Dorothy Day
Dorothy Day inside the Worker office at 175 Christie St. in New York City in 1965. NY Daily News / Getty Images

Why Pope Francis Cited Dorothy Day and Thomas Merton

Sep 24, 2015

In speaking to Congress on Thursday, Pope Francis demonstrated that he’d brushed up on his American history in advance of his historic visit to the U.S. In mentioning a few famous Americans whose lives could serve as inspirations as the world navigates current crises, he turned to two obvious choices—Abraham Lincoln and Martin Luther King—and two whose names might be unfamiliar to those less versed in the history of American religion: Dorothy Day and Thomas Merton.

So who were they?

Dorothy Day was the founder of the Catholic Worker Movement, who used her faith to work for social justice. In 1940, TIME noted that, “Among U. S. Christians who care for the poor, none are more blessed with selfless zeal than those Roman Catholics who labor in the Catholic Worker movement.”

When she died in 1980, TIME explained that her take on Catholic activism was anything but uncontroversial:

To admirers like Historian David J. O'Brien, writing in Commonweal, she was "the most significant, interesting and influential person in the history of American Catholicism." If so, it is because her Catholic Worker movement blended zeal for reforming the whole social system with practical concern for helping the individual poor. She was arrested a dozen times, the first as a suffragette in 1917, the last during a workers' demonstration in California in 1973, and took part in scores of labor and antimilitary protests.

Though she was raised Episcopalian and became an agnostic in her youth, as she “took a Marxist lover, joined the young labor movement and wrote for far-left newspapers like the Masses,” a relationship and the birth of her daughter led to the church. In the 1930s, in the depths of the Depression, she launched the periodical The Catholic Worker and a philosophy to go along with it: pro-union, anti-poverty, pacifist, anti-government. She even went so far as to refer to it as anarchism, believing that individuals could be empowered to do good on their own.

Pope Francis sits on board his plane bound for Rome after his six-day visit to the United States, in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, September 27, 2015. REUTERS/Charles Mostoller TPX IMAGES OF THE DAY
Pope Francis sits on board his Rome-bound plane after his visit to the U.S. in Philadelphia, on Sept. 27, 2015.Charles Mostoller—Reuters
Pope Francis sits on board his plane bound for Rome after his six-day visit to the United States, in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, September 27, 2015. REUTERS/Charles Mostoller TPX IMAGES OF THE DAY
A man looks at a television screen showing Pope Francis taking a pause as he celebrates mass at the Festival of Families Sunday mass along Benjamin Franklin Parkway in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
A man holds a child as Pope Francis celebrates Mass, Sunday, Sept. 27, 2015, in Philadelphia. (AP Photo/Matt Slocum)
Pope Francis conducts a papal mass on the final day of events in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
People without tickets watch on video screens, miles away from the altar and the secured area surrounding it, as Pope Francis celebrates mass in Philadelphia
Pope Francis waves to the crowd from the pope mobile during a parade along the Benjamin Franklin Parkway before Mass on Sunday, Sept. 27, 2015, in Philadelphia (AP Photo/Michael Perez)
US Pope Francis
APTOPIX US Pope Francis
US Pope Francis
US Pope Francis
Pope Francis
Pope Francis
Pope Francis
Nuns wait for Pope Francis' arrival at the Festival of Families rally along Benjamin Franklin Parkway in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Pope Francis, Michael Keating
APTOPIX US Pope Francis
APTOPIX US Pope Francis
Pope Francis Rides In Motorcade Through New York's Central Park
APTOPIX US Pope Francis
Pope Francis US Visit
Pope Francis US Visit World Trade Center
Pope Francis US Visit United Nations
US-VATICAN-RELIGION-POPE
People in the crowds outside of St. Patrick's Cathedral take pictures in New York
Pope Francis
US-VATICAN-RELIGION-POPE
US-VATICAN-RELIGION-POPE
Pope Francis US Visit Congress
Pope Francis US Visit Congress
Pope Francis US Visit Congress
Pope Francis US Visit Congress
Pope Francis US Visit Congress
Pope Francis US Visit mass Canonization
Pope Francis US Visit mass Canonization
Pope Francis US Visit mass Canonization
Pope Francis US Visit National Mall
Pope Francis US Visit National Mall
Pope Francis US Visit National Mall
Pope Francis US Visit White House
Pope Francis US Visit White House
Pope Francis US Visit White House
Pope Francis US Visit White House
Pope Francis US Visit White House
Pope Francis US Visit White House
Pope Francis US Visit White House
Pope Francis US Visit White House
Pope Francis US Visit White House
Pope Francis US Visit White House
Pope Francis US Visit
Pope Francis US Visit
Pope Francis US Visit
Pope Francis US Visit
President Barack Obama, first lady Michelle Obama, and others, greet Pope Francis upon his arrival at Andrews Air Force Base, Md., on Sept. 22, 2015.
Pope Francis US Visit
Pope Francis US Visit
Pope Francis US Visit
Pope Francis US Visit
Pope Francis US Visit
Pope Francis sits on board his Rome-bound plane after his visit to the U.S. in Philadelphia, on Sept. 27, 2015.
Charles Mostoller—Reuters
1 of 58

