How do I choose a mutual fund?

Mutual fund ads, which often tout a fund’s past performance, always include this bit of fine print: “Past performance is no guarantee of future returns.” Pay attention to that disclaimer. Not only is past performance no guarantee, it’s not even a very strong indicator of a fund’s future success. A recent study by Standard & Poor’s found that of all funds in the top 25% of their category in one year, fewer than one third made it to the top 25% the next year. Only 5% managed to stay in the winner’s circle three years in a row.

So how do you pick a good fund? Each year, Money magazine puts together a list of 50 recommended funds. Performance is one of the editors’ criteria, but it’s the least important among many. Money also considers:

Low fees: If one fund charges an annual expense ratio of .4% and another charges 1.4%, the cheaper fund has a built-in 1% edge on returns every year. Remember, you can’t count on a fund manager outperforming or even making you money. But you can count on him collecting his expense ratio. For this reason, the Money 50 list is heavy on low-cost index funds

Experienced management: A fund is nothing but a pool of money. If performance records matter at all, they belong to the manager not the fund. So if a fund switched managers last year, you truly can ignore most of its record.

Strong stewardship: Money looks for funds whose managers consistently put shareholders’ interests ahead of their own. That means having pay incentives aligned to performance, a strong board to represent fund shareholders, and record of avoiding regulatory issues. Morningstar, a fund research group based in Chicago, assigns funds a stewardship grade based on these and other factors. You can look up a fund’s stewardship grade at

Make sure you pick a fund with a strategy aligned to your goals. Some stock funds focus on big, stable blue-chip companies with the aim of producing relatively steady returns. Others reach for higher returns—and accept higher risk—by focusing on smaller companies, or on stocks in volatile but fast-growing industries. Most stock investors, however, will do just fine by choosing a low-cost, broadly diversified fund that holds a representative slice of all the stocks on the market.

Your browser, Internet Explorer 8 or below, is out of date. It has known security flaws and may not display all features of this and other websites.

Learn how to update your browser

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 46,456 other followers