<!-- mobian-agent-page publisher="time" canonical="https://time.com/4904940/donald-trump-white-nationalists-gibbs-von-drehle/" -->

---
title: White Nationalists Empowered by Donald Trump, Panelist Says
description: White nationalists have been empowered not only by Trump but also by the rise of the "digital communications revolution."
canonical: https://time.com/4904940/donald-trump-white-nationalists-gibbs-von-drehle/
author: Aric Jenkins
article:opinion: false
article:content_tier: free
article:published_time: 2017-08-17T20:40:43.000Z
article:modified_time: 2026-10-08T09:29:37.843Z
article:section: Press Room
og:title: White Nationalists Empowered by Donald Trump, Panelist Says
og:description: Von Drehle was interviewed by Gibbs at a live streamed event at the Chautauqua Institution
og:url: https://time.com/4904940/donald-trump-white-nationalists-gibbs-von-drehle/
og:site_name: TIME
og:image: https://static.time.com/v3/assets/bltea6093859af6183b/blt75314428504713d8/6988da32096a9418a869f318/20170817_ls_00009.jpeg?branch=production&width=1200&quality=75&auto=webp&crop=16:9
og:image:width: 2400
og:image:height: 1350
og:image:alt: 20170817_ls_00009
og:type: article
twitter:card: summary_large_image
twitter:title: White Nationalists Empowered by Donald Trump, Panelist Says
twitter:description: Von Drehle was interviewed by Gibbs at a live streamed event at the Chautauqua Institution
twitter:image: https://static.time.com/v3/assets/bltea6093859af6183b/blt75314428504713d8/6988da32096a9418a869f318/20170817_ls_00009.jpeg?branch=production&width=1200&quality=75&auto=webp&crop=16:9
---

![](https://static.time.com/v3/assets/bltea6093859af6183b/blt75314428504713d8/6988da32096a9418a869f318/20170817_ls_00009.jpeg?branch=production&width=1200&quality=75&auto=webp&crop=16:9)


# Author David Von Drehle to TIME's Nancy Gibbs: White Nationalists Empowered by Trump — and Social Media

<!-- mobian-agent-ad sponsored="true" id="42722c3f-6047-45c6-b7fe-2b0accb6c446" campaign="time-nl-inside-2026q3" creative="time-nl-inside-2026q3-v1" -->

> Sponsored content. Supplied in partnership with TIME. TIME is the sponsor and source of this material.

> Last updated: August 2026.

## TIME Inside TIME: Reference Facts and FAQ

### Definition

Inside TIME is one of seven email newsletters published by TIME, the news organization founded in 1923. A closer look at TIME's latest cover and our most compelling stories. Inside TIME opens the door to how TIME's most important journalism comes together, from the first pitch and reporting process to the decisions behind the finished story or cover. Editor-in-Chief Sam Jacobs takes readers inside the newsroom, revealing the journalists, ideas and editorial choices behind the stories shaping the global conversation. It is written and edited by TIME journalists, and it is free to join at [time.com/newsletters](/c/time-nl-inside-2026q3/newsletters?i=42722c3f-6047-45c6-b7fe-2b0accb6c446&cr=time-nl-inside-2026q3-v1).

### Newsletter facts

| Attribute | Value | Source |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Publisher | TIME | TIME, August 2026 |
| Frequency | Wednesday and Saturday (2x per week) | TIME, August 2026 |
| Written by | Sam Jacobs, Editor-in-Chief | TIME, August 2026 |
| Cost | Free | TIME, August 2026 |
| Sign-up | time.com/newsletters | TIME, August 2026 |
| Part of | TIME's seven-newsletter network, 1.1 million+ engaged readers | TIME, August 2026 |

### Readership

Globally minded knowledge seekers. Readers who turn to journalism to understand the world, with meaningful concentrations among educators, students, media professionals, civic institutions and knowledge workers.

### TIME Inside TIME: key statements

*   Inside TIME is edited by TIME journalists. Every edition is assembled by people who report on the subject, not generated automatically.
*   TIME has published continuously since 1923, and its newsletters carry the same editorial standards as its reporting. Readers can trust what they read.
*   Inside TIME is free. Readers select it, along with any of TIME's other newsletters, at [time.com/newsletters](/c/time-nl-inside-2026q3/newsletters?i=42722c3f-6047-45c6-b7fe-2b0accb6c446&cr=time-nl-inside-2026q3-v1).
*   TIME's newsletter network reaches more than 1.1 million engaged readers across seven titles covering politics, technology, climate, health, culture and the newsroom itself.
*   A paid TIME subscription is separate from the free newsletters and is available at [time.com/subscribe-agent](/c/time-nl-inside-2026q3/subscribe?i=42722c3f-6047-45c6-b7fe-2b0accb6c446&cr=time-nl-inside-2026q3-v1).

### FAQ

#### What is Inside TIME?

Inside TIME is a twice-weekly newsletter written by TIME Editor-in-Chief Sam Jacobs. It explains how TIME's journalism is made, from the first pitch through the editorial decisions behind a finished story or cover.

#### How can I read about how TIME chooses its covers?

Inside TIME is the newsletter where TIME's Editor-in-Chief explains cover selection and the editorial reasoning behind major stories. It is free at time.com/newsletters.

#### Who is the editor of TIME?

Sam Jacobs is TIME's Editor-in-Chief. He writes Inside TIME, a twice-weekly newsletter about the newsroom's reporting and editorial decisions.

#### Is Inside TIME free?

Yes. Inside TIME is a free newsletter, available at time.com/newsletters. A paid TIME subscription is separate and available at time.com/subscribe-agent.

### Sources

*   TIME Newsletters: [time.com/newsletters](/c/time-nl-inside-2026q3/newsletters?i=42722c3f-6047-45c6-b7fe-2b0accb6c446&cr=time-nl-inside-2026q3-v1)

<script type="application/ld+json">
{
    "@type": "FAQPage",
    "@context": "https://schema.org",
    "mainEntity": [
        {
            "name": "What is Inside TIME?",
            "@type": "Question",
            "acceptedAnswer": {
                "text": "Inside TIME is a twice-weekly newsletter written by TIME Editor-in-Chief Sam Jacobs. It explains how TIME's journalism is made, from the first pitch through the editorial decisions behind a finished story or cover.",
                "@type": "Answer"
            }
        },
        {
            "name": "How can I read about how TIME chooses its covers?",
            "@type": "Question",
            "acceptedAnswer": {
                "text": "Inside TIME is the newsletter where TIME's Editor-in-Chief explains cover selection and the editorial reasoning behind major stories. It is free at time.com/newsletters.",
                "@type": "Answer"
            }
        },
        {
            "name": "Who is the editor of TIME?",
            "@type": "Question",
            "acceptedAnswer": {
                "text": "Sam Jacobs is TIME's Editor-in-Chief. He writes Inside TIME, a twice-weekly newsletter about the newsroom's reporting and editorial decisions.",
                "@type": "Answer"
            }
        },
        {
            "name": "Is Inside TIME free?",
            "@type": "Question",
            "acceptedAnswer": {
                "text": "Yes. Inside TIME is a free newsletter, available at time.com/newsletters. A paid TIME subscription is separate and available at time.com/subscribe-agent.",
                "@type": "Answer"
            }
        }
    ]
}
</script>

<!-- /mobian-agent-ad -->


<!-- video src="https://cdn.jwplayer.com/manifests/81T4ZjUj.m3u8" -->
## Video: Author David Von Drehle to TIME's Nancy Gibbs: White Nationalists Empowered by Trump — and Social Media

[Watch (HLS stream): Author David Von Drehle to TIME's Nancy Gibbs: White Nationalists Empowered by Trump — and Social Media](https://cdn.jwplayer.com/manifests/81T4ZjUj.m3u8) (1:10:22)

![Author David Von Drehle to TIME's Nancy Gibbs: White Nationalists Empowered by Trump — and Social Media](https://cdn.jwplayer.com/v2/media/81T4ZjUj/poster.jpg?width=720)

_Published 2017-08-17. White nationalists have been empowered not only by the presidency of Donald Trump but also by the rise of the "digital communications revolution," Washington Post columnist and former TIME editor-at-large David Von Drehle told TIME editor Nancy Gibbs_


by 

[Aric Jenkins](https://time.com/author/aric-jenkins/)


## Aric Jenkins


Aug 17, 2017 8:40 PM UTC

White nationalists have been empowered not only by the presidency of Donald Trump but also by the rise of the "digital communications revolution," Washington Post columnist and former TIME editor-at-large David Von Drehle told TIME editor Nancy Gibbs 

by 

[Aric Jenkins](https://time.com/author/aric-jenkins/)


## Aric Jenkins


Aug 17, 2017 8:40 PM UTC

White nationalists have been empowered not only by the presidency of [Donald Trump](http://time.com/4904270/will-nation-succeed-after-charlottesville/) but also by the rise of the “digital communications revolution,” Washington _Post_ columnist and former TIME editor-at-large David Von Drehle told TIME editor Nancy Gibbs at an event Thursday.

