Mariah Carey No Longer Has the Most-Played Christmas Song

Hold onto those Santa Claus hats, because the impossible has happened. Mariah Carey’s “All I Want for Christmas Is You” is no longer the most-played Christmas song. PlayNetwork, a company that creates playlists for more than 400 stores, has compiled a list of the 20 songs consumers will hear most this holiday season — and Carey’s 1994 hit has been bumped down to number 2.

Instead, The Shins’ cover of Paul McCartney’s “Wonderful Christmastime,” has claimed the top spot. See a list of the 20 most popular holiday songs according to PlayNetwork below.

Shins “Wonderful Christmastime”

Mariah Carey “All I Want For Christmas Is You”

Christina Aguilera “Christmas Time”

Waitresses “Christmas Wrapping”

Jack Johnson “Someday At Christmas”

Kelly Clarkson “Underneath The Tree”

Michael Buble “A Holly Jolly Christmas”

Bing Crosby “White Christmas”

Train “What Christmas Means To Me”

Ella Fitzgerald “Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas”

Coldplay “Christmas Lights”

Jose Feliciano “Feliz Navidad”

Sharon Jones & The Dap Kings “White Christmas”

Vince Guaraldi Trio “Christmas Time Is Here”

Sam Smith “Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas”

Pentatonix “The Christmas Song (Chestnuts Roasting On An Open Fire)”

Paul McCartney “Wonderful Christmastime”

She & Him “Baby, It’s Cold Outside”

Elvis Presley “Blue Christmas”

Darlene Love “Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)”

This article originally appeared on EW.com.