Bob O'Connor

How Money Ranked the Best Colleges

Jul 24, 2014

Here’s how we determined which of the nation’s roughly 1,500 four-year colleges and universities give you the best value for your money.

To make our initial cut, a college had to have an above-average six-year graduation rate in its institutional category (public or private) or if the rate was below the median, we required a graduation rate at least 25% above what would be expected given the incomes and test scores of its students to be included. We then screened out schools with a speculative bond rating from Moody’s (indicating financial difficulties) or for which there wasn’t sufficient data available. We also did not include military schools that require a commitment of service in exchange for free tuition.

That left 665 schools, which we then ranked on 18 factors in three categories:

Quality of Education (1/3 weighting)

  • Six-year graduation rate (25%), which is widely recognized as one of the most important indicators of a college’s quality
  • Peer quality (15%), measured by the standardized test scores of entering freshman
  • Instructor quality (15%), measured by the student-to-faculty ratio (10%) and the college’s average grade from Ratemyprofessor.com (5%).
  • Students’ perception of quality (20%), measured by the percentage of accepted students who enroll in that college, known as yield
  • Value-added graduation rate (25%), or the difference between a school’s actual graduation rate and its expected rate, based on the economic and academic profile of the student body (measured by the percentage of attendees receiving Pell grants given to low-income students and the average standardized test scores of incoming freshmen)

Affordability (1/3 weighting)

  • Net price of a degree (40%), or the estimated amount a typical freshman starting in 2014 will pay to earn a degree taking into account the college’s sticker price; the school’s average need, merit, and athletic financial aid; tuition inflation; and the average time it takes students to graduate from the school
  • Debt (40%), taking into account both student debt upon graduation (20%) and parent federal PLUS loans (20%)
  • Student loan default risk (10%), a calculation of the odds that a student at the college will end up being unable to pay back a federal student loan
  • Value-added student loan default risk (10%), adjusted for the economic and academic profile of the student body

Outcomes (1/3 weighting)

  • Early (20%) and mid-career earnings (10%), as reported to Payscale.com by a school’s alumni
  • Earnings adjusted by majors (30%) to see whether students at a particular school earn more or less than would be expected given the mix of majors at that school, early in their careers (20%) and in mid-career (10%)
  • Value-added earnings (30%), adjusted for the economic and academic profile of each school's student body, in early career (20%) and in mid-career (10%)
  • Career services (10%), staffing per 1,000 students

Finally, we used a statistical technique to turn all the data points into a single score on a five-point scale, and ranked the schools based on those scores.

For a full description of the methodology, click here.

MONEY may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.

Quotes delayed at least 15 minutes. Market data provided by Interactive Data. ETF and Mutual Fund data provided by Morningstar, Inc. Dow Jones Terms & Conditions: http://www.djindexes.com/mdsidx/html/tandc/indexestandcs.html. S&P Index data is the property of Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved. Terms & Conditions. Powered and implemented by Interactive Data Managed Solutions