Bobby Jindal Campaign Launches With Uphill Battle

4 minute read

It’s been a long fall from grace for Bobby Jindal.

The Louisiana governor, who will launch his campaign for president on Wednesday in New Orleans, is polling in 15th place among major declared or likely candidates for the Republican nomination. That’s dead last. He’s all but certain to be excluded from the Fox News debate that will kick off the race for the White House on Aug. 6, a painful omission that won’t help his cause.

It wasn’t supposed to be this way. Ever since taking the governor’s mansion in Baton Rouge in 2008, Jindal, now 44, has been hailed as one of the GOP’s rising stars. A brainy young Indian-American, he was tapped to deliver the Republican rebuttal to President Obama’s first address to a joint session of Congress in 2009. In 2012, many conservatives floated him as a potential vice-presidential pick for Mitt Romney. The two-term governor, who had cruised to reelection and stockpiled goodwill among grassroots activists and Establishment donors alike, looked poised to be a player in the 2016 race.

So why does Jindal’s White House bid now seem such a long shot?

It’s easy to trace the start of the slide to speeches he began making at the end of 2012. In the aftermath of Romney’s loss, Jindal brutally excoriated the GOP as a hidebound party, captive to corporate interests and plagued by a pattern of incendiary remarks. Republicans, he declared, must “stop being the stupid party.”

Jindal looked like an apt candidate to lead the transition. A Rhodes Scholar, health-care policy expert and former McKinsey consultant, he launched a national policy group, released white papers and op-eds on everything from foreign policy to energy. He was at the forefront of the GOP in supporting over-the-counter contraception, a bid to counteract the Democrats’ potent “war on women” trope.

Read More: Bobby Jindal: America’s Next Top Columnist

“We need to stop being simplistic, we need to trust the intelligence of the American people and we need to stop insulting the intelligence of the voters,” he told Politico after Obama’s re-election.

But the truth-telling shtick didn’t last long. Soon the Ivy-league biology major was punting questions about evolution and climate change to shore up his standing with social conservatives. A governor with a glittering resume became better known to Americans as the defender of Duck Dynasty. Once a supporter of Common Core education standards, he watched conservatives turn against the program and launched a campaign to kill it in his state, home to one of the worst public education systems in the country. (Jindal has dramatically expanded school choice during his tenure.)

It wasn’t only that the turnabout struck some as inauthentic. It also forced Jindal to compete in a crowded space for donors and voter support. His pitch to voters centers on core fiscal and social conservative principles, a field occupied by more dynamic candidates like Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas and better-known ones like retired neurosurgeon Ben Carson and former Texas Gov. Rick Perry, who Jindal endorsed for President in 2011.

Read More: Why a Bobby Jindal Portrait Sparked a Racial Controversy

Back home, Jindal’s support has cratered at the worst possible time. The Louisiana governor has watched his approval rating slip into the 30s; a recent poll showed him trailing Hillary Clinton in the GOP stronghold. The budget is a mess, and he’s alienated allies by spending long stretches away from the state to tend to his national ambitions. “Bobby spotted at the capitol,” Republican state senator Dan Claitor tweeted on April 1. “(April Fool).”

Jindal still has the policy chops and conservative credentials to snap his slide. He’s cut the budget, pushed school choice and privatized state hospitals. In recent months he’s refined a stump speech that earns rave reviews from the GOP faithful. There’s no question he has the potential to catch a wave like a succession of lesser candidates enjoyed in 2012.

“Why has he not caught fire? He is not a candidate yet,” says a Jindal adviser. “When he gets into this race he will be the least-known candidate. He has only room to grow.”

“He’s been underestimated before,” the adviser adds, “and every time he’s won and he’s crushed the opposition.”

At the very least, he has nowhere to go but up.

Photos: The Curse of the State of the Union Response

Jim Wright State of the Union
House Speaker Jim Wright gave the response to George H.W. Bush in 1989. He resigned later that year after an ethics scandal. Terry Ashe—The LIFE Picture Collection/Getty Images
Bob Michel State of the Union
Rep. Bob Michel gave the response to Bill Clinton in 1993. Facing fights with other Republicans, he declined to run for re-election the next year. Terry Ashe—The LIFE Picture Collection/Getty Images
Bob Dole State of the Union Response
Sen. Bob Dole gave the response to Clinton in 1996. Later that year, he ran against Clinton and lost. Charlie Neibergall—AP
Dick Gephardt State of the Union
House Minority Leader Dick Gephardt (shown on TV) gave the response to George W. Bush in 2002. After Democrats lost seats that fall, he stepped down from leadership. Scott J. Ferrell—CQ-Roll Call/Getty Images
Kathleen Sebelius State of the Union
Kansas Gov. Kathleen Sebelius gave the response to Bush in 2008. The next year, she became Secretary Health and Human Services, where she oversaw the disastrous launch of AP
Bobby Jindal State of the Union
Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal gave the response to Barack Obama in 2009. It was poorly received, setting back his national prospects.AP
Bob McDonnell State of the Union
Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell gave the response to Obama in 2010. He was recently sentenced to two years in prison in a corruption case. Steve Helber—AP
Michele Bachmann State of the Union
Rep. Michele Bachmann gave the unofficial tea party response to Obama in 2011. The next year, she came in last in the Iowa presidential caucuses. AP
Paul Ryan State of the Union
Rep. Paul Ryan gave the official response to Obama in 2011. The following year, he ran for vice president and lost. AP
Marco Rubio State of the Union
Sen. Marco Rubio gave the response to Obama in 2013. His awkward drink of water midway through was much ridiculed. AP

More Must-Reads From TIME

Write to Alex Altman at