Privacy setting shortcuts are displayed on Apple Inc. iPhone 6 smartphone screen.
Privacy setting shortcuts are displayed on Apple Inc. iPhone 6 smartphone screen. Bloomberg via Getty Images

What I Learned When I Lost My Internship at Facebook

Aug 19, 2015
Ideas
Aran Khanna is a student at Harvard University.

A few months ago, I was set to begin a summer internship at Facebook. As a rising senior at Harvard University — the same school where Facebook founder and CEO Mark Zuckerberg sat in his dorm room and wrote the social media giant’s code — I was thrilled at the prospect of joining the “hacker culture” of Facebook where “code wins arguments.”

That forward-thinking “hacker culture” is how Facebook started. Can you imagine if Zuckerberg had gone to the school administration to ask permission to build Facebook in his dorm room? Luckily, he didn’t need permission. He built it, and his code won.

Before receiving this internship, I had taken a class called Privacy and Technology, taught by Professors James Waldo and Latanya Sweeney. In the course, I learned to question technology and its role in people’s lives. My experiences in this class, along with my interest in Facebook’s products, led me to code and release the Marauder’s Map extension, a plugin that allowed users of the Facebook Messenger app to see the geolocations of the people they were messaging. I had discovered that the Messenger app on Android automatically shared the geolocations of those using it with every message sent unless the user explicitly turned geolocation off.

Check Out How Facebook’s Fancy New Digs Compare to Their Old HQ

An aerial of Facebook headquarters in Menlo Park CA on the San Francisco Bay.
Main Headquarters: An aerial of Facebook's headquarters in Menlo Park, CA on the San Francisco Bay.Steve Proehl—Corbis
An aerial of Facebook headquarters in Menlo Park CA on the San Francisco Bay.
An aerial view of Facebook's new campus, an expansion of its current headquarters in Menlo Park, Calif. The LEED-certified building, known as MPK 20, has a 9-acre "green roof."
Hack
The roof of the new campus contains a half-mile walking loop for employees and over 400 trees.
Buidling 10 stands on the Facebook Inc. campus in Menlo Park, California, U.S., on Dec. 2, 2011.
The new Facebook headquarters, known as MPK 20, opened this spring
Facebook employees are shown on the campus in Menlo Park, Calif., Friday, March 15, 2013.
The lobby of the new campus is entered from the roof.
A general view of the outdoor lunch and relaxtion area at the old Facebook main campus in Menlo Park, California on May 15, 2012.
A view of the MPK 20 roof at night, which is topped by a massive garden
A Facebook Inc. employee works on a laptop computer at the company's old campus in Menlo Park, California, U.S., on Dec. 2, 2011.
Facebook employees took to Instagram to show off parts of their new digs, such as this artwork in the MPK 20 building.
A Facebook employee walks past The Facebook Wall at the old Facebook headquarters in Menlo Park, Calif. on March 15, 2013.
Colorful artwork adorns many of the walls at Facebook's new campus.
The desk is staffed inside the lobby area of the old Facebook Inc. campus in Menlo Park, California, U.S., on Dec. 2, 2011.
The Frank Ghery-designed staircases are designed to be bring in lots of natural light, as opposed to the claustrophobic stairwells of traditional office buildings
Main Headquarters: An aerial of Facebook's headquarters in Menlo Park, CA on the San Francisco Bay.
Steve Proehl—Corbis
1 of 16

Was the open sharing of personal locations a feature or a privacy issue? In the spirit of "hacker culture," I attempted to answer this question with code, and wrote a post on Medium about my findings. This wasn’t a new concern: In 2012, CNET had brought this issue to Facebook's and the public’s attention. My app wasn’t exploiting any trade secrets or breaking into anything. My app did nothing other than read data that was already on your screen and display it on a map (something anyone could do with a piece of paper, a pencil, and a little bit of time). For what it's worth, Facebook disagreed, saying I violated the site's user agreement by utilizing data taken from the site in my app.

I expected the blog post to circulate among a close circle of friends and maybe cause some people to take a second look at their location settings. To my surprise, the blog post resonated with people, and it spread quickly. Facebook took notice. An employee from the company asked me not to speak with the press and to deactivate the extension, which I did. I was both shocked and disappointed when a Facebook HR representative called the day before I was supposed to start my summer internship, after I had already moved to California, to inform me that my offer was being rescinded.

Shortly after, Facebook issued an update that reversed the way geolocation sharing worked on Facebook Messenger. Now, a person’s geolocation displays only if she actively elects to share it. (A spokesperson for Facebook told the press that the company had been working on this fix for some time.)

This episode has been an incredible learning opportunity, shedding light on how big tech firms respond to privacy issues and how that response may hurt users of their products. This was my main reason for publicly documenting this experience in my academic paper in the Harvard journal Technology Science.

So much of our lives have shifted online so quickly that it is not always clear how much data we are making accessible to others. This is made even more problematic by the fact that the companies tasked with holding and distributing our data are often incentivized to make us reveal as much as possible, while providing just enough privacy controls to ensure users don’t leave their platforms. Moving forward, will companies like Facebook be more aware of privacy concerns and more proactive in patching them? Or must we continue to rely on privacy guardians affecting change from the outside?

Read next: Mark Zuckerberg’s 3 Best Quotes on Facebook’s Future

Download TIME’s mobile app for iOS to have your world explained wherever you go


Ideas
TIME Ideas hosts the world's leading voices, providing commentary on events in news, society, and culture. We welcome outside contributions. Opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect the views of TIME editors.
All products and services featured are based solely on editorial selection. TIME may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.