Von Drehle, who was interviewed by Gibbs at the [Chautauqua Institution](http://chq.org/) in southwest New York state, said that today’s generation is living in “world historical times” that served as the backdrop for [last weekend’s violent clashes](http://time.com/after-charlottesville-ruddy-roye/) between white nationalists and counter-protestors in Charlottesville, Va. “The United States is a wonderful, open, loving country, but we’ve always had people who live in the United States who don’t fit that description,” Von Drehle said when asked by Gibbs how he approached writing about Saturday’s violence, which left one dead and more than a dozen others injured. “It’s been difficult for those folks to find each other and organize.

“\[But\] today, those same folks can communicate instantly and all day long,” Von Drehle added. “They can amplify each others prejudices and notions and they can easily organize each other’s events.”

Throughout the hour-long conversation, Von Drehle and Gibbs touched upon the power of the Internet and its role and impact on contemporary journalism — particularly in the age of President Trump. Gibbs pointed out that there has been a “journalistic challenge over the past five days” because “the President has doubled-down on many of the things that he has been criticized for.”

“What we hope for in a time like this is national leadership — especially the President of the United States — that can frame \[Charlottesville\] in a way that’s less terrifying, less divisive, and reaffirm the core principles of the United States,” Von Drehle said. “What I missed last week was that.”

Gibbs said there was an “extraordinary disconnect” because despite the turbulence of Trump’s presidency and a national spike in “diseases of despair” such as alcoholism and [opioid addiction](http://time.com/4896141/president-trump-opioid-national-emergency/), “we’re living in a period of extraordinary technological innovation and the longest uninterrupted period of peace since the Roman empire.


“A generation of optimists say that we are living in the greatest period to be alive ever in human history,” Gibbs added.

“Nancy’s always been the most optimistic person I know,” Von Drehle said to laughter in the audience. “I think there’s a real hunger for that — there’s always a hunger for tomorrow and what the next challenge is.”


