• History

Here’s What Critics Said About The Colbert Report When It Premiered

3 minute read

When The Colbert Report began it’s nearly decade-long run in 2005—the show rolls its final credits on Dec. 18—viewers and critics were excited but nervous. Colbert’s blowhard persona had been a mainstay of The Daily Show, but many worried that, given a whole half-hour to anchor, the character would grow tiresome.

Even in the first few weeks, the jury was out.

“Unfortunately, in just two weeks on the air, this half-hour spoof of a no-spin-zone type show has already stretched Colbert’s character and the artifice that supports it past its natural breaking point,” wrote USA Today. “Colbert was an invaluable part of the Daily Show, but as the whole show, he’s not enough and too much simultaneously.” And New York magazine decided that one of Colbert’s rivals at Comedy Central, David Spade’s The Showbiz Show, was the better of the two. The Colbert Report, wrote critic Adam Sternbergh, “has problems so intrinsic as to be potentially unfixable.” (The Showbiz Show ended in 2007.) Even critics who liked the show, like Heather Havrilesky at Salon, found the show “foolish, bizarre, idiotic fun,” mostly interesting in regards to his characters spoof of Bill O’Reilly.

See 13 Stephen Colbert Cameos You Might Have Missed

Stephen Colbert
The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug - Lake-town SpyTodd Eyre—Warner Bros.
Stephen Colbert
Exit 57 - Various Characters (pictured top left)Comedy Central
Stephen Colbert
Dana Carvey Show - Various CharactersABC
Stephen Colbert
Strangers With Candy - Chuck NobletComedy Central
Stephen Colbert
Missing Persons - Chet DaviesABC
Stephen Colbert
Saturday Night Live - Ace, The Ambiguously Gay Duo (pictured left)NBC
Stephen Colbert
Spin City - FrankABC
Stephen Colbert
Simpsons - Colby Krause (pictured right)Fox
Stephen Colbert
Curb Your Enthusiasm - TouristHBO
Stephen Colbert
American Dad! - Dr. R. Dandliker (pictured left)Fox
Stephen Colbert
Bewitched - Stu Robinson (pictured left)Columbia
Stephen Colbert
Mr. Peabody & Sherman - Paul Peterson20th Century Fox
Stephen Colbert
Monsters vs Aliens - President HathawayDreamworks

Still, when the consensus emerged, it was one that stuck: The show was great. “[H]e packs more wit and acid commentary in 22 minutes of his one-man show than multiple skits by the entire cast of ‘SNL,’” declared The New York Times, and the The Los Angeles Times said that “Colbert, with his young Republican haircut and dead-serious eyes, is a terrifically artful speaker; there may be no better reader of writing on TV than him.”

TIME’s James Poniewozik concurred:

Many people, Colbert included, were worried that that guy would be too much to take for 30 minutes. (Then again, people blow a full hour on Bill O’Reilly.) But Colbert inhabits his pose so lustily–“I’ve just swallowed 20 condoms full of truth, and I’m smuggling them across the border!”–that his glee is infectious. Like the band Weezer or The O.C.‘s Seth Cohen, he is in the grand modern tradition of the swaggering nerd.

And here’s another reason to swagger: His legions of fans would say that the question of whether he’s too much to take—for 11 seasons, much less 30 minutes—seems as “foolish, bizarre, idiotic” as the character to whom they’re saying good-bye.

Read James Poniewozik’s full Nov. 14, 2005, piece on The Colbert Report: The American Bald Ego

More Must-Reads From TIME

Write to Lily Rothman at lily.rothman@time.com