim holy fasting month of Ramadan in Lagos, Nigeria, on July 17, 2015. Sunday Alamba—AP
    Eid al-Fitr
    Indonesian muslims walk on 'sea of sands' as they prepare for Eid Al-Fitr prayer at Parangkusumo beach in Yogyakarta, Indonesia, on July 17, 2015.Ulet Ifansasti—Getty Images
    Eid al-Fitr
    A picture taken from the Abraj al-Bait Towers, also known as the Mecca Royal Hotel Clock Tower, shows Muslim worshipers praying at the Grand Mosque in the Muslim holy city of Mecca, a day before the end of the fasting month of Ramadan, on July 16, 2015.AFP/Getty Images

    More Must-Reads From TIME

    Contact us at letters@time.com

    TIME Ideas hosts the world's leading voices, providing commentary on events in news, society, and culture. We welcome outside contributions. Opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect the views of TIME editors.