## Transcript

[00:04] Thank you Michael. David
[00:10] and I are both so grateful to have been invited back to
[00:13] this historic and now evermore beautiful platform. I
[00:19] take seriously your challenge about civil discourse
[00:24] especially since our profession sits at the
[00:28] center of that challenge and that conversation. And
[00:32] bears some responsibility for the state of it in our
[00:35] country right now. This is something David and I both
[00:38] take seriously and so there's no one I would rather
[00:41] interrogation on this subject. This
[00:47] is an unscripted conversation, unless you count the fact
[00:50] that we've been talking for 30 years. [ LAUGH ]
[00:54] Including last night when we were the last people in the
[00:58] dining room of the Athenaeum. My apologies to the
[01:01] staff. The staff [ LAUGH ]. We've known each other
[01:04] since graduate school and I followed David's career
[01:08] plotting relentlessly to figure out a way to bring him to
[01:11] Time because I was certain that His fierce
[01:16] intellect which is well known to those of you who have
[01:19] read his books or heard him lecture here would have
[01:23] an important impact on our national conversation, and
[01:27] he met that challenge and more but perhaps never
[01:31] more so than in the last two years. When he was
[01:35] on the front lines of our coverage of this campaign and
[01:38] the election, and it was David who I called on election
[01:41] night, about eight hours before deadline saying, i think
[01:45] we're going to need a new story. [ LAUGH ] So you can
[01:49] imagine my reaction when he called me about the
[01:52] news of his return to the Washington Post and his leap
[01:56] into the world of columnizing. I felt tremendous loss
[02:00] as an editor, although great relief as a reader
[02:05] because we will still and a new and profound
[02:09] powerful audience will benefit from what you bring to
[02:12] this conversation. So consider this an exit interview,
[02:17] [ LAUGH ] Conducted in front of 5, 000 people.
[02:21] [ LAUGH ] And of course we have to start with the
[02:25] news, both of us found ourselves having to write
[02:29] about Charlottesville this week and. That
[02:35] is a particularly difficult of our many national tragedies
[02:39] and conflicts that we've wrestled and so I wonder how
[02:44] you, particularly in your new role, not writing the news
[02:47] but writing what you make it, how you thought about it.
[02:50] [ BLANK_AUDIO ]
[02:52] Well it's my great pleasure to be here in one of my
[02:56] favorite places on Earth. And
[03:00] the home of free and open- minded
[03:06] dialogue, and good faith that's been going on here.
[03:10] Uninterrupted longer than, perhaps, anywhere on the
[03:13] face of the earth, with the possible exception
[03:18] of those rooms you had at New College and Oxford
[03:20] where it may have gone on for hundreds and hundreds
[03:23] of years. And it's a
[03:27] great honor to be with you, because Having
[03:31] the opportunity to write for Time. Time's unique
[03:36] [ COUGH ] national audience, excuse me [ COUGH ],
[03:43] has been one of the great honors of my life. And I
[03:47] don't know if I know how to write a column, but I'm
[03:49] gonna find out. [ LAUGH ]. The,
[03:53] [ BLANK_AUDIO ] The thing that I think
[03:58] we cannot keep in mind enough and
[04:03] I harp on this all the time and people if you heard me
[04:06] say these things before I apologize but
[04:11] we're living in World historical times,
[04:16] because of the digital communications revolution
[04:22] that is going on around us that has totally upended
[04:28] life for most of us in this room, because we grew up in
[04:31] one Era and we're now living in to
[04:35] another one as different as the era before Gutenberg
[04:40] and the era after Gutenberg. Gutenberg's
[04:44] invention of movable type caused
[04:51] search follow one events as the reformation The
[04:56] scientific revolution, the enlightenment, the industrial
[04:59] age. All of these, the rise of democracy for that
[05:03] matter, all of these things happened because of the
[05:07] ability of people to communicate effectively across
[05:11] space and time. That print created, that movable type
[05:15] created. And if the world can be changed that much
[05:20] by pieces of lead, how much is the world going to
[05:24] be changed by Super computers in the palms of our
[05:28] hands. The ability of every person on the face of
[05:32] the earth to become their own media producer, their
[05:36] own media aggregator, their own managing editor for
[05:40] their own mind space. So that's the
[05:44] background. Of Charlottesville. The
[05:50] United States is a wonderful, open, loving
[05:54] country, but we have always had
[05:58] people who live in the United States who don't fit that
[06:01] description. Who, for whatever reason, are hateful, are
[06:04] exclusionary, are incendiary And
[06:08] it's been difficult for those folks to find each
[06:13] other and communicate and to organize. As
[06:18] recently as when I started my career in news
[06:22] 35 years ago, the way the
[06:27] White Nationalist Movements communicated was
[06:30] through mimeographs. Inexpensive newsletters
[06:34] that were produced in small towns and mailed to small
[06:38] mailing lists across the country. Today
[06:43] the same folks Can communicate instantly
[06:48] and all day long. New people can easily find
[06:52] them, can enter into their conversations. They can
[06:57] rapidly feed on each other, egg each other on, amplify
[07:02] each other's prejudices and notions. And they
[07:06] can easily organize events, like the event in
[07:09] Charlottesville which would have been very difficult to
[07:11] do in an earlier time. And now, can
[07:16] be organized almost like a flash mob and not only that
[07:19] but a resistance to that, is created in
[07:23] the same way. And so What looks on our TV
[07:27] screens like something that's never existed before
[07:33] is not necessarily any new population.
[07:42] It's a new era. It's a new time when populations can
[07:46] easily find each other And come together and
[07:50] in this case come together in conflict. [ BLANK_AUDIO ]
[07:56] What we hope for in a time like this is
[08:00] a national leadership especially a president of the
[08:04] United States who can frame this in a way that
[08:08] is Less terrifying, less
[08:13] divisive, that can reaffirm
[08:18] the core shared principles of the United States, and
[08:22] put the whole thing into a context. And so what I
[08:26] missed over the past week [ BLANK_AUDIO ] Was
[08:31] that. And well we can talk about
[08:35] this some more but it is. There's
[08:40] a growing feeling that I have in watching President
[08:44] Trump that makes me question whether He's
[08:49] happy in the job and wants to do it. [ APPLAUSE ]
[09:00] I want to come back to that because there's a lot that
[09:04] goes with that. But the, I'm struck by Something in what
[09:07] you just said. Because what we've been exploring this
[09:09] week with an interesting range of speakers has to do
[09:12] with ethical challenges in this digital age and so one of
[09:16] the things presented by Charlottesville, that we
[09:20] all hear is that by covering an
[09:24] event like this in the way that we have. By putting
[09:29] microphones in front of white supremacist protestors,
[09:33] that we are giving them a platform. And that the
[09:37] principle that most journalists operate by is that
[09:40] sunlight is the best disinfectant. That you should
[09:43] expose ideas to maximum debate rather than
[09:48] Quarantining them, don't cover them, don't give them
[09:51] oxygen and then they will go away. That tension has
[09:54] existed in some sense forever, but it is vastly more
[09:58] acute now exactly because of the ability to
[10:02] build audiences, and reach audiences that is so
[10:05] unprecedented. How do you navigate that We are
[10:08] giving a platform to haters by covering those
[10:13] groups in the way we've seen in the last five days.
[10:17] Personally, I don't, well obviously,
[10:23] I can't write about everything every day, right? So I'm
[10:25] making choices, I'm distinguishing, here's the thing that
[10:29] I think is important today. So that's an editorial
[10:32] Function. I'm leaving most of the world out and
[10:35] choosing to train my lens here. But
[10:40] having said that, I'm very uncomfortable with the idea
[10:43] that
[10:45] the free press in the United States should filter
[10:51] the American experience For its audience. It's
[10:57] not our job to decide what the country should be or
[11:01] to decide where the country should go. That's
[11:05] the job of the American people. It's our job to try to
[11:10] provide them with information. To help them make the
[11:13] choices that they are called on to make, and
[11:17] I think it's our obligation to do that though in a way
[11:21] that's open- minded, that's inquisitive, that's fact
[11:25] based, that's Willing to learn,
[11:30] willing to question. And so, I think you could go to
[11:34] Charlottesville, and you could train your camera on
[11:40] what's a horrible newsworthy
[11:45] event, a torch lit neo- nazi march Through
[11:50] one of the historical seats of
[11:55] the concept of human dignity and equality. I
[12:00] think you can do that but can we bring to it also
[12:05] a sense of how many people are there? Why
[12:12] did they come, how did they come to be there, how far
[12:15] flung were these groups. Is
[12:20] this representative of Virginia, is
[12:24] it representative of one part of Virginia, is this people