Merton, who came from a similarly non-Catholic background, became a Trappist monk and best-selling author who encouraged peace. As his 1968 TIME obituary made clear, his focus was parallel to Day's—he "found in the Word a command to do"—but it was through writing that he shared his philosophy with the world:

For 20 years Merton had been the most publicly visible Christian contemplative since St. Simeon Stylites took refuge on top of a pillar. Merton's pillar was print, and he had not exactly chosen it for himself. What he had chosen, at the age of 26 and as a new convert to Roman Catholicism, was the silent and anonymous life of the Trappist monks, who rise early, work hard, eat little and pray much. When he entered the Abbey of Our Lady of Gethsemani in Kentucky, however, his abbot decreed that Merton should continue writing—as he had since the age of ten. Merton was ordained a priest in 1949, the year after his first major book, The Seven Storey Mountain, had become a bestseller and thrust him permanently into a life of books, articles, poems and a massive correspondence with friends all over the world.

When The Seven Storey Mountain was first published, TIME called it a "perceptive, quietly stirring" reminder that "the most mystical human beings are often among the most practical as well."

While Day's activism was very much tied to the 1930s moment in which she got her start, with its focus on workers and soup kitchens, Merton's fit perfectly with the post-World War II world in which his autobiographical debut was published. Though Merton lived the life of a near-hermit for many years, he became fascinated by Zen Buddhism and Tibetan monastic practices right about when the Beatles did too, and he participated in protests against the Vietnam War.

Though their lives took very different paths, Day's and Merton's callings overlapped significantly, with a concentration on anti-poverty and pro-peace activism. In light of that parallel, one they share with another famous Catholic, it's no wonder Pope Francis would have mentioned their names—even if they're less famous than Lincoln and King.

Read Day’s full 1980 obituary, here in the TIME Vault: Street Saint

Read Merton's full 1968 obituary, here in the TIME Vault: The Death of Two Extraordinary Christians

Sign up for HISTORY and more. View Sample
June 16, 1924
Pope Pius XI on the June 16, 1924, cover of TIMETIME
June 16, 1924
Dec. 29, 1930
Apr. 3, 1933
Aug. 16, 1943
Dec. 14, 1953
Nov. 10, 1958
Oct. 5, 1962
Jan. 4, 1963
June 7, 1963
June 28, 1963
Sep. 24, 1965
Nov. 22, 1968
Sep. 4, 1978
Oct. 9, 1978
Oct. 30, 1978
June 18, 1979
Oct. 15, 1979
May 25, 1981
June 7, 1982
Mar. 14, 1983
June 27, 1983
Jan. 9, 1984
Feb. 4, 1985
Feb. 24, 1992
Dec. 26, 1994
Jan. 26, 1998
Apr. 3, 2000
Apr. 11, 2005
May 2, 2005
Nov. 27, 2006
Apr. 14, 2008
Feb. 25, 2013
Mar. 25, 2013
Dec. 23, 2013
Oct. 5, 2015
Pope Pius XI on the June 16, 1924, cover of TIME
TIME
1 of 35
All products and services featured are based solely on editorial selection. TIME may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.