As a sport and a business, golf is stuck in a proverbial sand trap, probably the deepest and most difficult one ever encountered by the industry. Player numbers are on the decline, especially among young people, and golf course closings in the U.S. are trumping golf course openings by a stunning ratio of nearly 10 to 1.
There is some hope, however, that golf will experience a renaissance, even among kids who are now too accustomed to instant gratification and too distracted by smartphones and social media to bother venturing outside to play baseball or go for a hike, let alone try their hands at the time-consuming, frustrating "old person's sport" of golf. And one of the big reasons for this optimism is that today's most exciting players also happen to be kids, and none more exciting than Rory McIlroy, the 25-year-old winner of the 2014 British Open.
OK, so a 25-year-old isn't exactly a child. But he's a kid compared with the prototypical gray-haired, 50-something golfer out on the links. And his success couldn't come at a better time. McIlroy is part of a much-needed youth movement in golf, notes Jim Frank, a contributing editor to Links Magazine who has covered the sport for three decades. Joined by emerging superstars Rickie Fowler, who is also 25 and is known for cool clothes and shaggy Bieber-like hair, and incredibly talented young female golfers like Lexi Thompson (19) and Lydia Ko (all of 17), McIlroy is seen as a fresh injection of energy, excitement, and—dare we say it?—perhaps even hipness into the sport.
"He supposedly took the first selfie of a British Open winner," said Frank. Hey, that's gotta count for something.
Perhaps the biggest contribution of McIlroy and the rest of the youth movement—besides their unwrinkled, photogenic faces and a generally cooler appearance compared with the usual grandpas on the links—is that they're changing the perception of how to play golf and when one tends to peak in the sport. "In the past, the assumption was that you didn't really hit your stride until your 30s, after you've worked out the kinks in your game," said Frank. "Today's young players are really powerful, they wrench their backs and really hit the ball hard. And they've been playing so long that by the time they're in the late teens and early 20s, they can dominate." (They can also get injured; just look at how Tiger Woods's body has fared in recent years.)
Nonetheless, the excitement, power, and youth that McIlroy and his peers bring to the game has to be good for golf, right? Sure, to some extent. But Frank believes it will take more than one charismatic, curly-haired Irishman to turn the tide.
"Are 14-year-olds sitting in front of a TV on a Sunday morning at 10 o'clock watching Rory McIlroy?" Frank said. The answer, of course, is no. While some parts of the golf world are trying to make changes to become more appealing to younger players and families, Frank believes that some retrenchment is still needed, and that the sport will always remain a niche activity, and one that always skews older.
When people in the business talk about rejuvenating the sport, they sometimes ask, "What's the snowboarding of golf?" said Frank. "Snowboarding brought young people back to the mountains, and it helped save skiing." Unfortunately, because a sizeable faction of the golf world has no interest in changing the game or doing much of anything to appeal to younger people, "there may not be an equivalent of snowboarding. But that's the way we have to think of it."
The big irony, Frank said, is that right now, when golf seems to be struggling so mightily in its attempts to attract new players to the game, there has never been a better time to play. "The equipment has never been better, and there's great value for what you can buy fairly cheaply," said Frank. "You can get on almost any golf course in the world, or join almost any club if you want. There are no lines, and there aren't people behind you telling you to play faster."