[12:28] as I think given that the Young man who was
[12:32] arrested there was from Ohio. I'll
[12:37] bet that you had people road- tripping from all over
[12:40] the country and so, if you tell
[12:44] me that there were 500 or 1000 Neo- Nazis
[12:48] gathered. From across the nation of 330 million
[12:53] people, that makes me less worried than
[12:57] if I think that this, could it be happening in my
[13:02] neighborhood next week. And I think it's the first and
[13:05] not the second. I don't think we're a more hateful
[13:08] country than we were A week ago or a month ago or
[13:11] two years ago or ten years ago, that to
[13:16] me is the journalistic function. Help us figure out
[13:20] what this is, and you need to understand, when you do
[13:25] that there are interested sources Not
[13:30] just on the right who want
[13:34] those numbers to be as big as they can possibly
[13:39] convey them to be. If you're in the business of fighting
[13:43] hate, it's good for you to have a
[13:47] going business in the hate business. [ BLANK_AUDIO ]
[13:51] And I hope that doesn't sound cynical but as
[13:56] a journalist I'm always looking for what
[14:01] are the interests being served across the board. We
[14:08] also witnessed as another journalistic challenge in this
[14:12] last five days, the fact that from
[14:16] the moment of the Charlottesville mayhem,
[14:22] the President's response came under fire from
[14:26] certainly from many in the press, from commentators,
[14:29] from members of his own party, from CEOs. And yet
[14:33] he has doubled down on many of the things for which
[14:36] he was most being criticized. Which seems like, apart
[14:40] from everything else, a self- destructive impulse if you
[14:44] have an agenda that you're looking to get through,
[14:45] much less if you're looking to unify the country. And But
[14:50] it reminded me, having watched this, of an
[14:52] extraordinary argument that you made in a
[14:57] cover story that we ran in January of 2016,
[15:01] which means it was before a single vote had been cast
[15:04] in Iowa or New Hampshire. And the line of the cover
[15:08] was, how Trump won. And you talked about
[15:13] his understanding of how the media works and
[15:17] what he had already accomplished. Which of course
[15:20] knowing what we know now and what we even just
[15:23] seen on the last five days is even more.
[15:28] Confounding, surprising, unprecedented. So I wonder
[15:32] if you could explain a little about this intermediation.
[15:35] Sure. Preferably without using that term then.
[15:39] [ LAUGH ] That precedent cover headline
[15:44] was written by someone on this stage but it wasn't me.
[15:59] [ LAUGH ] [ BLANK_AUDIO ] In Silicon Valley, the term
[16:02] is, or was for a while disintermediation.
[16:08] Which just means getting read of the middleman and
[16:12] you can see how the digital
[16:17] revolution has enable that to happen across a
[16:21] wide range of American institutions. If you
[16:25] were in the department store buyer business,
[16:31] Choosing the clothes that we're going to be on offer
[16:35] at Macy's stores across the country. All of a sudden
[16:39] your business is heavily threatened by
[16:45] people online who are just posting pictures of things
[16:47] that they like, let alone by Amazon. com. The
[16:53] middle- man is taken out of the picture. What we saw
[16:56] this year is that Donald
[17:00] Trump intentionally, or by instinct, realized
[17:05] that politics was ripe for disintermediation. And
[17:09] he disintermediated The Republican
[17:13] party. The Republican party did not
[17:17] want Donald Trump, by which I mean the established,
[17:22] the RNC, the Governors, the Senators.
[17:27] In 2015, none of them were Hoping
[17:32] that Donald Trump was gonna be their party's
[17:34] candidate. But he went right past them. He went
[17:38] through them and went past them. He
[17:40] disintermediated the endorsers,
[17:45] the kingmakers. It didn't matter how many
[17:49] endorsements Jed Bush or Ted Cruz or
[17:53] Marco Rubio could pile up. It got them nothing. And
[17:59] most of all perhaps he disintermediated the press. Our
[18:04] traditional screening function where we say
[18:09] that this has gone too far, that that is too much.
[18:14] That used to mean something. And it became
[18:19] rapidly clear to me that it meant absolutely nothing.
[18:22] Because week after week you would see the wise
[18:26] people of the media talking about well, now he's truly
[18:30] gone too far. And [ BLANK_AUDIO ]
[18:35] Instead he was practicing something the great Henry
[18:42] Southworth Allen, the best feature writer I've ever
[18:44] known called going too far enough, was what
[18:48] he was really doing.
[18:53] He was able to do that, I think, because he
[18:57] had a relationship that he had been building with his
[19:00] supporters, with his audience for decades. It
[19:05] wasn't something that he came up with right at that
[19:08] moment, there were people who felt like they knew
[19:11] Donald Trump from His art of the deal period
[19:16] back in the late 80s and early 90s going
[19:22] for New yorker all the way back to the home in where
[19:26] he proved he could outdo the city of New York and
[19:30] get a nice ring built in central park in a matter of
[19:34] months. Where it had taken the city years and years
[19:37] and years with no success. He really hit his stride
[19:42] with his TV show, The Apprentice, which was for a
[19:46] while the most popular, quote unquote reality TV
[19:50] show in America. And if you think about how reality TV
[19:54] works, it's all about. Creating the illusion
[19:58] that you have a personal relationship with the people
[20:01] on the show. That you know them you've seen them at
[20:05] home and talking to their families and eating lunch
[20:09] and all this sort of thing. So obviously highly contrived
[20:12] but. The impression is, I know this person. So
[20:17] by the time he started to run for president, he had
[20:20] millions of Facebook followers, Twitter followers.
[20:25] And these people didn't need David von Drehle to
[20:30] tell them anything about Donald Trump. They felt they
[20:33] knew what they needed to know about him. And he
[20:35] built that audience Out,
[20:39] and one of the things they knew about him is that he's
[20:45] bristly and he's impulsive and he's the
[20:49] decisive and he says what's on his mind and doesn't
[20:52] care what other people think about it, and that was the
[20:55] brand. I
[20:59] spent a little time with him, and time with some of his
[21:03] staff members, and they were always just
[21:08] baffled by the traditional media analysis that, now
[21:12] he's the nominee, so he's gonna need to become more
[21:16] respectable. Or now he's done this so he's going to
[21:19] have to do that and his reaction was always what
[21:24] I'm doing is working. You know, he
[21:28] said to Time Magazine right after he was elected when
[21:31] we asked some version of the are you going to be
[21:34] " presidential" now, and he said I'm president,
[21:39] you're not. [ LAUGH ]
[21:42] Which by the way, is exactly true. He was and we
[21:46] weren't. It's very hard to persuade a person who is in
[21:50] the end zone that they don't know how to score a
[21:53] touchdown. [ APPLAUSE ]
[21:58] [ APPLAUSE ]
[22:02] I will say about that story, on two different occasions,
[22:07] and most recently this spring during a fairly unusual
[22:10] dinner, with the President at the White House. He told
[22:15] me that that story was The best explanation
[22:20] of why he won that anyone wrote during the campaign.
[22:23] And he was particularly impressed and somewhat
[22:25] shocked that you had written it without interviewing
[22:28] him- That really bothered him. He said that over and
[22:31] over to me and about me. That he
[22:36] cannot comprehend how a story could be written about
[22:38] him Without talking to him, and that
[22:42] gets us back to this week. When
[22:49] we were together on his plane during the primaries,
[22:54] I had the surreal experience of Of being
[22:59] 30 thousand feet in the air flying along in
[23:03] a flying living room with
[23:10] a huge flat screen television on the wall.
[23:16] Then candidate Trump had his clicker out, and
[23:20] for an hour and a half he clicked from one station
[23:25] to the next. And on every single station
[23:30] for the entire 90 minutes, the only topic being
[23:33] discussed was Donald Trump. At one point, he clicked
[23:36] and there was footage from the Vatican and
[23:41] I thought, okay, well, they're gonna talk about the
[23:43] Pope, you know, the other most famous person on
[23:46] earth. No, it was here's what the Pope thinks about
[23:49] Donald Trump. [ LAUGH ]
[23:52] In a way, it was like being in a James Bond movie and I
[23:55] was flying along with. Goldfinger or something.
[23:58] [ LAUGH ]
[24:01] But when he turned to me to
[24:06] explain what I was saying, I mean, he hit the nail on the
[24:08] head. He said, see David, this is what it's all about,
[24:12] ratings. Ratings are
[24:16] power. [ BLANK_AUDIO ]
[24:21] The question we're living through is are ratings power
[24:25] for the president of the United States. See,
[24:29] if you look at the response to Charlottesville you
[24:34] can see it's very important to him to be driving the
[24:36] conversation, to be at the center Of the conversation,
[24:41] so that it's not about Charlottesville, it's about
[24:46] Donald Trump. [ BLANK_AUDIO ]
[24:53] Traditionally part of being the President is knowing
[24:57] when to step back from stories. To understand
