Frustration and Suffering in Haiti's Mental Facilities

3 minute read

More than three years after a massive earthquake devastated the already impoverished Caribbean nation of Haiti, killing an estimated 200,000 and leaving more than 10% of the population of 10 million homeless, many Haitians are still trying to rebuild their lives. While the capital, Port-au-Prince, bore the brunt of the damage, subsequent challenges and setbacks—including an ongoing cholera outbreak—have left few untouched by the quake’s ripple effects.

The damage isn’t just physical. Aid workers say mental-health needs skyrocketed in the months after the earthquake, but the Haitian government was not equipped to meet the demand, with fewer than 20 practicing psychiatrists working in state-run facilities at the time. The suddenly overwhelming need for emergency and primary care siphoned even more resources away from mental-health care.

In April, Italian photographer Fabio Bucciarelli spent 10 days photographing the patients of one of the country’s two state-run mental hospitals, Défilé de Beudet in Croix-des-Bouquets, outside Port-au-Prince. His pictures show the bleak conditions some of the country’s most vulnerable citizens face every day. “When you imagine a hospital, you think of white walls with clean beds,” says Bucciarelli. Instead, Haiti’s only hospital dedicated to helping the chronically mentally ill “looks like a prison.”

The 150-bed facility is home to about 250 men and women, Bucciarelli estimates, many of whom suffer from severe psychiatric disorders. Patients sleep on concrete slabs in barred cells, which Bucciarelli refers to as cages. In the week and a half he spent at the hospital, Bucciarelli saw only one doctor but never witnessed him, or any of the nursing staff, interact with the patients. In that same period of time, Bucciarelli saw only a single patient receive any visitors. The director general of Haiti’s Ministry of Public Health told Time in an e-mail that the government intends to increase funding for mental-health care but did not provide further details.

Nongovernmental organizations and aid agencies, including Partners in Health, a Boston-based nonprofit, are working with the Ministry of Public Health and Population to develop a more comprehensive mental-health-care program. They have provided treatment to some 25,000 Haitians since 2010, but progress has been slow. So as Haitians struggle to repair their homes, their businesses and their country, the residents of Défilé de Beudet have no choice but to wait at the back of the line.


Fabio Bucciarelli is an Italian photojournalist. In April, he was awarded the Robert Capa Gold Medal by the Overseas Press Club of America.

Megan Gibson is a writer and reporter for TIME, currently based in London. Follow her on Twitter @MeganJGibson.


buccia_10.JPG
The following photographs were taken in April 2013.A Haitian suffering from schizophrenia lies on the floor of his hospital room in Crux-de-Buquet, Port-au-Prince, Haiti.Fabio Bucciarelli
Prisoned Disease
Patients at Défilé de Beudet are permitted one hour a day in the hospital’s common areas where they eat and roam outside. Fabio Bucciarelli
Prisoned Disease
Patients eat their lunch in the hospital's canteen.Fabio Bucciarelli
Prisoned Disease
Patients wait in line for lunch.Fabio Bucciarelli
Prisoned Disease
A female patient consumes food during a lunch break.Fabio Bucciarelli
Prisoned Disease
Patients rush to the food distribution point right after the canteen's doors have been opened for lunch.Fabio Bucciarelli
Prisoned Disease
A female patient waits in solitary confinement.Fabio Bucciarelli
Prisoned Disease
Patients roam through the cells during the open air hours they are awarded each day.Fabio Bucciarelli
Prisoned Disease
Damaged in the earthquake, the hospital remains the home to some 250 patients. Fabio Bucciarelli
Prisoned Disease
Patients at Défilé de Beudet spend most of their time in their rooms, which resemble prison cells. Fabio Bucciarelli
Prisoned Disease
Patients stash some of their belongings in small holes that allow light and air into their cells.Fabio Bucciarelli
Prisoned Disease
One of the inmates heads back to her shared cell.Fabio Bucciarelli
Prisoned Disease
A young patient eats in the common space for inmates.Fabio Bucciarelli
Prisoned Disease
An inmate waits idly in his cell.Fabio Bucciarelli
Prisoned Disease
An inmate lies helpless on the floor near the entrance to the hospital.Fabio Bucciarelli
Prisoned Disease
A patient reaches out for the lock that holds his door closed.Fabio Bucciarelli

More Must-Reads From TIME

Contact us at letters@time.com