June 10, 2014 11:53 AM EDT

The hero who runs the MLB’s Twitter feed managed to started a full-scale, league-wide Taylor Swift sing-along.

It started with a simple tweet:

Then the Dodgers shot back with the first line of “Love Story”:

And then it just kept going:

And going:

Seamlessly weaving together T-Swift lyrics and baseball references:

And then the Pirates tried to steer things in a new direction:

And then the Indians were like, hey we want to play too, but apparently didn’t realize that this was a Taylor Swift sing-along, not a Goo Goo Dolls sing-along:

Besides that strange little hiccup, most teams were on point with this. Again, props to the social media guru/ninja/freak who started this — we knew you were trouble when you walked in.

Contact us at letters@time.com.

Read More From TIME

Related Stories