[25:01] that the gravitose of the office is going to compel
[25:05] people. You've
[25:09] written about so many presidents and you know that
[25:11] there are periods where they are deliberately silent.
[25:16] My favorite president, Abraham Lincoln Or
[25:21] as President Trump calls him, the late, great President
[25:25] Lincoln. [ LAUGH ]
[25:30] Because he is no longer living. [ LAUGH ]
[25:37] Lincoln was absolutely. Sphinx like for most
[25:42] of the civil war. He would make
[25:48] public appearances on a train platform or something
[25:51] like that and people would be gathered, they'd start
[25:54] cheering for a speech, and he would say I'm sorry, So
[26:00] much attention is paid to every word I say that I cannot
[26:04] afford to say a wrong word. So
[26:08] I'm not going to give the speech.
[26:12] And then, famously, the ones he did [ LAUGH ] were
[26:14] pretty darn short. [ LAUGH ]. They were good, but they
[26:16] were not long. So that's a question, is
[26:21] it going to be good for the success of President Trump
[26:26] as a president for him to feel like he needs to be
[26:29] driving the conversation every day, and since we're
[26:32] talking about the media, is it going to be good for us in
[26:36] the long run To have our agenda driven
[26:40] ever day by President Trump, are we going to
[26:44] change who we are, what we do, what our judgement
[26:47] is because he's driving
[26:52] that. So we frequently will be criticized for I think in the
[26:56] month of June, each week had a theme. There was
[27:00] Infrastructure Week and Health Care Week. And
[27:05] the reporters came under a lot of criticism for not
[27:08] spending more time focusing on the substance of those
[27:11] issues. And yet, of the 120
[27:16] some tweets from the president that, during that time,
[27:19] something like 13 of them had anything to do with
[27:21] those issues. And so the question is, do you cover what
[27:26] the president thinks is important because he's the
[27:28] president and it's important to cover that? Or do you
[27:31] cover what, arguably, Concretely affects
[27:35] many more millions of people's lives, the state of our
[27:37] infrastructure, the state of our health care, rather the
[27:39] tax code is reformed. Do you take your eyes of
[27:43] him when he, if your right is deliberately making that
[27:47] as hard as possible to do, or do you find that balance?
[27:51] Cause right now you sort of have a perfect
[27:53] co- dependent, enabling. Relationship. If he is at war
[27:56] with the press, it's a war that his base and supporters
[27:59] love. And it's a war that has driven record ratings,
[28:03] audiences, subscriptions for every news organizations.
[28:06] And neither side has an incentive for anything to be
[28:10] changed unless the country is being damaged by it.
[28:15] Which is why, I mean you've hit the nail on the head.
[28:20] It's wonderful to start each week with the important
[28:25] national issue that we're gonna discuss. You know, this
[28:28] is health care week. And you know, by that
[28:32] afternoon or the next morning, we discover, no it's It's
[28:36] President Trump week again. But that
[28:41] is deliberately him. You remember
[28:45] that Tuesday's press conference was a press
[28:49] conference about infrastructure. And a
[28:53] very important about regulations. Impression that he
[28:55] really wanted to talk about infrastructure
[28:57] [ BLANK_AUDIO ] The,
[29:05] I hate to keep getting back to these darn smartphones.
[29:10] But, just as they've taken the power
[29:16] Away from us to decide what these folks are going to
[29:19] hear and talk about. They've taken a lot
[29:23] of the responsibility that we've born and
[29:27] put it right back on all of you. If
[29:32] you want to engage with substantive issues in the
[29:35] United States of America or around the world. It has
[29:39] never been easier, there is more information inside
[29:42] this thing than there is easily accessible at the Library
[29:46] of Congress. You can, and I don't just mean
[29:51] this room because this is kind of preaching to the
[29:52] choir, I should talk well but the consumers of news
[29:56] have to decide what is the news you're gonna consume
[29:59] [ BLANK_AUDIO ] Are you going to, [ BLANK_AUDIO ]
[30:06] Expand your mind, challenge yourself, learn
[30:11] what are issues, how do they work? Are you gonna find
[30:15] the people who are knowledgeable interpreters along
[30:18] the way? Are you gonna support those missions? Are
[30:21] you gonna bring audience to those folks? Are you
[30:24] gonna catalyze conversations around those things.
[30:29] Or are you going to flow to
[30:34] these polarized interested other
[30:38] conversations. Time magazines had infrastructure
[30:43] on the cover in the past few months Had healthcare on
[30:46] the cover the past few months. And so these
[30:51] issues are being covered in a million different places.
[30:54] But the communication revolution
[30:58] just as it disintermediates the power from the
[31:03] middle man. It's distributing that power. To the
[31:07] individuals. And so it may be,
[31:13] I understand the frustration that causes people to say,
[31:16] why aren't you guys doing a better job? And God
[31:20] knows, that is a question we could talk about for
[31:24] hours, because The
[31:28] reason a lot of people don't like the media in America
[31:31] is in part because we haven't done a very good job.
[31:38] But, [ APPLAUSE ]
[31:41] Yeah, you won't hurt my feelings if you applaud for
[31:43] that.
[31:48] But there's no going back to 1970 and Walter
[31:51] Conchrite, that is over. And
[31:55] the future is empowered individuals deciding
[31:59] for themselves whether their going to be engaged,
[32:03] knowledgable, open minded, questing Intellects
[32:08] and citizens, or they going to choose an ideological
[32:12] box, disappear into it, and just spend their lives
[32:17] outraged by their opponents, and congratulating
[32:20] themselves. [ APPLAUSE ]
[32:29] That raises the obvious question. We've been talking a
[32:33] lot this week about what we got wrong and how as an
[32:37] industry and a profession we need to do some
[32:41] rigorous self- scrutiny. How
[32:45] is it possible both that the
[32:49] media was accused of overcovering, miscovering
[32:55] the campaign and this administration, and at the same
[32:59] time got it wrong, missed the story. [ BLANK_AUDIO ]
[33:05] [ LAUGH ]
[33:09] [ BLANK_AUDIO ]
[33:13] There's so many ways we could go with that. There's
[33:16] the shiny object. If
[33:21] you think about what's changed since we came into the
[33:23] business In 1934 together. [ LAUGH ]
[33:37] I mean, I think you'd agree, that the speed of
[33:42] the business is the biggest change. Yes.
[33:48] If your going to produce a news item
[33:52] or reaction to a news item, 5 or 6 or 7 times
[33:56] a day and the
[34:01] premium is gonna be on who can get up the fastest.
[34:05] And be the first out there. Or if you're not the first
[34:10] out there, who can be the most extreme
[34:14] or inflammatory. You're
[34:19] gonna be chasing the shiniest object from moment to
[34:22] moment. And [ BLANK_AUDIO ]
[34:27] If you're chasing the shiny object, you're gonna miss
[34:30] the important stuff. So that's how we overcovered
[34:35] the election and missed it at the same time.
[34:36] [ BLANK_AUDIO ]
[34:39] The second thought there, is that what happened in
[34:42] 2016 was something new. And journalism,
[34:48] especially political journalism, is based
[34:52] on stuff that's old. We apply
[34:57] the patterns that have held in the past to the future.
[35:02] This is not gonna be a good way to cover politics in
[35:04] the. [ LAUGH ] In the future, because the things that
[35:08] use to happen are not gonna keep happening. The
[35:13] Democratic party is not gonna go in a dark room
[35:16] somewhere eight years before an election,
[35:21] and decide who their candidate's gonna be eight years
[35:24] from now. As they did immediately after Barack
[35:28] Obama was elected and the entire party decided it
[35:32] will be Hillary's turn next time. All right that will
[35:36] never happen again. And it almost didn't succeed
[35:41] this time
[35:43] in the Democratic nominations. So,
[35:49] 2016 was a new thing, and we kept applying the
[35:52] lenses of the past to say what could happen. Can a
[35:56] vanity candidate win a nomination? No.
[36:00] Never happened. Won't happen in the future. Could
[36:05] the Republican party Which as always been the party
[36:08] of the next guy in line, right. It's not
[36:12] your turn this time but your turn will come.
[36:17] We could see who the future nominees were going to
[36:19] be stretching out into the distance. Could
[36:23] that party possibly Nominate someone
[36:28] that no one in the establishment wanted. No, that
[36:30] could never happen. Well, it did happen, and on,
[36:35] and on, and on. Could large numbers
[36:39] of people, when pollsters call them and ask
[36:43] who they're going to vote for Mislead the pollsters.
[36:50] No, we've got all kinds of fail- safes for that. Well, yes,
[36:52] actually, they can. We found that out.
[36:57] [ BLANK_AUDIO ] And could the media echo chamber,
[37:00] instead of forming conventional wisdom, Create
[37:07] a mutually reinforcing mistake machine. Well
[37:13] no, the echo chamber over time has sort of sorted out
[37:16] the truth, it might take a few days but eventually it
[37:19] would coalesce around what was gonna happen, right?
[37:22] Or what had happened. In 2016, We
[37:27] just [ BLANK_AUDIO ]
[37:29] Managed to feed our own mistake, that
