Peyton Manning finally got to fulfill one of his childhood dreams on Wednesday night’s episode of The Tonight Show, but it didn’t happen exactly the way he expected. The Super Bowl 50 champion had the opportunity to play one-on-one with NBA Hall of Famer Magic Johnson — in a game of Egg Russian Roulette, that is.
Host Jimmy Fallon pitted the two star athletes against each other in a game that involved taking turns choosing an egg out of a carton and then smashing it over their heads. The twist: eight of the dozen were hardboiled, but four of them were raw.
Read More: Watch Zac Efron Play Egg Roulette with Jimmy Fallon
“I had dreams growing up of being able to play Magic one-on-one someday,” Manning said. “I never thought it’d be in Russian egg roulette.”
Watch the full clip above.
More Must-Reads From TIME
- The 100 Most Influential People of 2024
- The Revolution of Yulia Navalnaya
- 6 Compliments That Land Every Time
- What's the Deal With the Bitcoin Halving?
- If You're Dating Right Now , You're Brave: Column
- The AI That Could Heal a Divided Internet
- Fallout Is a Brilliant Model for the Future of Video Game Adaptations
- Want Weekly Recs on What to Watch, Read, and More? Sign Up for Worth Your Time
Write to Megan McCluskey at megan.mccluskey@time.com