Watch Black Simon and Garfunkel Sing ‘Can’t Feel My Face’ With the Real Art Garfunkel on The Tonight Show

Art Garfunkel made a surprise appearance on Wednesday night’s episode of The Tonight Show, joining Black Simon and Garfunkel for a folk rendition of “Can’t Feel My Face.”

Previously covering “Bad Blood” and “Royals,” Questlove and Captain Kirk Douglas have perfected the Black Simon and Garfunkel routine, all the way from the harmonies to the look. And though he’s no longer sporting the hair, the real Garfunkel is still on point as well.

Watch the clip above to see Black Simon and Garfunkel and Garfunkel.

This article originally appeared on EW.com