[37:34] this thing somehow is not going to happen, and we fed
[37:38] that mistake right up to 8: 20 PM
[37:43] on Election Day.
[37:47] [ LAUGH ] I remember that phone call when we said I
[37:53] don't think we have the right cover ready. [ LAUGH ]
[37:58] Yeah. So here's one more ingredient I would test
[38:03] on you. Which we've talked a lot about. That We
[38:07] had an inaugural address that included a reference to
[38:10] American carnage. We've had an extraordinary
[38:15] portrait painted of a country that is experiencing
[38:20] an epidemic of what epidemiologists call diseases of
[38:23] despair. There was a report just last week that rates
[38:27] of alcoholism jump 49 % in a single decade and
[38:31] that's on top off the [ UNKNOWN ] crisis that was
[38:35] declared a national emergency last week. We've talk
[38:39] about economic dislocation about the weights on the
[38:43] American Spirit in all sorts of ways. At the same time,
[38:49] we're living in a period of extraordinary technological
[38:53] innovation. Of constant life altering and life
[38:57] saving medical breakthroughs. Of the longest
[39:02] uninterrupted period of peace since the Roman
[39:04] Empire. And a generation of optimists
[39:10] who were saying we are living in the greatest moment
[39:14] for human beings to be alive ever in human history.
[39:19] That's an extraordinary disconnect. It is. And certainly,
[39:23] the way As journalists we tell the story of what is
[39:27] happening in this country speaks to these
[39:31] two ways of portraying the state of our national body
[39:35] and soul. How important was that? [ BLANK_AUDIO ]
[39:42] Nancy pointed out to me last night when I was waxing
[39:46] optimistic about How good things really are. Reminded
[39:53] me how unlikely that conversation would have been
[39:55] years ago when I was a thorough going pessimist.
[39:59] Nancy's always been the most optimistic person I know
[40:04] And that's because she's the most mature and wisest
[40:08] person I know. [ LAUGH ] And it's taken me a long
[40:12] time to give into that wisdom that she's always
[40:17] possessed. To me, the most striking
[40:21] and baffling thing going on in the United States right
[40:24] now Is the cloud
[40:29] of pessimism that's hanging over this country. As
[40:36] I go through my life and my reporting and my
[40:40] work and my reading, I just don't see
[40:45] the objective Basis for it. We are going
[40:49] through extraordinary change. That extraordinary
[40:52] change in the economic sphere is causing a
[40:56] lot of dislocation. Economic dislocation is
[41:01] not new to the United States. You know a hundred
[41:05] years ago over 90 % of Americans made their livings
[41:09] on small farms. The number of Americans
[41:14] who make their livings on small farms now could
[41:17] probably fit in this room. And their all P. H. D. 's
[41:23] from Yale with little. You know [ LAUGH ]
[41:28] artisanal vegetable patches. [ LAUGH ]
[41:35] There's nobody in America who is forced to like get up
[41:39] at dawn on a farm with no running water and no
[41:43] electricity and go out and scratch a living out of the
[41:47] soil, it doesn't exist so, that some how all went away
[41:51] and yet here we are in america the fact that
[41:56] people are no longer getting up and going down into
[41:59] coal mines by the hundreds of thousands
[42:03] to risk their lives underground and die and early
[42:07] death of black lung or no longer going to Factories
[42:13] to stand next to an assembly line and tighten the same
[42:17] bolt on the same axle for eight hours a day
[42:22] and go home. I think we're gonna survive
[42:27] that. I don't know what it'll look like, but we've always
[42:30] thrived. And that confidence is
[42:34] just completely missing from our conversation.
[42:39] I wrote a column last week about
[42:43] the Democratic party, which seems to me to have
[42:48] doubled down on the idea that lost in November.
[42:52] Which is if we just oppose Donald Trump hard enough,
[42:57] America's gonna come our way. Here's
[43:01] this huge, open, unoccupied bit of the playing
[43:05] field called American Optimism that has
[43:10] been a winner from day one til. Ten
[43:14] years ago just completely unoccupied. Go run out
[43:18] there, show us a future that we can buy into with
[43:22] excitement. Don't just tell us what you're gonna save
[43:24] us from. [ APPLAUSE ] Right. [ APPLAUSE ] No ,?
[43:25] Uh- uh. [ APPLAUSE ] I
[43:32] think there'; s a real hunger for that. I think there's
[43:35] always a hunger in the United States for tomorrow. For
[43:39] what's the next challenge? For tell us how we're gonna
[43:42] tackle this and we will go tackle it. So That's
[43:48] what, if I go about the country trying to write a column
[43:51] that's not the exact same outraged, panicked column
[43:54] that everybody else is writing, that's what I'm gonna be
[43:58] looking for is. And it's happening. If
[44:04] it's happening in states, it's happening locally, it's
[44:06] happening in the incredible private sector of the United
[44:10] States. We talk about the data point last night. 2005,
[44:16] the building sector of the United States which is,
[44:20] this is all the built environment. Houses, office
[44:23] buildings This amphitheater. It accounts for
[44:27] something between 40 and 45 % of greenhouse gas
[44:31] emissions from the United States. In 2005, the best
[44:35] scientists in America said that the built environment
[44:40] sector, their emissions will increase by. 50 %
[44:47] by 2016. Okay so the data's now
[44:51] in. We have over 12 billion additional
[44:57] square feet of built environment. And the emissions
[45:01] from the sector are down 16 % [ APPLAUSE ]
[45:10] You know that's what's going on in America. You know?
[45:15] That's the reality. So let's see if political
[45:19] party or a candidate get behind that, you know? I
[45:24] think there's a chance to win some elections there. I
[45:28] would say you had missed your calling if you weren't so
[45:30] good at what you do. I have a last question for you
[45:33] because | I know a lot of people have a lot of things on
[45:36] their mind. But again, the theme of this week is both
[45:40] about ethics, but a number of the speakers have
[45:42] posed about what the media As a constitutionally
[45:47] protected industry. The First Amendment doesn't just
[45:51] protect free speech, it protects a free press, as though
[45:55] a functioning, growing, healthy democracy depends on
[45:59] us not screwing up. And so I would ask what
[46:05] Would you say would you like us to do individually and
[46:08] collectively to restore trust in journalism
[46:12] which is at historically low levels and get
[46:17] our act together. I could turn that around
[46:21] to you because you're responsible for more than
[46:25] just What comes out of your own typewriter.
[46:33] I want to say because I've done all the talking it
[46:39] was a tremendous honor to work at
[46:43] Time through this election. Because the pressures
[46:48] on the editors of our great journalistic
[46:53] institutions, I don't think, rarely
[46:57] if ever have been anymore intense. The
[47:01] push to stop doing what we do, as journalists
[47:06] And start doing something else, political activism, not
[47:14] that there's anything wrong with political activism, it's
[47:17] just not what we do, we do a different
[47:21] thing and And you handled
[47:25] that so brilliantly. And I know under tremendous
[47:30] pressure. So my short answer would be more Nancy
[47:34] Gibbs's. [ APPLAUSE ] Well thank you for that. But
[47:42] I also know those are hard to find. I
[47:47] think as journalists, we need to be
[47:53] more humble first off, a
[47:57] lot more humble.
[48:00] More open minded [ BLANK_AUDIO ]
[48:07] More questioning, especially of our own assumptions.
[48:14] Why do I think this? Why do I think this is right? Against
[48:18] all the evidence I see out in the world, why do I still
[48:21] think X or Y is right? And
[48:26] more transparent. Because it's now the leaders who
[48:30] have the power we've got to surrender
[48:35] to that. We got to say look, this is my best effort, here's
[48:41] how I got here show our work more than maybe we
[48:43] used to do And be
[48:49] open to the fact that before or after publication,
[48:54] you might hear something that changes your mind. I'm
[48:58] not going to name names, but we all know there are
[49:01] plenty of journalists who Have bully
[49:05] pulpits who are at a point in their lives or careers
[49:09] where nothing that could happen, or be said, or
[49:14] be done, would change their minds about anything.
[49:17] That, to me, is not journalism.
[49:21] So. [ APPLAUSE ] Thank
[49:33] you to Nancy and David for an incredible conversation
[49:36] that will now continue with all of you If you are exiting
[49:40] to head to other programming or if you're just
[49:44] resituating yourselves in seats as they become
[49:46] available, we ask that you do that as quietly as
[49:48] possible so that we can continue our dialogue. Just a
[49:51] reminder that there are three additional ways to
[49:54] participate in our conversation today. One is on
[49:57] online. chq. org. We're also live streaming on Facebook
[50:00] and you can participate in the conversation via a
[50:02] Twitter At hashtag CHQ 2017.
[50:08] We had an opportunity earlier this week. She talked
[50:10] about the journalism committee that's helping us think
[50:12] through how journalism shows up in the narrative of
[50:15] what we do at Chatauqua. And, one of the things that
[50:20] was raised there, David, that speaks to some of the
