Frank Sinatra Recording Session
American singer and actor Frank Sinatra (1915 - 1998) gestures with his hands while singing into a microphone during a recording session in a studio at Capitol Records, early 1950s.  M. Garrett—Getty Images

Frank Sinatra’s Timing Was Even Better Than You Thought

Dec 11, 2015

In the early 1950s, a young teen boy used to bring hit records into a bar on New York City's Upper East Side. In exchange for keeping their jukebox current, the bartenders would let the teen have a drink on the sly. One afternoon he heard a record there that he didn't provide, and it would go on to change his life

“I remember it vividly as a Tuesday,” says the now-77-year-old Jonathan Schwartz. “I gave the bartender a dollar bill and asked him for ten dimes. So I listened to this record, which was called 'The Birth of the Blues,' ten times. The singing of it was so virile, so masculine, so understandable, so intense, so beautiful. I’d never heard anything like it.”

Today, Schwartz is a radio personality responsible for sharing several hours’ worth of Frank Sinatra each week: between his weekend show on WNYC, New York City’s flagship public radio station, and his 24-7 online station, The Jonathan Channel, he spins Sinatra every single day. Schwartz says that's because even now, 100 years after the singer was born, on Dec. 12, 1915, the public appetite for the crooner is still going strong.

What is it about Sinatra that has made the music endure so well? One of Sinatra’s special abilities, Schwartz says, was finding what the arranger Nelson Riddle called “the tempo of the heartbeat.”

But Sinatra’s great timing wasn’t limited to music. Much of his sound–and therefore his success–owes to his is being born in 1915 and finding his voice in the 1940s and ‘50s.

“Sinatra grew up in the world of Bing Crosby,” Schwartz says, and Crosby’s style dominated the airwaves well into the 1940s: the ideal male singer was a crooner, someone Schwartz summarizes as a “nice” singer. Sinatra would later say that, while he idolized Crosby, he knew that he didn’t want to sing like that—even before he knew what singing some other way would sound like. The eventual result, for Sinatra, was an emphasis on conveying emotion. And, because he was doing something different, and doing it extremely well, he would come to represent that new style of music.

“Without any question, he was the greatest interpretative singer who ever lived, in any music,” Schwartz says. Though singers who don’t write their own songs sometimes get less credit these days, Schwartz believes the interpretative part of a singer’s art—the ability to communicate the feeling in something written by another person—is just as important, and Sinatra’s ability to do that has meant that his music appeals emotionally to a range of audiences. “I don’t think he was in command of other parts of his life,” Schwartz says, referring to Sinatra’s tumultuous personal life, “but he was in command of his feelings and his entire being when he was singing.”

Differentiating himself from the singers of the 1940s wasn’t the only way that Sinatra capitalized on changing times.

In the 1940s, the recording industry was structured around people Schwartz compares to short-story writers, who released 78-rpm records with one song on each side. And, for about a decade of his career, that was what Sinatra did too. Long-playing 33 1/3-rpm records did exist, but they hadn’t made inroads into a market where most consumers only owned the equipment to play 78s. By the mid-1950s, that had changed, and 33 1/3 records were everywhere. That changing technology allowed Frank Sinatra to take his interpretative singing to the next level, as he controlled not just the delivery of a song but also the full arc of an LP.

“He sequenced the songs so that it played like a novel, not just a bunch of short stories,” Schwartz says. “It’s not only Sinatra [the singer] but his taste in songs — every album that Sinatra made is a Sinatra album, right down to the covers.”

And at least according to Schwartz, it also helped that the music of the 1940s and ‘50s was just plain good—“It was the music of the streets, only it was beautiful,” he says.

But these elements alone don’t fully explain the Sinatra phenomenon. Asked why he thinks it’s likely that nobody will ever be as good as Frank Sinatra was, Schwartz pauses.

“Why,” he asks, “was there one Babe Ruth?”

Read TIME's full commemorative Frank Sinatra issue from 1998, here in the TIME Vault

History NewsletterStay on top of the history behind today’s news. View Sample

Best of Frank Sinatra

25 year old Frank Sinatra poised at mike, singing As Time Goes By at Riobamba nightclub, 1943.
25-year-old Frank Sinatra poised at the microphone, singing "As Time Goes By" at the Riobamba nightclub, 1943.Herbert Gehr—The LIFE Images Collection/Getty Images
25 year old Frank Sinatra poised at mike, singing As Time Goes By at Riobamba nightclub, 1943.
Frank Sinatra with wife Nancy and 3 yr-old daughter Nancy home, 1943.
Frank Sinatra singing Close to You in CBS radio broadcasting studio as his admirer Rita Stearns, the winner of the Why I Like Frank Sinatra contest, looks on, in the audience, 1944.
Frank Sinatra singing "Five Minutes More," 1946.
Ethel Merman and Frank Sinatra singing duet Your the Top in preliminary rehearsal for Anything Goes presented on TV show The Colgate Comedy Hour, 1954.
Frank Sinatra and Donna Reed (R) holding Oscars while posing w. presenter, actress Mercedes McCambridge, for Best Supporting Actors in the movie "From Here to Eternity" at the 26th Annual Academy Awards Ceremony, 1954.
Frank Sinatra singing to Vivian Blaine in scene from film "Guys and Dolls," 1955.
Dean Martin and Frank Sinatra, 1958.
Director Frank Sinatra during filming of movie None But The Brave, 1964.
Nancy Sinatra with father, Frank Sinatra, during producing and directing of movie "None But The Brave," 1964.
Frank Sinatra with girlfriend Mia Farrow on deck of yacht Southern Breeze, 1965.
Frank Sinatra 1965.
Frank Sinatra giving musicians of the Count Basie Band direction at a rehearsal in an LA sound stage. Count Basie is playing on the piano, 1965.
Frank Sinatra relaxing with pet dog Ringo at home, 1965.
Sammy Davis Jr. talking with singer Frank Sinatra at his farewell peformance, at UCLA, 1971.
Frank Sinatra waves at the camera during a rehearsal for a MPTRF benefit, 1971.
25-year-old Frank Sinatra poised at the microphone, singing "As Time Goes By" at the Riobamba nightclub, 1943.
Herbert Gehr—The LIFE Images Collection/Getty Images
1 of 16
TIME may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.