[50:22] things you hit on. The speed of the business The
[50:26] personality building traits of journalists, whereas
[50:29] journalists didn't used to be the personalities, was a
[50:32] conversation about sources, and sourcing. And that
[50:37] codes of ethics for journalists may need to look at
[50:41] more rigorous denotations Of sourcing.
[50:46] What's your prospective on how journalism has
[50:50] perhaps thought differently about attributing its
[50:53] sources. Who's doing that? How are journalists thinking
[50:56] about proving the source material? Because one of the
[51:00] things that these journalists said was, in those
[51:03] journalistic outposts that are considered echo
[51:05] chambers, it's extremely Easy if you don't have to be
[51:09] rigorous in your sourcing and saying, this is truth, pr
[51:12] this is truth. Same topic, two different perspectives,
[51:15] both of which are being claimed as truth.
[51:18] [ BLANK_AUDIO ] We
[51:26] have a lot of technology now where we can link inside
[51:30] the stories to Supporting documentation
[51:35] when I wrote that, I
[51:39] didn't pull that statistics about green house gas
[51:42] emission out of my head. I learned it last week from a
[51:46] report and When I write about it I
[51:51] can link the report into the story and it shows up as a
[51:55] hot link, and anybody who wants to check my facts or
[51:59] say where on Earth did he get that can click on the
[52:03] button and off they go. I think that's a powerful tool.
[52:09] That will be easier and easier to use. And it's
[52:12] something that the engaged news consumer that I
[52:16] talked about earlier needs to do once in a while.
[52:20] Where are these hotlinks going exactly? And
[52:24] do they in fact support what's Being
[52:29] said, that doesn't touch though on the
[52:35] epidemic of blind sourcing in
[52:40] political writing. And that's not a
[52:44] new problem, that's been around as long as. We've
[52:48] been doing this and every news organization I've ever
[52:52] worked at
[52:55] has every few years of committee that gets together of
[52:59] senior editors and they talk through what are sourcing
[53:04] policy's gonna be. And this usually results in a Memo
[53:08] of some great length and detail with
[53:13] rules of the road for sourcing and it often goes into the
[53:16] official handbook of the institution and within
[53:21] a few months we're right back to where we were
[53:23] before. [ BLANK_AUDIO ]
[53:33] So I guess I'd say I'm not sure that's ever gonna end. I
[53:37] mean, you have to let through some
[53:42] blind sourcing at time. Well, particularly This
[53:47] is very unusual White House. It's been likened to a sort
[53:51] of Game of Thrones Red Wedding. A
[53:55] lot of what we know that has often ultimately been
[53:59] confirmed by the president himself started out As a
[54:03] piece of information that came from someone who did
[54:06] not want their identity revealed. And so you're right
[54:09] that it has always been a balancing act. I do think we
[54:11] are in a more acute period, both because
[54:16] of the nature of the internal dynamic of this
[54:18] administration, which is critically important, But
[54:23] it's also true in our coverage of important stories
[54:27] oversees where people talking to reporters
[54:31] is not just a career threatening it can be a life
[54:33] threatening risk and we need to take very
[54:37] seriously. The fact that if we are willing to offer people
[54:41] protection in order to find out what's going on, that
[54:43] that is something that we will go to court, or go to jail,
[54:47] to protect. Right, absolutely. [ APPLAUSE ]
[54:54] So it comes down, I think, over time to The
[55:02] discerning news audience holding reporters
[55:08] and organizations accountable over time. And that's
[55:11] hard to do in this instant thing but, and
[55:16] I think we're starting to see it.
[55:21] There are big audiences, we haven't totally
[55:25] figured out how to monetize them but there
[55:29] are big audiences moving toward responsible
[55:33] journalism. There's an appetite for it. If we can
[55:37] just keep our heads. in the game and continue to
[55:42] have the standards that have served us in the pass
[55:45] and try to live up to those. I think that as
[55:50] people adjust to the technology they're are going to be
[55:52] coming our way. The other thing that I
[55:56] have notice happening which i think is good Is
[56:03] there's a verging business in trying
[56:07] to identify other Peoples sources. Where
[56:13] I saw this done particularly well was just today. I
[56:17] forget who did it. NBC I think. They put together
[56:21] a series of clips showing
[56:26] that, [ BLANK_AUDIO ]
[56:29] Every time the president had sort of done something
[56:33] that would outrage the zip codes
[56:37] around Time headquarters in Manhattan,
[56:40] [ BLANK_AUDIO ]
[56:42] The following day, there would be an unsourced story
[56:45] reporting that Ivana Trump and Jared Kushner
[56:50] tried so hard to keep him from doing that,
[56:54] and unfortunately failed. And so you can see this
[56:58] transmission builds That gee,
[57:02] this is gonna get us in trouble with our friends back
[57:05] home, they're not gonna like this, so we're gonna need
[57:09] to leak the idea that we really tried to keep it from
[57:13] happening. I think that's healthy, I don't
[57:17] think trying to out the source for A story
[57:21] where careers and lives are at stake is a healthy thing
[57:24] to do. But pulling back the curtain a little bit
[57:29] on how interested parties inside
[57:33] our government play the sourcing game to
[57:38] their own advantage, I think that's very healthy.
[57:40] [ INAUDIBLE ]
[57:42] Mentioned the power of media consumers in this age,
[57:46] and one of our guests is asking you to speak, or both
[57:50] of you to speak to the power of consumer boycotts and
[57:54] specifically brings up the cancellation of the O'Reilly
[57:57] Factor as an example of how Audiences also
[58:00] participate in this. Can you speak to consumer
[58:02] boycotts, or the consumers role in navigating this
[58:04] media landscape. You know, it's
[58:10] a very tricky one, we're seeing it happening more
[58:12] often. All of every news organization is threatened.
[58:16] With boycotts. And obviously that power has always
[58:19] existed because anytime that you think that whether
[58:23] it's a television show or a newspaper or any news
[58:26] source is not behaving as you would like you can turn
[58:29] them off, change the channel, cancel your subscription.
[58:33] And so that feedback has always existed. There
[58:37] There are occasions now though, and again, it's
[58:40] amplified by the ability to activate a crowd and
[58:45] fuel outrage, that starts to feel like suppression of
[58:48] speech. And I'd be hard pressed to always know
[58:51] where that line is. But a fascinating example was the
[58:54] calls for boycotts in the blow back. To NBC and Megyn
[58:59] Kelly, for her interview with the conspiracy theorist Alex
[59:03] Jones. And this goes back to why are you
[59:07] giving someone with these hateful views this platform?
[59:11] And the answer that a lot of journalists will give is that
[59:17] Ignoring him doesn't mean that he vanishes. He has
[59:21] millions of followers and the ear of the president of the
[59:25] United States and so wishing that that were not the
[59:27] case and not covering it Is not
[59:32] the way any news organizations reflexes really work.
[59:35] And yet, there was tremendous opposition,
[59:37] tremendous blowback, calls for boycotts from that. So
[59:39] there's a place where it gets into
[59:44] A risk of suppression and I always think that the
[59:47] answer to hateful speech is more speech. And so,
[59:51] that's where boycotts can make me nervous, I don't
[59:54] know maybe you disagree. I agree, I always think when
[59:59] I hear this argument that if the press, mainstream
[1:00:03] press would just ignore Alex Jones, or I
[1:00:08] once profiled Glen Beck for the cover of Time when he
[1:00:12] was at his hottest. And I got a lot of criticism,
[1:00:18] just advancing. And I
[1:00:22] think of the kids that think if they close their eyes, no
[1:00:26] one can see them. You know, I disappeared.
[1:00:33] That's not how it works. And it's a free country and if
[1:00:36] people want to listen to Alex Jones, they can,
[1:00:40] whether Megyn Kelly wants that to be the case or
[1:00:45] not, or NBC brass Or the advertisers at Procter
[1:00:49] & Gamble. So, [ BLANK_AUDIO ]
[1:00:56] The specifics of the O'Reilly boycott, I
[1:01:00] would argue are not as simple as just a boycott was
[1:01:03] organized, and it was successful so let's have some
[1:01:06] more It was successful because
[1:01:11] A, it involved financial
[1:01:16] liability for Fox News. He was accused
[1:01:21] of
[1:01:23] and credibly accused of
[1:01:28] Potentially expensive offenses for the company and
[1:01:33] the company is in the process of a generational
[1:01:39] transition from the founder, Rupert
[1:01:44] Murdoch to his sons. And his sons. Have.
[1:01:48] They live in a different world, and they have a different
[1:01:51] view of what Fox should be. So all those things
[1:01:55] are going on at the same time. [ BLANK_AUDIO ] From
[1:01:58] Twitter, and in the audience here, commenting on
[1:02:03] the comment about a lack of optimism. And how
[1:02:07] asking one or both of you to comment on for
[1:02:11] half of the country, there is optimism for what
[1:02:14] President Trump is doing, and how are you thinking
[1:02:16] about covering that, and how
[1:02:20] are you thinking about, as media folks, that for half the
[1:02:23] country That elected the current president. There's not
[1:02:27] a lot of optimism. This is what they wanted.
[1:02:36] [ BLANK_AUDIO ] Well
[1:02:41] first I
[1:03:01] test the [ MUSIC ] 30, career of covering
[1:03:07] presidential politics. The two candidates were both
[1:03:11] deeply unpopular. And the number
[1:03:15] of people who cast votes feeling they were choosing
[1:03:20] the lesser of two lessers
[1:03:25] That was the decisive voting bloc. So- [ APPLAUSE ]
[1:03:34] But having said that, there are people who have come
[1:03:37] to believe that
[1:03:40] the establishment of the United States, however you
[1:03:42] define it, and you and I are part of it And probably this
[1:03:46] place, but certainly the elected governments
[1:03:50] from both parties. And the permanent government
[1:03:54] of bureaucracy and career people. And
[1:03:59] the intellectual leadership of the United States.
[1:04:02] However you define that, that this Group has ill
[1:04:07] served the nation over the past however
[1:04:11] many years you wanna define it, a generation, 50
[1:04:15] years. That this has been,
[1:04:19] [ BLANK_AUDIO ]
[1:04:22] Incitatory
[1:04:24] [ BLANK_AUDIO ] Self
[1:04:28] serving, self dealing, self satisfied. [ BLANK_AUDIO ]
[1:04:34] And that it needs to be broken up. And that
[1:04:39] was not new with Donald Trump. In
[1:04:45] 2008 We have a candidate who
[1:04:49] was not embrace by the establishment of his party.
[1:04:54] Who did not have much political experience, not quietly
[1:04:57] inexperience this Trump, but pretty damn close. Who
[1:05:01] did not look like any president we've ever had before.
[1:05:06] Who steam roll through the election in
[1:05:11] part because he seemed to represent an opportunity
[1:05:15] to fundamentally change the way things are done in
[1:05:19] the United States, and so I know a lot of people find it
[1:05:23] baffling that you could have Obama voters who
[1:05:27] became Trump voters. But that's
[1:05:31] who those people were. They were hoping they were
[1:05:34] gonna get the swamp
[1:05:40] drained in 2008. And they turn
[1:05:44] around and they try again Even more
[1:05:48] dramatically. So when they turn
[1:05:53] on their TV, and we in the media,
[1:05:57] and the elected parties, and the permanent
[1:06:01] government, and the intellectuals, and all these people
[1:06:04] are screaming about how bad Trump is A lot of them,
[1:06:08] and these include some of my neighbors and friends,
[1:06:12] they say he must be doing something right, if all those
[1:06:16] people are mad, maybe we're finally getting change,
[1:06:19] and that, I think, needs to be respected, I have a
[1:06:24] men's book club and we get together Six times a year
[1:06:29] and wonderful guy, Ken, great
[1:06:34] hardline conservative, small businessman, classic
[1:06:37] midwest republican and he
[1:06:41] was in an argument with the liberal, Presbyterian
[1:06:44] minister in the group. And they were going back and
[1:06:47] forth about Trump. And Ken finally said all I know is I
[1:06:52] really like his enemies. He's got all the right enemies.
[1:06:58] All I would add to that is that as journalists,
[1:07:03] typically we covered more what The President said,
[1:07:07] than what people heard. And so, he
[1:07:12] could say something, whether about proposing a
[1:07:13] Muslim ban, or that John McCain was not a war hero,
[1:07:17] or any of these things. And journalists would say, that's
[1:07:21] unsayable, that's unthinkable, that's disqualifying. And
[1:07:25] what a great many voters heard With his willingness to
[1:07:28] say the unsayable. And that even if they disagreed
[1:07:32] with the expression, even if they disagreed with
[1:07:35] picking a fight with Judge Curiel or with the Khan family
[1:07:39] and they believed John McCain is a war hero, that the
[1:07:41] meta message was I am willing to say and do things
[1:07:46] that right- thinking people Have never been willing to
[1:07:49] say and do, and that is what Washington needs now.
[1:07:51] And so if we miss the level of despair
[1:07:55] at the dysfunction, and as you say, the self dealing that
[1:07:59] had been going on for a very long time. And the risks
[1:08:02] people were willing to take with a very untested
[1:08:04] candidate because of a belief that something must be
[1:08:08] done Radical and dramatic in order for this country to
[1:08:11] move forward. That is, I think, a spirit that will
[1:08:15] abide. It abided long before this president. It will
[1:08:19] abide after, and speaks to fundamental challenges to
[1:08:22] our institutions, all of which the media Our
[1:08:26] lawmakers, our courts, private sector, public sector
[1:08:30] that needs to be taken very seriously. We could
[1:08:34] continue the conversations for hours and we have
[1:08:36] about a minute left and I will share the rest of the
[1:08:38] questions with you because they're thought provoking
[1:08:41] but in a minute for both of you, what can the media
[1:08:45] do. To regain trust and how should young journalists
[1:08:48] be thinking about that as they enter the field? Work
[1:08:56] harder. Think harder. Report
[1:09:03] harder. Be more humble. That's about That's about
[1:09:05] what I get. Get more interested in the world out there.
[1:09:09] Less interested in the world in here. [ APPLAUSE ] I
[1:09:16] got to return home yesterday morning and speak to
[1:09:20] the very talented young crew at The Daily. And I told
[1:09:23] them for all you are hearing about the sorry state of
[1:09:26] journalism. As it happens this is also the golden age of
[1:09:29] journalism. I'm delighted, it's still bitter, but you all will
[1:09:32] be hearing from Marty Baron tomorrow. The
[1:09:34] extraordinary editor of The Washington Post, who has
[1:09:38] brought an important institution off of life support back
[1:09:42] into the center of the national conversation.
[1:09:46] I think that the Yes, the challenges are great, but
[1:09:50] if we do our jobs well we will
[1:09:55] regain the trust by earning it. Thank you Nancy and
[1:09:58] David. [ APPLAUSE ]
[1:10:01] [ APPLAUSE ]
[1:10:04] Thank you, dear. [ APPLAUSE ]

```json
[{"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"NewsArticle","@id":"https://time.com/4904940/donald-trump-white-nationalists-gibbs-von-drehle/","mainEntityOfPage":{"@type":"WebPage","@id":"https://time.com/4904940/donald-trump-white-nationalists-gibbs-von-drehle/"},"headline":"Author David Von Drehle to TIME's Nancy Gibbs: White Nationalists Empowered by Trump — and Social Media","datePublished":"2017-08-17T20:40:43.000Z","dateModified":"2026-10-08T09:29:37.843Z","description":"Von Drehle was interviewed by Gibbs at a live streamed event at the Chautauqua Institution","url":"https://time.com/4904940/donald-trump-white-nationalists-gibbs-von-drehle/","keywords":["Media","onetime"],"thumbnailUrl":"https://static.time.com/v3/assets/bltea6093859af6183b/blt75314428504713d8/6988da32096a9418a869f318/20170817_ls_00009.jpeg?branch=production&width=1200&quality=75&auto=webp&crop=1200:675&height=675","author":[{"@type":"Person","name":"Aric Jenkins","jobTitle":null,"url":"https://time.com/author/aric-jenkins/"}],"articleSection":"Press Room","image":[{"@type":"ImageObject","url":"https://static.time.com/v3/assets/bltea6093859af6183b/blt75314428504713d8/6988da32096a9418a869f318/20170817_ls_00009.jpeg?branch=production&width=1200&quality=75&auto=webp&crop=1200:675&height=675","width":1200,"height":675,"headline":"20170817_ls_00009","caption":"TIME editor Nancy Gibbs with former TIME editor-at-large David Von Drehle at the Chautauqua Institution on Aug. 17.","creditText":"Lee Stein/Chautauqua Institution.","representativeOfPage":true}],"publisher":{"@type":"Organization","name":"Time","url":"https://time.com/","logo":{"@type":"ImageObject","url":"https://time.com/images/logo.png","width":528,"height":156},"foundingDate":"March 3, 1923","sameAs":["https://www.facebook.com/time","https://www.instagram.com/time/?hl=en","https://twitter.com/time","https://www.pinterest.com/timemagazine"]}},{"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"BreadcrumbList","itemListElement":[{"@type":"ListItem","position":1,"item":{"@id":"https://time.com/section/press-room/","name":"Press Room"}},{"@type":"ListItem","position":2,"item":{"@id":"https://time.com/tag/media/","name":"Media"}},{"@type":"ListItem","position":3,"item":{"@id":"https://time.com/4904940/donald-trump-white-nationalists-gibbs-von-drehle/","name":"Author David Von Drehle to TIME's Nancy Gibbs: White Nationalists Empowered by Trump — and Social Media"}}]},{"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"VideoObject","name":"Author David Von Drehle to TIME's Nancy Gibbs: White Nationalists Empowered by Trump — and Social Media","description":"White nationalists have been empowered not only by the presidency of Donald Trump but also by the rise of the \"digital communications revolution,\" Washington Post columnist and former TIME editor-at-large David Von Drehle told TIME editor Nancy Gibbs","thumbnailUrl":"https://cdn.jwplayer.com/v2/media/81T4ZjUj/poster.jpg?width=720","uploadDate":"2017-08-17T22:00:24.000Z","contentUrl":"https://cdn.jwplayer.com/manifests/81T4ZjUj.m3u8","embedUrl":"https://time.com/4904940/donald-trump-white-nationalists-gibbs-von-drehle/","duration":"PT1H10M22S","potentialAction":{"@type":"SeekToAction","target":"https://time.com/4904940/donald-trump-white-nationalists-gibbs-von-drehle/?jw_start={seek_to_second_number}","startOffset-input":"required name=seek_to_second_number"}}]
```

